As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Evalanche 2/5 and Mautic 1.5/5 in Marketing Automation. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 4 of the 6 judges pick Evalanche and 2 pick Mautic. Evalanche scores higher on 5 of 6 criteria (Consent, tracking & profiling, European sovereignty, CRM integration & data model, plus 2 more). Mautic scores higher on 1 of 6 criteria (Journeys & orchestration). Provenance — Evalanche: EU-Made, Germany; Mautic: Rest of world, United Kingdom. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The computed table has Evalanche ahead on five criteria, each with 4 judges leaning its way to Mautic's 2: consent and profiling (4.5 to 2.0), sovereignty (4.2 to 2.0), CRM and data (3.7 to 2.2), channel coverage (4.0 to 3.0), and lead management (3.8 to 3.7). Journey orchestration is the genuine split: Mautic holds the higher mean, 4.0 to 3.8, while 4 judges lean Evalanche and 2 lean Mautic. Pricing transparency goes to Mautic 6 judges to 0, means 4.2 to 1.2, and carries no weight in the verdicts. Per-judge weighted totals favor Evalanche for 4 judges, Mautic for 2; Evalanche's totals of 0 for the sales operations and lifecycle marketing judges are unexplained by the table. Sovereignty attributes list Evalanche's data residency as EU-only with SaaS-only hosting, and Mautic's hosting as self-hostable with data residency unknown.
Choose Evalanche if
You need documented consent and profiling: consent and profiling stands at 4.5 for Evalanche against 2.0 for Mautic, with 4 judges leaning Evalanche; the verdict cites logged double opt-in entries with timestamps and pseudonymised tracking.
Your compliance posture points to EU custody: Evalanche's sovereignty attributes record data residency as EU-only and legal jurisdiction in Germany, and sovereignty scores 4.2 to Mautic's 2.0.
Your team already runs SAP, Salesforce, Microsoft or a German mid-market CRM: CRM and data reads 3.7 to 2.2, with 4 judges leaning Evalanche on those connectors.
You need campaigns spanning email, SMS, social media and print: channel coverage is 4.0 to Mautic's 3.0, with 4 judges leaning Evalanche.
Your data protection officer signs off on the purchase: that judge's weighted total reads 6.3 for Evalanche against 2.3 for Mautic.
Choose Mautic if
You need cost visible before committing: pricing transparency goes to Mautic 6 judges to 0, means 4.2 to 1.2; captured pages describe the software as free to download and use, with a 14-day trial that needs no credit card.
You must run the software on your own infrastructure: Mautic's sovereignty attributes record hosting as self-hostable, where Evalanche's record SaaS only.
Your reference point is the panel's mean for journey building: Mautic holds 4.0 to Evalanche's 3.8 on journey orchestration, on a drag-and-drop campaign builder with lead nurturing from capture to conversion.
Your sales operations or lifecycle marketing judge drives the decision: those weighted totals read 2.6 and 3.2 for Mautic against 0 for Evalanche.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Lifecycle Marketer
Thinks in cohorts and retention rather than in campaigns. Wants frequency capping across every journey, holdout groups so the effect is measurable, and personalisation drawn from the behavioural record rather than assembled by hand.
Evalanche
Mautic
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Journeys & orchestration
Evalanche
The campaign designer pages show condition-driven journeys with behaviour triggers on clicks and page visits, waits between steps (a two-day wait is the documented example), split nodes with automated A/B testing, and scoring results used as trigger conditions that can hand a lead to the CRM or start a further campaign. I found no public information on frequency capping or suppression across journeys, on what happens when a contact qualifies for several at once, or on holdout groups and versioning — the parts that make a programme measurable rather than merely automated.
Mautic
The captured pages document a drag-and-drop Campaign Builder for "automation at every touch point" and lead nurturing "from capture to conversion", which evidences multi-step automation without detailing triggers, branching, waits or exit conditions. We found no public information on frequency capping across journeys, priority when a contact qualifies for several at once, or holdout groups for measurement — the controls that decide whether a programme scales safely.
Lead scoring, routing & lifecycle
Evalanche
Implicit activity scoring and explicit profile scoring are configurable, presettable with default values, mapped in a scoring matrix, and leads count as sales-ready at grade A or B; routing then happens by automated reporting email to the sales lead or through the CRM interface, with handed-over leads removed from running campaigns. I found no public information on negative scoring, score decay, account-level scoring, per-contact score history, or any explanation of each signal's contribution.
Mautic
Customizable lead scoring is the one published capability, described as helping to "identify and focus on high-quality prospects", but the pages do not show what feeds the score or whether lifecycle or pipeline stages exist. We found no public information on routing to owners or teams, negative scoring, score decay, or per-contact score history, so I cannot tell whether a decision would be explainable to the person it was made about.
Channels & personalisation
Evalanche
Email, SMS, social media and print are listed as channels steered from one platform, and personalisation goes beyond merge fields: content adapting in real time to behaviour and preferences, image personalisation, and send-time optimisation computed from profile history. Push, on-site personalisation, ad-audience sync and cross-channel frequency capping are not shown on the captured pages, which caps this well short of the top band.
Mautic
Email is thoroughly evidenced — drag-and-drop builder, personalisation and A/B testing for marketing and transactional sends — alongside forms, landing pages and web tracking. We found no public information on SMS, push or ad-audience sync driven from the same contact profile, and personalisation is documented on email content rather than on the behavioural record.
Consent, tracking & profiling
Evalanche
Consent is positioned as a precondition — without valid opt-in no profiles may be created and no behaviour analysed — and double opt-in is provable inside the software through a database entry with timestamp, logged with proof per Art. 7; tracking offers opt-in, opt-out and withdrawal plus a pseudonymised mode, defaults are privacy-friendly, and access, blocking, rectification and deletion rights are documented. I found no public information on versioned consent wording, retention stated and executed per data category for the marketing database, or erasure that demonstrably extends to derived scores.
Mautic
Web tracking is marketed with a "data privacy and compliance focus" and the vendor commits not to rent or sell personal data, but the consent tool the privacy policy names — "Real Cookie Banner" — governs the vendor's own website cookies. We found no public information on double opt-in, per-channel consent status, consent timestamps per contact, or erasure of contact profiles and derived scores; the deletion and backup statements on the pages concern community accounts on mautic.org.
CRM integration & data model
Evalanche
Bidirectional connectors with field mapping to SAP, Salesforce, Microsoft and a long list of German mid-market CRMs are documented, explicitly positioned as extending rather than replacing the core systems, with a report API for statistics export. Duplicate handling, per-field conflict resolution, account and custom objects, sync retry with an error log, and API rate limits are not shown on the captured pages, so the deeper join that resolves disagreements stays unclear.
Mautic
A documented REST API for bespoke integrations and an extendable plugin ecosystem are the published facts, with a Drupal integration for automated emails. We found no public information on sync with a named CRM, field mapping, duplicate handling or conflict resolution — the one CRM the pages mention, Savannah CRM, collates contributor activity for the project itself rather than for customers.
European sovereignty
Evalanche
SC-Networks GmbH of Starnberg is the contracting entity, hosting is stated to be exclusively in German ISO 27001-certified data centers, with an external data protection officer, TÜV ISO 27001 for company and data center, IT Security made in Germany, and a data protection package on request — a strong chain for behavioural profiles of named people. The data centers are not named, no published subprocessor list for the platform itself appears, and the pages give no processing location for the AI features; the privacy policy also describes third-country processing under Art. 44–49 safeguards for the vendor's own website services.
Mautic
The legal frame around the project is American — disputes governed by North Carolina law, the trademark held by the US-based Open Source Collective, and website use framed as consent to international transfer — while the only European element is a UK postal address for privacy inquiries rather than a stated EU contracting entity. We found no public information on data residency, a data processing agreement or subprocessors; self-hosting is offered as the route to "true data sovereignty", which places the burden on the operator rather than evidencing a European chain.
Pricing transparency
Evalanche
The captured pages describe a tariff architecture — a Marketing Core base with optional add-ons, plus an onboarding package at a fixed package price — and claim transparent tariffs without hidden costs, but no price figure, contact limit or billing period appears anywhere I was given, so an annual invoice is not computable from public evidence. A pricing page is linked from the homepage but its contents were not captured; the documented next step is a free consultation and a free live demo.
Mautic
The software is publicly priced at nothing — "free to download and use" — and a 14-day trial requires no credit card, so the licence line is computable for the self-hosted route. The managed hosting and SaaS routes offered through partners carry no public prices in the captured pages, so the real annual cost of a supported deployment cannot be computed from them.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Evalanche
Mautic
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Incorporated in GB
Hosting location
EU only
Not determined
Hosting options
Cloud service only
Self-hostable
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not needed, no transfer outside the EU/EEA
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
Fact
Evalanche
Mautic
Product · Lead scoring
Automatisches Lead Scoring erzeugt einen Gesamt-Score zur Vertriebsreife1
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Evalanche higher: 2/5 against 1.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 4 of the 6 judges pick Evalanche and 2 pick Mautic. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Evalanche or Mautic European?
Evalanche is European (EU-Made, Germany). Mautic is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United Kingdom). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Evalanche and Mautic store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Evalanche: In the EU. Mautic: its pages as captured do not say.