Panel rating · 6 judges · How to read the stars

Category median

Sovereignty: 2 of 6 dimensions proven

0–5 in half steps. 5 means the rubric's top anchor is met on the evidence.

by RosterElf Pty Ltd · www.rosterelf.com

Report an error on this page Is this your product? →

Link to this page

RosterElf: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai RosterElf: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai (dark)

Add ?theme=dark to the image address for dark backgrounds. The badge shows the category and the month of the latest evaluation, and EU-Made where that is the product’s provenance. It never shows a score.

RosterElf at a glance

Vendor
RosterElf Pty Ltd
Headquarters
Incorporated in Australia source, captured 17 Nov 2026
Data hosting
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 17 Nov 2026
Free plan
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 17 Nov 2026
Panel verdict
The AI panel rates RosterElf 2.5/5, the mean of 6 judges. RosterElf is an employee scheduling tool from Roster Elf Pty Ltd in Western Australia, strongest on pricing transparency, staff self-service and payroll and integrations: Core is 'From $6.00 AUD per employee a month, billed annually', Full Suite from $7.00 AUD ($8 and $10 monthly), plus GST, for each active employee whether or not they log in, with admins and managers counted as paid seats, a 15-day trial with no credit card required, and approved timesheets going to Xero in one click, already split into pay items, with file exports for MYOB and Smartly. how scores are made
As of
Vendor pages captured 17 Nov 2026; evaluated by the panel 18 Nov 2026. all sources

RosterElf alternatives, European ones first →

Read this page as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The Skeptic

Weighted verdict

Has read a great many pages saying the product "supports" the Arbeitszeitgesetz and wants to know whether it blocks a violation, warns about it, or merely exports it. Reads for which tier the time clock and the DATEV export sit in, how seasonal staff are counted per employee, and what the forecasting "AI" actually uses as input.

Same scores as the panel view — this lens weights them the way this judge cares.

Scored by The Skeptic

Panel median The Skeptic This judge’s scores over the panel median. Each label opens its reasoning below.
Scores per criterion, in stars out of 5
Criterion Panel median The Skeptic
Roster building & demand planning 3 of 5 3 of 5
Working-time law & collective agreements 2 of 5 1 of 5
Mobile self-service for deskless staff 3.5 of 5 3.5 of 5
Works council & employee data 2.5 of 5 2.5 of 5
Payroll handoff & integrations 3.5 of 5 3.5 of 5
European sovereignty 1 of 5 0.5 of 5
Pricing transparency 4 of 5 3.5 of 5

Roster building & demand planning

How this is scored

How a plan gets built across locations, roles and qualifications — templates, staffing requirements, forecasting from sales or occupancy, and whether the product proposes a roster or only draws one.

0 — Not a rostering tool; shifts cannot be planned in the product (a time clock, HR file or messenger only).

3 — A weekly shift grid per location with shift templates and roles attached, and the roster published to staff.

5 — Shift templates with roles or qualifications on shifts, several locations or departments, and open shifts or coverage gaps shown while planning.

8 — Staffing requirements per shift and demand-based planning from a named data source (POS revenue, footfall, occupancy or bookings), automatic roster proposals the planner can accept or adjust, labour cost shown against budget while planning, and cross-location staff sharing.

10 — Planning closes the loop: forecast, proposed roster and actual hours compared in one place, the proposal explains which rule or demand figure drove each assignment, and the vendor documents the forecasting method rather than calling it AI.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Templates with positions, layering, multi-site filtering, open shifts and a labour-budget comparison while planning are documented, and rosters can be drafted by an AI assistant. But the AI is a skill installed into Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini that works from a text description rather than demand data, and we found no public information on staffing requirements per shift, forecasting from POS revenue, footfall or occupancy, or cross-location staff sharing. 1 3 4 7

Report an error

Working-time law & collective agreements

How this is scored

Whether the roster knows the rules it is subject to — ArbZG rest periods and maximum hours, youth and maternity protection, Minijob earnings limits, Tarifvertrag and works-agreement rules, surcharges — and whether it enforces them, warns, or leaves them to the export.

0 — No working-time checks: the vendor states or shows that any shift can be planned without a rule check.

3 — Basic checks such as overtime, maximum-hours or break warnings shown to the planner.

5 — Named working-time checks — daily or weekly maximum hours, rest periods between shifts and breaks — shown to the planner before the roster is published, and contract hours or earnings limits tracked per employee.

8 — ArbZG named with the 11-hour rest period and daily maximum checked, the Minijob earnings ceiling warned about, whether a check blocks or only warns stated, and configurable rule sets per contract or employee group covering Tarifvertrag surcharges (night, Sunday, holiday), time accounts, youth-protection limits and works-agreement rules, with the planner's override of a violation recorded and reasoned.

10 — The rules are modelled as law, not as warnings: maintained rule sets for named collective agreements, sector-specific exceptions (care, hospitality) documented with the statute they rely on, every override attributable, and published guidance mapping each feature to the provision it serves.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Overtime exists as pay configuration: daily and weekly overtime rules per pay template are applied when a roster is costed, together with penalties and allowances, and breaks are recorded at the clock — the rules price a long shift rather than stop one. We found no public information on planner-facing warnings or blocks, rest periods between shifts, maximum-hours or youth-protection checks, and the vendor's own disclaimer says award and pay templates are a starting point only to be verified against the applicable award. 2 5 8 11

Report an error

Mobile self-service for deskless staff

How this is scored

What the employee on the shop floor actually gets: a mobile app to read the roster, enter availability, request and accept swaps, claim open shifts and clock in — in their language, on their own device or a shared one.

0 — No employee access; the roster reaches staff only as a printout or PDF.

3 — An app or web view in which employees see their own shifts and are notified of changes.

5 — A mobile app with the roster, availability or absence requests, and shift swaps or open-shift claiming, with push notifications of changes.

8 — Swaps and open shifts resolved under the rule set (qualifications and rest periods checked before approval), clock-in by app or shared terminal with offline handling, a multilingual interface, and team communication that keeps shift talk out of private messengers.

10 — Self-service is designed for people who never open a laptop: swap and cover flows that resolve without a manager where the rules allow, accessibility and language coverage stated, use on a shared or personal device both supported, and employees able to see and export the data held about them.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Staff get a real app on iOS and Android: shifts, push notifications they choose, leave and availability, swaps within rules the manager sets, open-shift claiming with a pending queue showing the best match, clock-in on the phone or a site's shared tablet, shift tasks and team chat in the same app. We found no public information on offline handling, interface languages, or swap approvals resolved against qualifications and rest periods, which is what the top levels turn on. 7 8 10 11

Report an error

Works council & employee data

How this is scored

Whether the product can be introduced under co-determination (BetrVG § 87) — role-based visibility, what is logged, which monitoring can be switched off, retention of availability, absence and location data — and whether the vendor supplies what a works agreement needs.

0 — No access control: the vendor's pages show every user seeing all employee data, or tracking of individuals that cannot be switched off.

3 — Admin, manager and employee roles with different rights, and a privacy policy that covers employee data.

5 — Configurable roles and permissions limiting who sees whose data, a data processing agreement offered, and either location tracking stated as optional or a retention or deletion rule for employee data.

8 — Fine-grained visibility (absence reasons hidden from colleagues and line managers where not needed), GPS and similar tracking off by default, an audit log of who viewed and changed an individual's data, configurable deletion periods, and documentation the vendor offers for works-council approval under BetrVG § 87.

10 — Data minimisation is designed in and evidenced: a model works agreement or feature-by-feature data inventory published, no performance or behaviour scoring of individuals, monitoring functions individually deactivatable, and deletion executed automatically per configured period.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The permission model is genuinely tiered — Owner, Admin, Manager, Assistant Manager and Staff, scoped per site, with HR records and financial data gated — and smartphone clock-in is a global setting with selfie proof only if configured. But the privacy framework shown is Australian (Australian Privacy Principles, a UK GDPR addendum whose text is not displayed), and we found no public information on an audit log of views and changes, retention or deletion periods, or documentation for works-council approval. 2 8 9 10

Report an error

Payroll handoff & integrations

How this is scored

How planned and worked hours, surcharges and absences reach payroll — DATEV, Lohn und Gehalt, the tax adviser — and how the roster connects to the POS, HR and time systems a shift business already runs.

0 — No payroll path: the product offers no export of hours and no integration.

3 — An export of worked hours and absences (CSV or Excel) intended for payroll.

5 — A named payroll integration or payroll export (DATEV Lohn und Gehalt or LODAS, or another named payroll system) covering hours and absences, plus several named HR, POS or accounting integrations.

8 — Vendor-maintained payroll integrations with a lock step before transmission, wage types mapped per surcharge, POS integrations feeding forecasting, an HR master-data sync, and a documented API.

10 — Payroll is designed for, not exported to: several named payroll systems maintained, retro corrections after the close handled, the tax adviser given scoped access, and a versioned public API with webhooks and a deprecation policy.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The handoff is real and gated: approved timesheets go directly to Xero already split into pay items with every rule mapped to a Xero Pay Item, file exports for MYOB and Smartly carry every hour, penalty and leave line, a CSV fallback exists, and a free accountant role gets scoped access to approve and send payroll. The named systems are Australian and New Zealand ones — we found no public information on DATEV or other European payroll, a documented API (the AI assistant logs in as the user rather than through one), POS integrations, or an HR master-data sync. 3 5 10 11 12

Report an error

European sovereignty

How this is scored

Where the employee data lives, who the contracting entity is, who the subprocessors are, and whether that is documented rather than assumed. Independently sourced by the sovereignty pipeline; weighted seriously here, because a scheduling tool holds availability, absence and often location data about employees who had no say in the vendor.

0 — Vendor, contracting entity and hosting of employee data all shown to be outside the EU, with no transfer safeguard stated.

3 — A named contracting entity and a privacy policy or data processing agreement; EU hosting offered as an option or claimed without a provider, or the hosting location not stated.

5 — EU hosting stated as standard, together with an EU contracting entity or a published subprocessor list, and a data processing agreement offered.

8 — EU or DACH hosting with a named data-centre provider, EU contracting entity, full subprocessor list published, and any non-EU processing — push notification services included — named with its legal basis.

10 — Sovereign end to end and evidenced: vendor, entity, hosting and every subprocessor in the EU, certification published, and a DPA that covers the employee data the app collects on personal devices.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The contracting entity is Roster Elf Pty Ltd with an Australian business number and a Western Australia address, the pages present the product as Australian-made with the region given as "Australia (Global)", and the privacy policy claims the Australian Privacy Principles; the only processing addendum shown is a UK GDPR one for UK customers. We found no public information on an EU hosting option, an EU data processing agreement, subprocessors, or any transfer safeguard for employee data. 2 11 12

Report an error

Pricing transparency

How this is scored

Whether a buyer can compute the real annual invoice for their headcount and locations — including the time clock, payroll export, forecasting and other modules sold as add-ons — from public pages alone.

0 — No public prices at all; every tier is a sales conversation.

3 — A public per-employee "from" price, a free tier or one priced tier, while the other tiers or what they include are not stated.

5 — Per-employee or per-location prices public for each tier with the billing period stated; add-on modules (time clock, payroll export, forecasting, terminal hardware) may still be unpriced.

8 — Every tier and add-on priced publicly with the per-employee maths, how inactive or seasonal staff are counted, minimum term and VAT treatment stated; only genuinely custom work lacks a number.

10 — Complete price computability: a calculator or table producing the annual invoice for a given headcount, location count and module selection, including hardware, onboarding and renewal terms.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Both tiers are public with the billing period stated ("From $6.00 AUD per employee a month, billed annually" for Core, $7 for Full Suite, $8 and $10 on monthly billing), prices are "+ GST, for each active employee, whether or not they log in", admins and managers count as paid seats while the accountant is free, and a comparison table shows the monthly cost for a team of 20. The "from" qualifier is unexplained and we found no public information on a minimum term or a price calculator, so the exact invoice for an arbitrary headcount cannot be fully computed from public pages. 1 7 10

Report an error

European sovereignty — proven facts

2 of 6 dimensions proven

Built only from facts shown on the vendor's own pages. A dimension we could not prove is left open, not scored as zero.

Hosting location Not determined — uncited Report an error
Hosting options Not determined — uncited Report an error
Open source Not determined — uncited Report an error
Data processing agreement Published, self-serve unverified
Why unverified?

Only a UK GDPR addendum is listed, and the excerpt shows just a 'Read more' link rather than the agreement text itself, so it is unclear whether an EU Art. 28 DPA is equally published.

1/1 pts 2 Report an error
Transfer impact assessment Not determined — uncited Report an error

Questions about RosterElf

Is RosterElf European?

Not determined: the vendor’s pages as captured do not say where RosterElf is based. Its vendor, RosterElf Pty Ltd, is incorporated in Australia, per the vendor’s page captured 17 Nov 2026.

Where does RosterElf store data?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 17 Nov 2026.

Does RosterElf have a free plan?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 17 Nov 2026.

What are the best alternatives to RosterElf?

As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Ordio (3/5), Shiftbase (3/5) and gastromatic (3/5) highest among the other 32 Employee Scheduling products evaluated. Ratings that look equal are rounded to half stars; the order uses the unrounded rating, then the name. The highest-rated European alternative is Ordio (EU-Made). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made. The full list, with European products first: RosterElf alternatives.

Where this could be wrong

What we left out

A claim that does not survive our checks costs us the claim, not the page. This is what was taken off this one.

Sources (12)

The pages every claim on this page was read from — each one checked, dated, and kept verifiable.

  1. 1 Vendor page www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  2. 2 Legal notice — found from the homepage www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  3. 3 Roster building & demand planning — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  4. 4 Roster building & demand planning — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  5. 5 Working-time law & collective agreements — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  6. 6 Working-time law & collective agreements — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  7. 7 Mobile self-service for deskless staff — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  8. 8 Mobile self-service for deskless staff — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  9. 9 Works council & employee data — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  10. 10 Works council & employee data — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  11. 11 Payroll handoff & integrations — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →
  12. 12 Payroll handoff & integrations — found from sitemap www.rosterelf.com Checked 17 Nov 2026 Details →