As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates ISMS.online 3/5 and verinice 2.5/5 in Information Security. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick ISMS.online and 0 pick verinice. ISMS.online scores higher on 3 of 5 criteria (Audit readiness & evidence, Controls, SoA & measures and Framework & standard coverage). verinice scores higher on 2 of 5 criteria (Asset & risk management depth and European sovereignty). Provenance — ISMS.online: UK / wider Europe, United Kingdom; verinice: EU-Made, Germany. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The benches split by criterion, not by product. ISMS.online leads integrations and automation 7.3 to 0.0 (we found no public information on an API, connectors or single sign-on for verinice), audit readiness 6.7 to 3.2, and controls and statement of applicability 6.5 to 4.2 — 6 judges lean ISMS.online, 0 verinice, on those three criteria — with framework coverage at 8.0 to 7.2 (4 lean ISMS.online, 2 ties). Verinice leads information security management 7.8 to 5.7 and pricing transparency 4.7 to 0.0, both at 6 lean verinice; ISMS.online publishes no prices, and pricing is not weighted in its verdict. Weighted totals favor ISMS.online, from 6.8 versus 4.8 on the lead-auditor bench to 5.7 versus 4.7 on the skeptic bench. Sovereignty runs 4.5 to 3.7, 3 lean verinice, 3 ties: verinice is a DE entity, self-hostable, copyleft; ISMS.online is a GB entity with selectable EU hosting; data residency is unknown for both.
Choose ISMS.online if
You need ready-made connectors to Jira, ServiceNow, Slack and Microsoft, plus control monitors that surface Entra MFA status without manual screenshots — integrations and automation stands 7.3 to 0.0, with 6 judges leaning ISMS.online.
Your team faces a heavy external-audit calendar — audit readiness stands 6.7 to 3.2 with 6 judges leaning ISMS.online, and the lead-auditor bench's weighted total is 6.8 to 4.8.
You maintain compliance across many frameworks at once — a claimed catalogue of over 100 frameworks and a documented SOC 2-to-ISO 27001 crosswalk extended to GDPR and NIST put framework coverage at 8.0 to 7.2 (4 lean ISMS.online, 2 ties).
Your GRC team works day to day in controls and the statement of applicability — that criterion stands 6.5 to 4.2, 6 judges lean ISMS.online.
You are comfortable contracting under a UK legal entity and want EU hosting as a selectable choice among UK, EU, APAC and US data centres, with Germany primary and Sweden backup.
Choose verinice if
You build your ISMS on the BSI Standards 200-1 to 200-3 methodology or the German NIS2 implementation law — information security management stands 7.8 to 5.7 with 6 judges leaning verinice, and the 24-hour, 72-hour and one-month NIS2 reporting deadlines are documented in its incident workflows.
Your asset model requires protection needs to inherit automatically across asset relations — verinice documents this; for ISMS.online we found no public information on it.
You must self-host on-premises or require open source — verinice is self-hostable and copyleft under A-GPL, with a German legal entity.
You need published prices to budget against — three bundles carry public from-prices, including 'ISO 27001 Bundle from 5.750 € / year', and pricing transparency stands 4.7 to 0.0 with 6 judges leaning verinice.
Your framework scope is the German market stack — NIS2, GDPR, Grundschutz, ISO 27001, BCM and TISAX are verinice's six domains, with the German NIS2 implementation-law deviations integrated.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The CISO
Owns the ISO 27001 certificate and the NIS2 exposure of a 400-employee company. Optimizes for a real risk backbone: methodology, inheritance, incident clocks, a statement of applicability that is never stale. Rejects checklist theater and risk registers that cannot answer who accepted what.
ISMS.online
This judge's pick
verinice
Criterion by criterion
Asset & risk management depth
ISMS.online
The asset bank feeding an inventory, a dynamic risk register with treatment, and a genuinely configurable risk map — five levels by default, additive, multiplicative or sequential scoring, review periods set per risk level — plus incidents synced in from Jira make this a workable ISMS core. To go higher I would need a documented risk methodology of the ISO 27005 or BSI 200-3 class, protection needs inherited across asset relations, the NIS2 24h/72h clocks inside the incident workflow, or risk acceptance with named owners, and we found no public information on any of these.
verinice
The risk backbone is documented and it is the one I certify against: BSI Standards 200-1/200-2/200-3 with automatic inheritance of protection needs across asset relations, an NIS2 incident clock of notification after 24 hours, situation report after 72 hours and final report after one month, and continuity through BSI 200-4 and ISO 22301. I found no public information on risk acceptance with a named owner, so "who accepted what" remains unproven on these pages — that gap keeps it short of the top.
Controls, SoA & measures
ISMS.online
Controls are wired to risks and evidence through a documented risk-to-control-to-evidence chain, policies and measures carry version history, approval workflow, owners and review reminders, and Annex A content is regularly updated with live signals on named controls like A.5.15 — a living fabric rather than checklist theater. I hold it below the top because we found no public information on measure delegation and escalation, or on a statement of applicability generated from live control status rather than maintained by hand.
verinice
Requirements, measures, threats and risks are first-class object types with dedicated input masks, backed by an implementation and audit plan and TOM management — a real Grundschutz control fabric rather than a checklist. I found no public information on a generated statement of applicability, on owners and due dates for measures, or on evidence attached to each control, which is exactly where a stale SoA would bite me in an audit.
Framework & standard coverage
ISMS.online
Over a hundred frameworks and regulations run on one data basis, with a documented crosswalk aligning SOC 2 to ISO 27001 Annex A and extended to GDPR and NIST, NIS 2 and ISO 22301 named in the catalogue, and published updates plus transition content when ISO 27001 moved from 2013 to 2022. We found no public information on TISAX, DORA or BSI IT-Grundschutz, which is precisely the coverage my own market exposure would demand.
verinice
The regimes are all there for a German-EU buyer — IT-Grundschutz under a BSI licence, ISO 27001 under an ISO licence, TISAX, NIS2 with the German implementation law's deviations integrated, plus ISO 22301 and the 27000 series including 27005 — and the documented ISO 27001 certification path on the basis of IT-Grundschutz shows one data basis serving two regimes. I found no public information on DORA or on a published cadence for updates when a standard moves.
Audit readiness & evidence
ISMS.online
Immutable audit trails with rigorous version control, forensic histories, systematically timestamped evidence per control, and exportable consolidated reporting including a dual quantitative-and-qualitative audit window — this is defensible proof, not merely current state. We found no public information on read-only auditor access, on-demand evidence packs as a defined artefact, or reproducing any record as it stood on a given date.
verinice
What is documented is outcome, not machinery: an ISO 27001 certification and a BSI Testat in Basis-Absicherung are achievable with the tool, supported by an implementation and audit plan and a partner network for certifications and audits. I found no public information on revision-safe change history, evidence packs generated on demand, read-only auditor access, or management report generators — the proof machinery itself is undocumented.
Integrations & automation
ISMS.online
A documented public API with practical examples, ready-made Jira, ServiceNow, Slack and Microsoft connectors, Zapier, single sign-on, and control performance monitors surfacing Entra MFA status and live signals inside the platform — the monitoring actually replaces manual screenshots and IT chasing. We found no public information on REST coverage of the core objects, webhooks, or SCIM provisioning, so it does not reach infrastructure grade.
verinice
I found no public information on single sign-on, a documented API, directory, CMDB, ticketing or scanner connectors, or import and export for the platform; the only automation the captured pages show is the automatic inheritance of protection needs inside the ISMS model, which does not feed from the live estate. This criterion is reported as unevidenced rather than scored on capability.
European sovereignty
ISMS.online
Alliantist Ltd contracts under England and Wales with a UK private-equity majority owner, customers choose among UK, EU (Germany primary, Sweden backup), APAC and US data centres, and a data processing agreement, published subprocessor lists and transfer mechanisms exist — EU hosting is an option rather than a stated default. The published lists include US processors such as Google, Microsoft, OpenAI and Stripe, support staff in the Philippines may access personal data, and the ICO is the supervisory authority, so the chain is not European end to end; we found no public information on processor-role subprocessors specific to customer platform content.
verinice
A German contracting entity in Göttingen, a published data processing agreement (AV-Vertrag) and Art. 32 GDPR technical and organisational measures, an A-GPL open-source product and a self-operated on-premises option — that is jurisdictional substance I can put in front of my board. Against that, the captured pages give two names for the responsible party (SerNet GmbH and SerNet Service Network GmbH), I found no public information on where verinice.cloud is hosted, and the published subprocessors are website-level (Matomo, PayPal, Stripe) rather than a list for the product itself.
Pricing transparency
ISMS.online
The vendor states that pricing is bespoke and discussed on a demo call, and no price, edition, seat or scale figure appears on any captured page. A buyer cannot compute even a fragment of the invoice from public information; every configuration is a sales conversation.
verinice
Public annual from-prices with the inclusions spelled out — the ISO 27001 Bundle "from 5.750 € / year", the IT-Grundschutz Bundle "from 5.750 € / year", ISO + IT-Grundschutz "from 8.530 € / year" — plus 60-day free evaluations and named purchase portals for cloud and on-prem. I found no public information on the price of the standalone NIS2 subscription and the additional modules, on user or entity boundaries, setup fees, or VAT treatment, so the real invoice for my size of company is not yet computable.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
ISMS.online
verinice
Legal entity
Incorporated in GB
Incorporated in DE
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
EU region selectable
Self-hostable
Open source
Not determined
Open source (copyleft)
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates ISMS.online higher: 3/5 against 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick ISMS.online and 0 pick verinice. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is ISMS.online or verinice European?
ISMS.online is European (UK / wider Europe, United Kingdom). verinice is European (EU-Made, Germany). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.