# Karthago — Property & WEG Management

Karthago by Karthago Systeme GmbH holds a panel rating of 1.5/5 from 6 AI judges (category median 1/5), as of 2026-11-18. Provenance: EU-Made; sovereignty: 2 of 6 dimensions proven.

- Vendor: Karthago Systeme GmbH (https://www.karthago.de)
- Category: [Property & WEG Management](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management.md)
- Provenance (editorial classification): EU-Made
- Canonical page: https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/karthago
- Alternatives: https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/karthago/alternatives ([markdown](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/karthago/alternatives.md))
- Data as of: 2026-11-21 · evaluated 2026-11-18 · oldest source captured 2026-09-15

**AI-generated.** Every score, rationale and verdict here is written by a panel of AI judges from public evidence — an analysis, not a hands-on test. Every fact quotes the vendor page it was read from. No score can be bought. How scores are made: https://whats-best.ai/methodology

## At a glance

- Vendor: Karthago Systeme GmbH
- Headquarters: Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
- Data hosting: In the EU [S1]
- Free plan: Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026

## The panel's verdict

Karthago is ERP software from Karthago Systeme GmbH for mid-sized and large administrations of WEG and rental properties, with 30 years of development. Weighted verdicts run from 2.9 to 3.6. It is strongest on WEG accounting, scoring 3-4: the published module list names double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and a WEG and utility settlement module, and the lower marks reflect pages that stop at module names, with no public information on the business plan, distribution keys or reserve-fund handling. Sovereignty scores 3-4, resting on German servers with certified data protection stated for the cloud and a genuine on-premise option; we found no public information on a data processing agreement, a subprocessor list or the contracting entity's jurisdiction. Weakest is assembly and resolutions, scored 0 — no public information appears on convening owners' meetings, recording votes or maintaining a resolution register. Owner self-service spans 0-2, the widest spread in the scores. No price figure appears on the pages we read; cost comes only through a consultation form asking for managed units and required workstations.

**Speaks for it:**
- Named modules for double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and WEG and utility settlement; WEG accounting scores 3-4.
- Aimed at mid-sized and large administrations of WEG and rental properties, with 30 years of development.
- German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud variant; sovereignty scores 3-4.
- An on-premise installation is offered that, in the vendor's words, keeps all data and systems in your hands.
- Integrated document management and digital facility management are named modules, scoring 3 and 2-3.

**Held against it:**
- Assembly and resolutions scored 0 — we found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes or maintaining a resolution register.
- Owner self-service scored 0-2 — we found no public information on a portal, personal logins, statements on demand or owner-side defect reporting.
- WEG accounting stops at 3-4 because the pages give module names only, with no public information on the business plan, distribution keys or reserve-fund handling.
- Maintenance and defects scored 2-3 — we found no public information on defect tickets, contractor assignment or statutory inspections with stored proof.
- We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods or a handover package, nor on a data processing agreement, subprocessor list or the contracting entity's jurisdiction.

**Best for:**
- You run a mid-sized or large administration of WEG and rental properties and want bookkeeping and the settlement cycle inside one ERP.
- You want the choice between a cloud stated to run on German servers and an on-premise installation on your own infrastructure.
- You are prepared to verify settlement depth, assembly functions and owner portal capabilities in a consultation rather than from public pages.

**Avoid if:**
- You need owners'-meeting functions — convening, voting, the resolution register — documented publicly before a shortlist.
- You need an owner or tenant self-service portal with personal logins evidenced in public material.
- You need settlement depth — business plan, distribution keys, reserve-fund handling — publicly documented before signing.
- You must show a successor administrator a structured handover export, or evidence statutory inspections, before committing.

## Scores by judge and criterion

Scores out of 5, each judge scoring independently against the published rubric (v2). "n/r" = not rated: the vendor publishes no price, or the judge found no public information on that criterion.

| Criterion | The WEG Administrator | The Advisory Board Member | The Accountant | The Portfolio Manager | The Data Protection Officer | The Skeptic |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage | 2/5 | 2/5 | 1.5/5 | 2/5 | 2/5 | 1.5/5 |
| Eigentümerversammlung & Beschluss-Sammlung | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r |
| Owner & tenant self-service | 1/5 | 1/5 | n/r | 1/5 | n/r | n/r |
| Maintenance, defects & contractors | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1/5 | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1/5 |
| Documents, retention & handover | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 | 1.5/5 |
| European sovereignty | 2/5 | 2/5 | 1.5/5 | 2/5 | 2/5 | 2/5 |
| Pricing transparency | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r | n/r |
| **Weighted verdict** | **1.5/5** | **1.5/5** | **1.5/5** | **1.5/5** | **2/5** | **1.5/5** |

### The judges

- **The WEG Administrator** (v1.0): Manages forty communities and personally carries the duties the WEG places on the Verwalter. Wants the statutory year — Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung, Versammlung, Beschluss-Sammlung — discharged inside one system. Judges a product by the March settlement run, not the demo.
- **The Advisory Board Member** (v1.0): An owner, elected and unpaid, who checks the administrator's settlement before recommending it to the assembly — and is answerable to the neighbours if it is wrong. Wants to see the underlying records without asking, the resolution register current, and arithmetic that can be followed back to an invoice.
- **The Accountant** (v1.0): Prepares the settlement and answers for its form. Cares that the Abrechnungsspitze is shown separately, that the Rücklage is genuinely segregated trust money rather than a labelled balance, and that heating costs apportion per HeizkostenV without a spreadsheet.
- **The Portfolio Manager** (v1.0): Runs a firm managing several thousand units and lives on throughput. Wants statutory inspections scheduled with proof stored, defects that route to the right trade, multi-community reporting, and onboarding a new WEG that takes days rather than a quarter.
- **The Data Protection Officer** (v1.0): The system holds names, addresses, bank details and arrears for people who never chose the vendor. Wants owner and tenant visibility strictly separated, an access log over the archive, retention that executes, and an answer on where the AI invoice reader sends a document.
- **The Skeptic** (v1.0): Has read many pages claiming "WEG-konform" and wants the feature that makes it true — the post-2021 settlement form, the maintained Beschluss-Sammlung, the majority arithmetic. Also reads for the per-unit minimum, the setup fee, and what it costs a community to leave with its own records.

## European sovereignty — proven facts

Built only from facts on the vendor's own pages; a dimension we could not prove is left open, never scored as zero. Headline: 2 of 6 dimensions proven.

| Dimension | Finding | Points | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal entity | Not determined | — | — |
| Hosting location | EU only | 4/4 | [S1] |
| Hosting options | Self-hostable | 1/1 | [S1] |
| Open source | Not determined | — | — |
| Data processing agreement | Not determined | — | — |
| Transfer impact assessment | Not determined | — | — |

## Key facts

Each fact is the vendor's own statement, cited to the source page it was read from ([S*n*] → Sources).

**Compliance**
- Complaint procedure lksg: Beschwerdeverfahren nach § 8 LkSG mit öffentlich zugänglicher Verfahrensordnung [S4]
- Employee code of conduct: Code of Conduct für Mitarbeitende der Aareon-Gruppe [S4]
- GDPR supplier notice: yes [S4]
- Supplier code of conduct: Code of Conduct für Lieferanten, inkl. Bewertung ökologischer, sozialer und ethischer Nachhaltigkeit bei Lieferantenauswahl [S4]
- Whistleblowing languages: Deutsch · Englisch · Französisch · Niederländisch · Schwedisch · Spanisch [S4]
- Whistleblowing provider: LegalTegrity · Deutschland [S4]
- Whistleblowing system: Hinweisgebersystem (Whistleblowing-System) von Aareon [S4]

**Hosting**
- Cloud available: yes [S1]
- Cloud available: Keine Hardwarekosten · schnelle Bereitstellung · maximale Ausfallsicherheit · yes [S3]
- Cloud data residency: yes [S1]
- Cloud region: Deutschland · yes [S3]
- Cloud region: Deutschland · yes [S3]
- Cloud region: Germany · yes [S2]
- Data residency: Germany · yes [S2]
- On premise available: local installation, customer controls infrastructure and costs [S1]
- On premise available: Offline-Verfügbarkeit · keine Mietkosten · vollständige Systemsicherheit · yes [S3]
- On premise benefits: yes [S1]

**Legal**
- Copyright holder: Aareon 2026 [S2]
- Entity name: Aareon Group GmbH [S4]
- Vendor: Aareon [S3]
- Vendor: Aareon [S3]
- Vendor: Aareon [S2]

**Product**
- Cloud available: no hardware costs · fast provisioning · high availability · yes [S2]
- Company tenure: 30 [S3]
- Consultation contact form: yes · Vorname · Nachname · Unternehmensname · Telefonnummer · E-Mail · Straße Hausnummer · PLZ Ort · Verwaltete Einheiten · Benötigte Arbeitsplätze [S3]
- Consultation form fields: first name · last name · company name · phone · email · street · postal code/city · managed units · required workstations [S2]
- Deployment cloud: Cloud-Lösung ohne lokale Installation; Updates, Wartung und Backups inklusive [S3]
- Deployment cloud: no local installation; vendor handles updates, maintenance, backups [S2]
- Deployment on premise: On-Premise Desktop-Installation; Offline-Verfügbarkeit, keine Mietkosten, vollständige Systemsicherheit [S3]
- Deployment on premise: local installation; customer controls infrastructure and costs; offline availability, no rental costs [S2]
- Experience years: 30 [S2]
- Modules: rental & WEG property management · master data management · double-entry accounting · automated invoice import · integrated document management · WEG & utility cost billing · digital facility management · reporting [S1]
- Modules: Stammdaten, Doppelte Buchhaltung, Automatisierter Rechnungsimport, Integriertes Dokumentenmanagement, WEG- & Nebenkostenabrechnung, Digitales Facility Management, Auswertungen [S3]
- Modules: master data management · double-entry accounting · automated invoice import · integrated document management · WEG and utility cost accounting · digital facility management · reporting [S2]
- Modules: Stammdaten · Doppelte Buchhaltung · Automatisierter Rechnungsimport · Integriertes Dokumentenmanagement · WEG- & Nebenkostenabrechnung · Digitales Facility Management · Auswertungen [S3]
- On premise available: offline availability · no rental costs · full system security · yes [S2]
- Processes: master data management, billing/settlement, owner and tenant communication in one solution [S2]
- Rental and condo management: rental property management · condominium (special ownership) management [S2]
- Scope: central platform covering master data, billing/accounting and communication with owners and tenants in one solution [S1]
- Scope: Zentrale Plattform für Immobilienmanagement; alle Prozesse in einer Lösung [S3]
- Supports rental and condo ownership: yes [S1]
- Target market: ERP software for mid-sized and large property management firms, flexible for WEG and rental properties [S2]
- Target market: ERP-Software für mittelständische und große Verwaltungen, für WEG und Mietobjekte [S3]
- Target segment: ERP software for mid-sized and large property management companies, for WEG and rental properties [S1]
- Target segment: WEG (con homeowners) · rental property management · mid-sized · large [S2]
- Target segments: WEG · Mietobjekte · mittelstand · gross [S3]

**Support**
- Teamviewer: TeamViewer listed as support offering [S1]

## Questions

### Is Karthago European?

Yes. whats-best.ai classifies Karthago as EU-Made.

### Where does Karthago store data?

Karthago stores customer data in the EU, per [the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026](https://whats-best.ai/evidence/922).

### Does Karthago have a free plan?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026.

### What are the best alternatives to Karthago?

As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates [Condomana (3.5/5)](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/condomana), [Immoware24 (3/5)](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/immoware24) and [etg24 (2.5/5)](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/etg24) highest among the other 27 Property & WEG Management products evaluated. The highest-rated European alternative is [Condomana](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/condomana) (EU-Made, Germany). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: [how scores are made](https://whats-best.ai/methodology#ordering). The full list, with European products first: [Karthago alternatives](https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/karthago/alternatives).

## Head-to-head

- [Karthago vs DOMUS](https://whats-best.ai/compare/domus-software-vs-karthago.md)

## What this page leaves out

- We could not confirm any pricing information on the vendor’s own pages as captured, so this page shows none rather than a statement we cannot stand behind.
- 7 product facts could not be confirmed on the vendor’s page as captured and were left out of this page and of the panel’s material.
- 2 compliance facts could not be confirmed on the vendor’s page as captured and were left out of this page and of the panel’s material.
- 1 data fact could not be confirmed on the vendor’s page as captured and was left out of this page and of the panel’s material.
- 1 sovereignty dimension could not be confirmed on the vendor’s own pages and is shown as unknown.

## Sources

- [S1] Vendor homepage: https://www.karthago.de/ (checked 2026-11-16)
- [S2] Imprint: https://www.karthago.de/impressum (checked 2026-11-16)
- [S3] Privacy policy: https://www.karthago.de/datenschutz (checked 2026-11-16)
- [S4] Security / trust page: https://www.aareon.de/compliance (checked 2026-11-16)

---

Cite as: whats-best.ai, "Karthago — Property & WEG Management", AI panel analysis, as of 2026-11-21. https://whats-best.ai/software/property-management/karthago

Corrections: https://whats-best.ai/correct/244?target=page
