As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mattermost 3.5/5 and Slack 2.5/5 in Business Instant Messaging. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mattermost and 0 pick Slack. Mattermost scores higher on 5 of 6 criteria (Deployment & data custody, Retention, discovery & co-determination, Channels, threads & search, plus 2 more). Slack scores higher on 1 of 6 criteria (European sovereignty). Provenance — Mattermost: Rest of world; Slack: Rest of world. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The computed means put Mattermost ahead on five criteria — messaging core (7.3 vs 5.3, two ties), encryption and access (7.5 vs 6.0, three ties), governance and discovery (7.8 vs 5.7), deployment control (9.3 vs 4.3, six Mattermost leans and zero Slack leans) and integrations (7.0 vs 5.2). Slack carries the other two: sovereignty (5.3 vs 2.7) and pricing transparency (5.3 vs 0.8), each with five Slack leans to one for Mattermost; the panel's note states pricing is not weighted against Mattermost, whose prices are sales-routed. Per-judge totals run 6.3–7.5 for Mattermost against 6.1–6.6 for Slack, with the works council's Slack total at 0. Slack's verdict records an Irish processor for customers outside the USA and Canada and public prices (free 0€, Pro 8,25€, Business+ 18€ per user per month at monthly billing); Mattermost's records self-hosting as putting the archive in your perimeter.
Choose Mattermost if
You need the message archive inside your own perimeter: the sovereignty attributes list Mattermost as self-hostable, and deployment control is its strongest criterion (9.3 vs 4.3).
Your platform runs air-gapped or restricted networks: Mattermost's verdict records air-gapped runbooks with a bill of materials and package mirroring.
Your compliance team needs eDiscovery automation, legal hold and compliance exports to CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML or Proofpoint — governance and discovery leans Mattermost five judges to zero.
You want a customer-owned MySQL or PostgreSQL database and full source code access, which appear in Mattermost's deployment-control verdict.
Your works council must approve the purchase: its weighted total reads 6.3 for Mattermost against 0 for Slack.
Choose Slack if
You need EU data residency by default: Slack's sovereignty attributes record EU-default residency and five judges lean Slack on sovereignty (the captured pages give different figures for German storage — all plans versus from Business+).
Your procurement needs public prices before shortlisting: free 0€, Pro 8,25€, Business+ 18€ per user per month at monthly billing are public, and five judges lean Slack on pricing transparency.
You need the data protection paperwork quickly: Slack's attributes list a self-serve data processing agreement and a published transfer impact assessment.
You buy outside the USA and Canada and your legal review weighs the processing entity: Slack's verdict records an Irish processor.
Your auditors ask for a subprocessor list and a C5 attestation — both appear in Slack's sovereignty verdict, where five judges lean its way.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Compliance Counsel
Will one day have to produce this archive, edits and deletions included, to a regulator or a court. Wants legal hold, an export a lawyer can work from, retention per channel, and an audit trail that survives the admin who made the change.
Mattermost
This judge's pick
Slack
Criterion by criterion
Channels, threads & search
Mattermost
Full searchable history across channels, threads and direct messages with per-channel permissions and retention is stated, and the documented search limit (core search up to 3 million posts, enterprise search beyond) tells a buyer what finding an eighteen-month-old decision actually costs. Threaded discussions, guest accounts, shared channels with federation, and moving a thread to another channel are all documented. We found no public information on pinned or saved items, which keeps this just below the working-knowledge-base level.
Slack
Public and private channels, threads, notification-style mentions, file sharing and searchable history are all documented, and Slack Connect extends channels across organisations with invitations an admin may need to approve. History limits are stated per plan — ninety days on free, unlimited on paid — which is the number I need before promising a regulator an eighteen-month-old record. I found no public information on message-edit history, pinned items, search filters, or exporting a conversation in a form a human can read.
Encryption & access control
Mattermost
Encryption in transit with TLS and at rest via documented disk and database methods, MFA, SSO, certificate-based authentication, session duration configuration, guest accounts and role-based access with custom permissions are all evidenced, and bring-your-own-key encryption is offered as an optional add-on on the top plan. The deployment guide also states plainly that encryption within the database is not offered so that end-user search and compliance reporting keep working — a named trade-off rather than a hidden one. We found no public information on end-to-end encryption of message content.
Slack
Encryption in transit and at rest is stated as default, administrators can mandate two-factor authentication for all users, SAML single sign-on appears per plan, and an administrator can remotely sign out every authenticated device on demand. Enterprise Key Management is offered as an add-on, which reads as customer-held keys, but the captured pages do not document the key handling behind it. I found no public information on an end-to-end encryption mode.
Retention, discovery & co-determination
Mattermost
This is the strongest part of the record for my purposes: by default every deployment retains all messages including edits and deletions plus all uploaded files, and the compliance export documentation shows edits and deletions carried into exports with each message trackable by its MessageId across batches, in formats lawyers already run — CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML and Proofpoint. Retention policies, legal hold and eDiscovery automation are named Enterprise features, every compliance query and download is itself logged in an audit history, and past history can be exported from a chosen timestamp. Two things hold it back: Playbooks and Boards content is excluded from compliance export, and we found no public information on switching presence or read receipts off organisation-wide.
Slack
Retention configurable team-wide and per channel with nightly execution is documented, and legal holds, eDiscovery support, audit logs, native DLP and information barriers are all named as product capabilities. For my purposes the record stops at the export: no documented admin export format appears, nothing shows edits and deletions captured in a discovery export, and the legal-hold workflow on the marketplace runs through a third party, Everlaw. I found no public information on switching presence or read receipts off organisation-wide.
Deployment & data custody
Mattermost
Custody genuinely can be the customer's: full source code, self-hosted subscriptions, three documented install paths that install the same server, an air-gap runbook with bill of materials and registry mirroring, FIPS-compliant STIG-hardened container images, and a backup strategy to set before the first user. The customer owns the database (MySQL or PostgreSQL) with their own internal controls, federation via the Matrix protocol is offered, and Slack-compatible webhooks plus export of past history document the way in and the way out rather than resisting either.
Slack
A cloud multitenant service with a selectable hosting region — German storage from Business+ upward — and a documented exit: return of customer data on request within thirty days of termination, hard deletion within twenty-four hours of a deletion request, and continuation on the free tier after a non-enterprise subscription ends. I found no public information on a self-hosted or open-source edition, so custody stays with the vendor and only the door out is written down.
Integrations & extensibility
Mattermost
A versioned REST API with bearer authentication, incoming and outgoing webhooks, slash commands, an MCP server and a flexible plugin platform are all documented, with interactive components — Mattermost Blocks and interactive dialogs — for structured interaction. Named operational integrations including Jira, GitHub, GitLab and ServiceNow and no-code Slack-compatible webhooks round this out. We found no public information on documented rate limits, SCIM provisioning, or event subscriptions with retries, which is what would distinguish a full app framework.
Slack
There is a marketplace with named apps from Google Drive to Workday, documented incoming webhooks with JSON payloads, SAML single sign-on with SCIM provisioning, and a platform pitched for building custom solutions. The webhook documentation marks outgoing webhooks as legacy and points to Slack apps as the replacement; what that newer framework offers — interactive components, event subscriptions, rate limits — does not appear on the captured pages.
European sovereignty
Mattermost
The contracting entity is proven American — Mattermost, Inc. of Palo Alto — with processing in the United States and other countries and Google Analytics on its sites, so the cloud chain is not European as far as the captured pages show. What keeps this above the floor is a listed Data Processing Addendum and Subprocessor documents, explicit commitments to Standard Contractual Clauses and the EU–US Data Privacy Framework with EU rights honoured, and the fact that self-hosted or air-gapped operation puts the archive and its metadata inside the customer's own perimeter. We found no public information on EU data residency, an EU contracting entity or EU representative, or subprocessor locations.
Slack
The captured pages give different statements on German storage: the German homepage presents it unconditionally while the pricing footnote makes it available from Business+. Around it sit an Irish contracting entity for customers outside the US and Canada, a data processing addendum containing the EU Standard Contractual Clauses, a subprocessor page stating identity, location and role, and named transfers to Australia, Canada, India, Japan, South Korea and the USA carried on the contractual clauses — with Amazon Web Services named as the infrastructure provider. The parent's seat is not stated on these pages, so the top of the chain stays open.
Pricing transparency
Mattermost
Every paid plan is a sales conversation: Professional says "Contact Sales", Enterprise says "Get Pricing", Enterprise Advanced says "Request Quote", and no per-user figure appears anywhere captured. A free limited-use evaluation edition, a one-hour trial and FAQ headings on license sales, the SaaS offering and seat overages are public, but the answers were not captured, so a buyer cannot compute an annual invoice for any headcount from public pages.
Slack
Three of four tiers carry public per-user prices with the billing period stated — Pro at 8,25€ and Business+ at 18€ per user per month at monthly payment, free at 0€ — and VAT treatment is spelled out down to the reverse-charge rule for a valid VAT ID, alongside refund and proration terms. Enterprise+, the tier where the audit, eDiscovery and key-management features sit, is contact-sales only, and the Enterprise Key Management add-on shows no public price. A buyer can compute a Pro or Business+ invoice; a compliance-grade one still needs a sales conversation.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Mattermost
Slack
Legal entity
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
EU by default
Hosting options
Self-hostable
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Published
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mattermost higher: 3.5/5 against 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mattermost and 0 pick Slack. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Mattermost or Slack European?
Mattermost is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Slack is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Mattermost and Slack store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Mattermost: its pages as captured do not say. Slack: In the EU by default.
Do Mattermost and Slack have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.