Panel rating · 6 judges · How to read the stars

Category median

Sovereignty: not determined

0–5 in half steps. 5 means the rubric's top anchor is met on the evidence.

by Circula GmbH · circula.com

Report an error on this page Is this your product? →

Link to this page

Circula: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai Circula: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai (dark)

Add ?theme=dark to the image address for dark backgrounds. The badge shows the category and the month of the latest evaluation, and EU-Made where that is the product’s provenance. It never shows a score.

Circula at a glance

Vendor
Circula GmbH
Headquarters
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 10 Nov 2026
Data hosting
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 10 Nov 2026
Free plan
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 10 Nov 2026
Panel verdict
The AI panel rates Circula 3/5, the mean of 6 judges. Circula is an expense management product from Circula GmbH, judged here on help-centre documentation in German and English. how scores are made
As of
Vendor pages captured 10 Nov 2026; evaluated by the panel 11 Nov 2026. all sources

Circula alternatives, European ones first →

Read this page as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The panel's verdict

Circula is an expense management product from Circula GmbH, judged here on help-centre documentation in German and English. It is strongest at reimbursement and VAT, the only criterion scored above six: Federal Ministry of Finance per diem rates are kept up to date in the app, meal deductions and the eight-hour and midnight rules are calculated automatically, and approved reimbursable expenses leave as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard. Receipt capture and cards and spend control score six with no spread; approval and policy and accounting export run from six to seven, the higher scores crediting the four configurable workflows per entity and a DATEV XML export that carries the receipt images themselves, and no criterion divided the judges more widely than that single point. Sovereignty scores zero with no spread — we found no public information on hosting, subprocessors, a data processing agreement or certifications — and pricing transparency scores zero to one, the captured pages stating no prices.

Report an error

Speaks for it

  • Per diems follow Federal Ministry of Finance rates kept up to date in the app, including €28 full-day, €14 arrival and €20 overnight amounts with 20 and 40 per cent meal reductions
  • Receipt images are transferred with the receipt data in the DATEV XML export, with Unternehmen Online and Belege Online named as the prerequisite
  • Card limits, transaction limits, purposes of use and allowed or blocked categories are configured per card, and transactions breaking the rules are declined at the moment of payment
  • Approved reimbursable expenses export as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard once employee IBANs are stored
  • Four configurable workflows run per entity, with routing by project and cost centre, supervisor replacements and trip pre-approval

Report an error

Held against it

  • Scans are capped at three pages per submission, with longer receipts requiring a multi-page PDF created outside the product
  • Supervisor replacements are in gradual rollout and do not cover project or cost-centre approval workflows
  • Trip pre-approval works with only two of the four workflows, 'Approval first' and 'Parallel workflow'
  • The EO Comfort export passes kilometre distances but not the travel cost amount, and covers only expenses with an assigned EOC project
  • The captured export mapping shows no tax key, and we found no public information on a documented API, webhooks or a GoBD-compliant archive

Report an error

Best for

  • You calculate German statutory travel allowances — per diems, meal deductions, the eight-hour, midnight and multi-country rules — and want them maintained and calculated automatically in the app
  • You keep your books in DATEV with Unternehmen Online and Belege Online and want receipt images to travel with the export
  • You want card spending controlled before payment, with per-card limits and allowed or blocked categories declining non-compliant transactions at the moment of payment
  • You reimburse employees by SEPA transfer and can hold employee and company IBANs in the system

Report an error

Avoid if

  • Your approval chains rely on project or cost-centre supervisors whose absences need cover, which the replacement feature does not yet support
  • You use the 'Control first' or 'Control only' workflows and need trip pre-approval, which the pages state is incompatible with them
  • A single trip needs reimbursement beyond three months, the stated maximum per trip
  • You split expenses across projects and need each part approved by its own supervisor, since a split goes to the first item's approver

Report an error

The scores

Panel median The median of the judges’ scores per criterion. Each label opens its reasoning below.
Scores per criterion, in stars out of 5
Criterion Panel median
Receipt capture & expense claims 3 of 5
Company cards & spend control 3 of 5
Approval workflows & expense policy 3.5 of 5
Reimbursement, travel allowances & VAT 3.5 of 5
Accounting handoff & DATEV 3 of 5

Receipt capture & expense claims

Show reasoning
How this is scored

How an expense gets into the system: a mobile app that photographs receipts, text recognition (OCR) that reads amount, date, merchant and VAT, receipts forwarded by email or pulled from suppliers, claims for out-of-pocket spending in any currency, mileage and trip entries, a substitute receipt (Eigenbeleg) when the original is lost, and duplicate detection.

0 — Not an expense capture tool; receipts and claims cannot be recorded in the product.

3 — Receipts uploaded as photos or files and attached to an expense by hand; text recognition, email capture or claims in other currencies are basic or not described.

5 — A mobile app that captures receipts with text recognition reading amount, date and merchant, receipts forwarded by email, expense claims for out-of-pocket spending submitted from the app, and foreign currencies converted.

8 — Extraction of VAT rates and amounts and line items, receipts collected automatically from email inboxes or named suppliers, duplicate and fraud checks on submission, a substitute receipt for lost originals, mileage with route calculation, and replacement scanning (ersetzendes Scannen) stated as GoBD-compliant so paper originals may be discarded.

10 — Capture without employee effort: e-receipts delivered directly by travel and merchant partners, extraction accuracy or review process published, a certified scanning procedure (for example an audit report to IDW PS 880 or a TÜV certificate) named, and every receipt traceable from capture to booking.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee

The plus button in the mobile app scans a receipt and text recognition fills in merchant, invoice date, currency, total amount, VAT rate and invoice number, still editable before I submit — photograph-and-done in essence, with multi-page receipts as PDF, unreadable-receipt detection and an AI receipt check named alongside it. Mileage claims appear in trips and in the DATEV export, but route calculation is not described. We found no public information on receipts forwarded by email, duplicate detection, or a substitute receipt for lost originals. 1 2 9

Report an error

The Office Manager

The mobile app scans receipts and text recognition pulls merchant, invoice date, currency, total amount, VAT rate and invoice number into editable fields, telling me plainly whether the read was full, partial or nothing. Scans can be cropped and set to black-and-white, longer receipts ride along as multi-page PDFs, and an AI receipt check with unreadable-receipt detection sits on top. We found no public information on receipts collected automatically from email inboxes, a substitute receipt for lost originals, or mileage with route calculation. 1 2

Report an error

The Controller

The mobile app scans receipts and the text recognition reads merchant, invoice date, currency, total, VAT rate and invoice number, the extracted fields stay editable, and a three-state status shows how much was read; receipts sitting in storage are then matched automatically to card expenses. We found no public information on capture by email, duplicate checks at submission, or a substitute receipt for lost originals, and a scan is capped at three pages unless a multi-page PDF is created outside the product and uploaded. 1 2 4

Report an error

The Finance Lead

The mobile app scans receipts and text recognition fills merchant, invoice date, currency, total amount, VAT rate and invoice number into editable fields, with a manual scan mode, image editing and a multi-page PDF route for longer receipts; unreadable-receipt detection and an AI receipt check are named as related capabilities. Receipts held in storage are matched automatically to expenses. We found no public information on capture by email forwarding, duplicate checks, a substitute receipt for lost originals, or a scanning procedure certified so paper originals can be discarded. 1 2

Report an error

The Tax Adviser

A mobile app scans receipts and the text recognition reads merchant, invoice date, currency, total amount, VAT rate and invoice number, with results editable by the employee and clear statuses (extracted, partially extracted, nothing extracted); an AI receipt check, unreadable-receipt detection and automated receipt matching are named as capabilities. We found no public information on receipts collected from email or named suppliers, a substitute receipt for lost originals, duplicate checks, or replacement scanning stated as GoBD-compliant, and scans are capped at three pages per submission. 1 2

Report an error

The Skeptic

The mobile app scans receipts and recognition reads merchant, date, currency, total and VAT rate, with an AI receipt check and automated receipt matching listed alongside it — more than manual upload. But we found no public information on capture by email, duplicate detection, a substitute receipt for lost originals or replacement scanning, and a scan is capped at three pages. Mileage allowance entries do appear in the export mapping, so claims beyond paper receipts exist. 1 2 9

Report an error

Company cards & spend control

Show reasoning
How this is scored

How spending is controlled before it happens: physical and virtual company cards with limits, single-use and subscription cards, limits by amount, merchant category and time, budgets per team or project, real-time notifications and receipt reminders — or, for a product that issues no cards of its own, live feeds from the company's existing cards with automatic receipt matching. The issuing institution and its licence count where cards are issued.

0 — Neither issues cards nor reads card transactions; only out-of-pocket claims exist.

3 — Card transactions imported from a statement file or a single feed and matched by hand, or a card offer with fixed limits; budgets, reminders and controls are basic or not described.

5 — Either own physical and virtual cards with per-card limits, freezing and real-time notifications, or live feeds from named corporate card schemes or banks with automatic matching of receipts to transactions; spending visible as it happens and employees reminded to submit receipts.

8 — Cards for every employee with limits by amount, merchant category and period, single-use and subscription cards, budgets per team or project that cards draw from, pre-approval of a purchase before the card is charged, feeds from existing bank cards beside the own cards, and the issuing institution and licence named.

10 — Spend control across the company: multi-entity and multi-currency card accounts, budgets and policies enforced at the moment of payment, card spend reconciled to the statement automatically, safeguarding of funds and credit terms stated, and cards and transaction history portable to another provider.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee

Card limits, transaction limits, purposes of use and allowed or blocked expense categories are configured per card, and transactions that break the rules are declined at the moment of payment — control before the money leaves, which is what I want at a hotel desk in a third currency. Transactions become draft expenses automatically, receipts from storage are matched to them, and overdue expenses are visibly flagged and prioritised. We found no public information on budgets per team or project, single-use or subscription cards, pre-approval before a charge, or the issuing licence behind the Pliant card integration. 3 4

Report an error

The Office Manager

The captured pages describe a Pliant credit card integration where card limits, transaction limits, purposes of use and allowed or blocked expense categories are configured per card, and transactions breaking the rules are declined at the moment of payment. Card transactions become expense drafts automatically, receipts from the storage match themselves to those drafts, overdue expenses are flagged with priority, a fixed submission deadline can be switched on, and admins see transactions, card limits and credit card statements. We found no public information on budgets per team or project, single-use or subscription cards, or the issuing institution and its licence. 3 4

Report an error

The Controller

Cards run through the Pliant integration with card limits, transaction limits and allowed or blocked expense categories configurable per card, and transactions that break the rules are declined directly at the time of payment — control before the money moves, which is exactly what I want. We found no public information on budgets that cards draw from, single-use or subscription cards, real-time notifications, or the issuing institution and its licence. 3 4

Report an error

The Finance Lead

Per-card limits, transaction limits, purposes of use and allowed or blocked categories are configured in the product, transactions that break the rules are declined at the moment of payment, an expense draft is created automatically for each card transaction, and admins and accountants see transactions, submission status, card limits and card statements, with overdue expenses visibly flagged. The cards run through a Pliant credit card integration. We found no public information on feeds from the company's own bank cards, single-use or subscription cards, budgets per team or project, or pre-approval of a purchase before the card is charged. 3 4

Report an error

The Tax Adviser

Card limits, transaction limits and allowed or blocked expense categories are configured per card, and transactions breaking the rules are declined at the moment of payment, with an automatic expense draft and automated matching of receipts to card transactions; admins see transactions, submission status, card limits and card statements, and overdue expenses are flagged with priority. Cards run through the referenced Pliant integration; we found no public information on budgets per team or project, single-use or subscription cards, or the issuing institution and its licence. 3 4

Report an error

The Skeptic

Cards arrive through a referenced Pliant integration with per-card limits, transaction limits, purposes of use and allowed-or-blocked categories, and non-compliant transactions are declined at the moment of payment — real enforcement, not just reporting, with automatic expense drafts and receipt matching doing the work. We found no public information on the issuing institution and its licence, single-use or subscription cards, budgets per team or project, or what a card payment abroad costs. That silence is exactly what a buyer should chase before signing. 3 4

Report an error

Approval workflows & expense policy

Show reasoning
How this is scored

How the company's rules are applied: approval chains by amount, team, cost centre or project, delegation and deputies, an expense policy with limits per category and per country that the product checks, pre-approval of trips and purchases, roles and permissions, multi-entity set-ups, and an audit trail of who approved and changed what.

0 — No approval step; every expense goes straight to export or payment.

3 — A single approver per employee or one sign-off step; policy rules, deputies and audit history are basic or not described.

5 — Multi-step approval flows configurable by amount, team or cost centre, an expense policy with limits per category that flags violations, approval from the mobile app, and a history of who approved what.

8 — Rule-based routing by amount, project, cost centre and entity with deputies and escalation, policy checks before submission (limits per country, per diem rules, duplicates), pre-approval of trips or purchases, granular roles and permissions, several legal entities in one account, and an exportable audit trail.

10 — Controls that stand up to an audit: anomaly and fraud detection with its rules explained, separation of duties enforced, country-specific policies maintained centrally, every change to a claim versioned and attributed, and control reports offered to auditors.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee

Four workflows per entity — approval first, control first, control only, or the parallel supervisor-and-accountant flow — plus routing to project supervisors, cost-centre control of invoices, deputies for absent supervisors and pre-approval of whole trips before any expense is incurred. The captured pages state real limits too: replacements do not yet cover project or cost-centre flows, trip pre-approval works with only two of the four workflows, and routing is fixed at submission. We found no public information on approval chains keyed to amount, approval from the mobile app, or an exportable audit trail of who approved what. 5 6

Report an error

The Office Manager

Four configurable workflows per entity — approval first, control first, control only, parallel — let supervisor approval and accountant control run in parallel, and approval can route by assigned project or cost centre with project supervisors, supervisor replacements and pre-approval of trips before expenses are incurred. Routing is fixed at submission, split expenses go to the first item's approver, and folder-based routing is excluded. We found no public information on routing by amount, escalation rules, per-country policy limits or an exportable audit trail. 5 6

Report an error

The Controller

Workflows are configurable per entity (approval first, control first, control only, parallel), supervisor approval and accountant control run in parallel, accounts payable invoices route to the cost centre supervisor, trips can be pre-approved, and supervisors can name replacements — though replacements do not yet cover project or cost centre approval chains. We found no public information on routing by amount, on policy limits checked before a claim is submitted, or on an audit trail of who approved and changed what; routing is fixed at submission, but that is not an exportable history. 5 6

Report an error

The Finance Lead

Four configurable workflows run per entity (approval first, control first, control only, parallel), with supervisor approval and accountant control in parallel as the standard, approval routed by assigned project and cost centre, supervisors able to name replacements, and trips pre-approved before expenses are incurred; routing is fixed at submission. We found no public information on routing by amount, escalation, policy limit checks per category or country at submission, or an exportable audit trail of who approved and changed what. 5 6

Report an error

The Tax Adviser

Four configurable workflows per legal entity (approval first, control first, control only, parallel) with distinct submitter, supervisor, accountant and admin roles, routing by project and cost centre, project supervisors assigned two ways, supervisor replacements and trip pre-approval before costs are incurred. The vendor states replacements are in gradual rollout and do not cover project or cost-centre approvals, and we found no public information on escalation rules, policy limits per category checked at submission, or an exportable audit trail. 5 6

Report an error

The Skeptic

Four configurable workflows per entity, project and cost-centre routing, trip pre-approval and supervisor replacements are documented — clearly more than one sign-off step. The replacements are in gradual rollout and skip project and cost-centre workflows, routing is fixed at the moment of submission, and we found no public information on routing by amount, policy limits per country checked before submission, or an exportable audit trail of who approved what. 5 6

Report an error

Reimbursement, travel allowances & VAT

Show reasoning
How this is scored

How the employee gets money back and the company gets the tax right: reimbursement of approved claims by bank transfer or a SEPA payment file, mileage allowances and per diems at statutory rates per country (Verpflegungspauschalen, Kilometerpauschale, meal deductions), taxable and tax-free reimbursements separated for payroll, the input VAT captured per receipt for the deduction, and foreign VAT reclaimed.

0 — No reimbursement of employees; the product covers company cards only and out-of-pocket spending is out of its scope.

3 — Out-of-pocket claims recorded and paid back outside the product by hand; travel allowances and VAT handling are basic or not described.

5 — Approved claims reimbursed through the product or a SEPA payment file, mileage and per diems at configurable rates, and the VAT rate and amount captured per receipt for the input-tax deduction.

8 — Statutory per diems and mileage rates per country maintained by the vendor (German travel expense law named), meal deductions and multi-day trips calculated, reimbursement in several currencies within a stated time, VAT split per rate and receipts checked for the invoice requirements of the deduction, and foreign VAT reclaim offered or integrated with a named partner.

10 — Travel expense law and VAT handled end to end: country rules kept current with a stated process, taxable reimbursements passed to payroll, foreign VAT reclaim filed with the recovered amounts reported, and every reimbursement traceable to the claim and the rule that produced it.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee

The German travel-expense engine is deeply documented: €28 full days, €14 arrival days, €20 overnight, meal reductions of 20 and 40 per cent, the eight-hour rule, the midnight rule, half-day counting and multi-country day rules, with Federal Ministry of Finance rates kept up to date in the app — per diems without me touching a spreadsheet. Approved reimbursable expenses export as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft format once employee IBANs are stored, and the scan captures the VAT rate per receipt. We found no public information on foreign VAT reclaim, VAT split by rate, taxable amounts handed to payroll, or a stated time until the money is back on my account. 7 8 2

Report an error

The Office Manager

Statutory German per diems are kept current in the app from Federal Ministry of Finance rates — €28 for a full day, €14 on arrival, €20 per overnight stay, 20 and 40 per cent meal deductions, the 8-hour and midnight rules, plus cross-border, multi-country and multi-destination rules — all calculated automatically from the travel data entered. Reimbursable expenses export as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft format once employee and company IBANs are stored, and the receipt scan captures the VAT rate per document. We found no public information on foreign VAT reclaim or on passing taxable reimbursements to payroll. 2 7 8

Report an error

The Controller

German travel expense law is clearly maintained by the vendor: BMF per diems kept up to date in the app, arrival-day, full-day and overnight amounts, meal deductions at 20 and 40 percent, the eight-hour rule, the midnight rule and multi-country day rules all calculated automatically from the entered travel data, and approved claims leave as a SEPA XML file in the latest Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard. The VAT side is thinner: the scan captures the VAT rate, but we found no public information on a VAT split per rate, checks against the invoice requirements of the deduction, or foreign VAT reclaim. 7 8

Report an error

The Finance Lead

Approved reimbursable expenses export as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard against stored employee and company IBANs, and the per diem engine is genuinely German: Federal Ministry of Finance rates by country and city kept up to date in the app, arrival and departure day treatment, meal reductions with a zero floor, the midnight rule, one-day trips needing more than eight hours of absence, and multi-country days, all calculated automatically. Mileage claims exist and kilometres flow to the DATEV export. We found no public information on statutory mileage rates maintained by the vendor, checks of receipts against the invoice requirements for the input-tax deduction, or foreign VAT reclaim. 7 8

Report an error

The Tax Adviser

German travel expense law is implemented in real depth: meal allowances of €28 for full days and €14 on arrival, €20 overnight, meal reductions of 20% and 40% with a zero floor, the eight-hour threshold, midnight rule and multi-country day rules, with the BMF rates kept up to date in the app and international rates by country and city. Reimbursable expenses export as a SEPA XML file in the current Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard once employee IBANs are stored; we found no public information on taxable reimbursements passed to payroll, checks that receipts meet the invoice requirements of the input-tax deduction, or foreign VAT reclaim. 7 8

Report an error

The Skeptic

The German travel-law side is genuinely deep: per diems and meal deductions at Federal Ministry of Finance rates kept up to date in the app, the midnight rule, cross-border and multi-country day rules, and reimbursement through a SEPA XML export at Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft standard that requires employee IBANs. The VAT rate is read from each receipt. We found no public information on foreign VAT reclaim, a VAT split per rate, or reimbursement in other currencies within a stated time. 2 7 8

Report an error

Accounting handoff & DATEV

Show reasoning
How this is scored

What reaches the books: export or sync to DATEV (DATEV format, DATEV Unternehmen online, Belegbilderservice) and to named accounting and ERP systems, booking proposals with account, tax key and cost centre, receipts that travel with the booking, card statements reconciled, a GoBD-compliant archive, an API and webhooks, and a complete export of claims, receipts and booking data.

0 — No export of any kind; expenses have to be retyped into the books.

3 — A CSV or PDF export of expense reports; booking data, named integrations and the archive are basic or not described.

5 — Export or sync to at least one named accounting system (DATEV or another) with account and tax code per entry and the receipt attached, several accounting or ERP integrations listed, and a documented API.

8 — A DATEV interface with receipt images (DATEV Unternehmen online or the DATEV Marketplace named), booking proposals that learn account, tax key and cost centre, two-way sync with named ERPs (SAP, Microsoft Dynamics, NetSuite or similar), card statements reconciled for the month-end, a GoBD-compliant archive stated, and webhooks.

10 — The month-end close runs through the product: multi-entity bookings and accruals, a procedure documentation (Verfahrensdokumentation) or GoBD audit offered, a complete audit trail of every financial event, and a full export of claims, receipts and bookings that a successor system can import.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee

Both DATEV paths are documented — the XML export that carries the receipt images themselves into DATEV Unternehmen Online with Belege Online, and the EO Comfort export that hands over booking files, kilometres and EOC project data, with account, counter-account and gross amount mapped in the export. We found no public information on booking proposals that learn tax key and cost centre, interfaces to other ERP systems, a documented API or webhooks, card statement reconciliation, or a GoBD-compliant archive. 9 10

Report an error

The Office Manager

Expenses export under Prüfung & Freigabe in DATEV Format or DATEV XML with the receipt images themselves transferred in the XML, DATEV Unternehmen Online including Belege Online named as the prerequisite, and the mapping carrying booking account, gross amount in the account's standard currency, creditor number and booking text. A second route exports project-tagged expenses to DATEV EO Comfort, including kilometre distances but not the travel cost amount. We found no public information on booking proposals that learn tax key and cost centre, two-way ERP sync, a GoBD-compliant archive, an API or webhooks. 9 10

Report an error

The Controller

The DATEV handoff is real: export in DATEV format or DATEV XML with the receipt images included, DATEV Unternehmen Online with Belege Online named as the prerequisite, and a documented field mapping for account, counter-account, currency and booking text; a three-part DATEV EO Comfort flow imports and exports order data, with kilometre distances passed on but not the travel cost amount. We found no public information on booking proposals that learn, a tax key in the export, card statement reconciliation for the month-end, a GoBD-compliant archive, or an API and webhooks. 9 10

Report an error

The Finance Lead

Receipts travel with the booking: the DATEV XML export transfers the receipt images themselves into DATEV Unternehmen online with Belege Online, and the export mapping carries booking account, gross amount in the account's standard currency, creditor counter-account, currency code and booking text. A round trip with DATEV EO Comfort imports order data and exports kilometres and expenses assigned to EOC projects. We found no public information on booking proposals with tax key and cost centre, reconciliation of card statements for the month-end, sync with named ERPs, a GoBD-compliant archive, or an API and webhooks. 9 10

Report an error

The Tax Adviser

The DATEV handoff is genuine: an XML export under Prüfung & Freigabe > FiBu Export transfers the receipt images together with the receipt data, requires DATEV Unternehmen online with Belege Online, and maps Buchungskonto, gross amount, Gegenkonto and booking text; a second channel exports order data to DATEV EO Comfort, passing kilometres but not the travel cost amount, only for expenses with an assigned EOC project. We found no public information on a GoBD-compliant archive, webhooks, a documented API, or two-way sync with ERP systems beyond the EO Comfort import. 9 10

Report an error

The Skeptic

A real DATEV handoff exists: XML export with the receipt images themselves transferred, Unternehmen Online with Belege Online named as the prerequisite, a field mapping listing account and counter-account, and an EO Comfort order-data import/export cycle. The captured mapping shows no tax key, and we found no public information on booking proposals that learn cost centres, a documented API, webhooks or a GoBD-compliant archive — on this evidence the month-end close does not run through the product. 9 10

Report an error

European sovereignty panel opinion

n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r Show reasoning
How this is scored

Who the contracting entity and the parent company are, where receipt, card and employee data are hosted, and who the subprocessors are (hosting, card issuer and processor, text recognition, open banking, email delivery). Independently sourced by the sovereignty pipeline; expense data is personal and financial at once and shows where employees travel, so the whole chain counts, not only the database.

0 — Non-EU vendor and contracting entity, hosting unstated, subprocessors unnamed, and no data processing agreement offered.

3 — A privacy policy and a data processing agreement exist, but hosting location is unstated or non-EU and the subprocessors are not listed.

5 — EU hosting available and an EU contracting entity or EU representative, but parts of the chain (text recognition, card processing, email, analytics, support) run through non-EU providers without a stated safeguard.

8 — EU hosting on named infrastructure, EU contracting entity and card issuer, subprocessors listed with their locations, a data processing agreement published, and security certifications (ISO 27001, SOC 2) stated.

10 — Sovereign end to end and evidenced: European ownership, entity, issuer, hosting and every subprocessor, data export and deletion documented, and certifications published with their scope rather than implied.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee not rated — no public information

The only chain detail visible anywhere is the Pliant name on the card integration; we found no public information on the contracting entity, hosting location for receipt, card and employee data, subprocessor locations, a data processing agreement, or security certifications on the captured pages. 3 9

Report an error

The Office Manager not rated — no public information

We found no public information on the contracting entity, hosting locations, subprocessors, a data processing agreement or security certifications in any of the captured help pages. This dimension stays open and does not count toward the verdict. 1 7 9

Report an error

The Controller not rated — no public information

We found no public information on the contracting entity and parent company, where receipt, card and employee data are hosted, or the subprocessors behind hosting, card issuing, text recognition and email delivery; the captured help-centre pages on receipts, cards and DATEV export cover none of this, and no data processing agreement is mentioned. 1 3

Report an error

The Finance Lead not rated — no public information

We found no public information on hosting locations, subprocessors, a data processing agreement or certifications in the pages captured for this evaluation; only the vendor name Circula GmbH appears. The help-centre pages I read, covering cards, per diems and the DATEV export, give no facts on any sovereignty dimension, so the whole chain stays unknown. 3 8 9

Report an error

The Tax Adviser not rated — no public information

We found no public information on the contracting and parent entities, where receipt, card and employee data are hosted, or the subprocessors behind hosting, card issuing, text recognition and email delivery; the captured pages are product documentation only. 1 5 9

Report an error

The Skeptic not rated — no public information

We found no public information on where receipts and the text recognition are processed, who hosts the data, or any subprocessor list, data processing agreement or certification — the receipt-scanning and OCR pages never say where the reading happens, and the card pages reference a Pliant integration without naming the issuing institution or its licence. Ten help-centre pages in German and English are the whole picture here, and none of them speaks to the chain behind the app. 1 2 3

Report an error

Pricing transparency not rated — the vendor publishes no price

Show reasoning
How this is scored

Whether a buyer can compute the real annual cost from public pages alone: price per user or per active user, platform or base fee, which modules (travel, reimbursements, DATEV or ERP connectors, extra entities) cost extra, card fees (physical cards, foreign transactions, currency conversion, top-ups), minimum seats and term, and setup.

0 — No public prices at all; every customer is a sales call.

3 — A starting price or a free tier exists, but how cost scales with users, cards or modules is unclear.

5 — Tiers are public with their per-user or base price and main inclusions, but at least one commonly needed piece (extra users, physical cards, foreign-currency fees, ERP connectors) is unpriced or "on request".

8 — Every tier priced publicly with its scaling rule (per user, per active user, per card), card and foreign-transaction fees listed, add-ons priced, minimum term and VAT treatment stated.

10 — Complete price computability: annual cost derivable for a given headcount, card count and module set, with every add-on, setup, support, card and currency fee and the cancellation and data-return terms published.

Report an error

The Travelling Employee not rated — no public information

The captured pages are help-centre articles on workflows, cards, per diems and exports, and none of them names a price, tier, per-user fee or card fee. We found no public information on pricing; the closest is a note that one feature is switched on by contacting support. 5 6

Report an error

The Office Manager not rated — no public information

We found no public information on prices in the captured pages — no per-user rate, tiers, card fees, minimum seats or term. I cannot work out what this would cost us for thirty people before a trial. 1 3 8

Report an error

The Controller not rated — no public information

We found no public information on pricing: nothing on per-user or per-active-user fees, a platform fee, which modules such as travel, reimbursements or the DATEV connectors cost extra, card and foreign-currency fees, minimum seats, term or setup. The captured help-centre articles state no figures at all, so a buyer cannot compute an annual cost from them. 1 5

Report an error

The Finance Lead not rated — no public information

We found no public information on pricing: the captured help-centre articles describe functionality only, with no per-user price, tiers, base fee, card or foreign-currency fees, minimum seats or term. A real annual cost cannot be computed from the pages read. 1 5

Report an error

The Tax Adviser not rated — no public information

We found no public information on per-user or per-active-user prices, base or platform fees, charges for modules or connectors, card fees, minimum seats, term or setup costs; everything captured concerns product function, not price. 2 6

Report an error

The Skeptic

None of the captured pages shows a price of any kind — not per user, not per card, not a currency fee — and at least one feature is switched on only by contacting the support team, which is the only commercial interaction the pages describe. A buyer cannot begin to compute an annual cost from this. 6

Report an error

Questions about Circula

Is Circula European?

Not determined: the vendor’s pages as captured do not say where Circula is based.

Where does Circula store data?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 10 Nov 2026.

Does Circula have a free plan?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 10 Nov 2026.

What are the best alternatives to Circula?

As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Moss (4/5), N2F (3.5/5) and Spendesk (3.5/5) highest among the other 28 Expense Management products evaluated. Ratings that look equal are rounded to half stars; the order uses the unrounded rating, then the name. The highest-rated European alternative is Moss (EU-Made, Germany). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made. The full list, with European products first: Circula alternatives.

Where this could be wrong

What we left out

A claim that does not survive our checks costs us the claim, not the page. This is what was taken off this one.

Sources (10)

The pages every claim on this page was read from — each one checked, dated, and kept verifiable.

  1. 1 Receipt capture & expense claims — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  2. 2 Receipt capture & expense claims — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  3. 3 Company cards & spend control — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  4. 4 Company cards & spend control — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  5. 5 Approval workflows & expense policy — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  6. 6 Approval workflows & expense policy — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  7. 7 Reimbursement, travel allowances & VAT — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  8. 8 Reimbursement, travel allowances & VAT — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  9. 9 Accounting handoff & DATEV — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →
  10. 10 Accounting handoff & DATEV — found from sitemap help.circula.com Checked 10 Nov 2026 Details →