As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Aplano 2.5/5 and Staffomatic 2.5/5 in Employee Scheduling. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Aplano and 6 pick Staffomatic. Aplano scores higher on 3 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency, Roster building & demand planning and Working-time law & collective agreements). Staffomatic scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Payroll handoff & integrations and European sovereignty). Provenance — Aplano: EU-Made, Germany; Staffomatic: EU-Made, Germany. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The benches split by criterion. Aplano leads pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8; 5 judges lean Aplano, 0 Staffomatic, 1 tie) on per-employee monthly prices — Core 0,50€, Basic 2€, Pro 4,50€ — and roster planning (6.0 vs 5.3; 4 lean Aplano, 2 tie). Staffomatic's captured pages give different figures for Basic — '2,00 Monat / Person' versus 'Im Monatsabo ab 2,40 €'. Staffomatic leads payroll and integrations (6.3 vs 3.0; 6 lean Staffomatic, 0 tie) and sovereignty (4.7 vs 3.0; 6 lean, 0 tie): Aplano's data residency attribute is non-EU, Staffomatic's unknown, with its verdict describing a German server centre and named subprocessors including HubSpot Inc. (USA). Staff self service is level at 6.5, 2 leaning each way; codetermination and privacy level at 5.0, 1 each way. Weighted totals favor Staffomatic (5.5 vs 5.8, 4 vs 5, 4.7 vs 5, 5.1 vs 5.4, 4.9 vs 5.1); the table shows none for the operations director.
Choose Aplano if
You need per-employee monthly prices visible before you buy — pricing transparency leans Aplano 5 judges to 0 with 1 tie, on tiers of Core 0,50€, Basic 2€ and Pro 4,50€.
Your planning lives in week-to-week rostering — roster planning leans Aplano 4 judges to 0 with 2 ties, means 6.0 vs 5.3.
You want a short commitment — Aplano's verdict lists a one-month minimum term.
Your team keeps surcharge and correction arithmetic in-house — working time rules leans Aplano 2 judges to 1 with 3 ties, means 3.8 vs 3.7.
Choose Staffomatic if
You hand payroll to DATEV — payroll and integrations leans Staffomatic 6 judges to 0 with 0 ties, means 6.3 vs 3.0, with an export mapping surcharges, absence types and cost centres that only transmits completed periods.
Your data-protection review turns on where data sits — sovereignty leans Staffomatic 6 judges to 0, means 4.7 vs 3.0; its verdict describes a German server centre and named subprocessors including HubSpot Inc. (USA), while Aplano's data residency attribute reads non-EU.
Your buyer role matches one of the judging roles — the weighted totals read 5.5 vs 5.8 for the shift manager, 4 vs 5 for the payroll officer, 4.7 vs 5 for the works council, 5.1 vs 5.4 for the frontline employee, and 4.9 vs 5.1 for the skeptic.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Skeptic
Has read a great many pages saying the product "supports" the Arbeitszeitgesetz and wants to know whether it blocks a violation, warns about it, or merely exports it. Reads for which tier the time clock and the DATEV export sit in, how seasonal staff are counted per employee, and what the forecasting "AI" actually uses as input.
Aplano
Staffomatic
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Roster building & demand planning
Aplano
Shift templates carry working time and a role and drop onto the weekly grid, open and released shifts cover gaps, and a staffing-requirement field feeds a generator the planner can accept, reject or re-roll. But we found no public information on any demand source behind that requirement — no POS revenue, footfall or occupancy is named — nor on labour cost against budget or sharing staff across locations; the automation runs on rules the planner types in.
Staffomatic
Weekly-schedule templates with a template manager, a qualification filter, work areas and an all-locations view are documented, and shifts are colour-coded against the number of required staff per shift, yellow marking an uncovered shift and blue a fully staffed one — a planning grid with real coverage signals. We found no public information on demand-based planning from a named source such as POS revenue or occupancy, on automatic roster proposals the planner accepts or adjusts, or on labour cost shown against budget; the 'intelligente Planungshilfe' and the beta KI-Assistent Staffo (daily usage limit, price may change after beta) are names without a documented method.
Working-time law & collective agreements
Aplano
Break rules are configurable in the scheduling settings with hours and minutes and can be auto-deducted from stamped time, and rest periods and overtime are named as features — more than a bare grid. But we found no public information naming the Arbeitszeitgesetz, the 11-hour rest period or a daily maximum, whether a violation blocks publication or only warns, or anything on Minijob earnings ceilings, Tarifvertrag surcharges or youth protection.
Staffomatic
The rule machinery documented is time-and-pay arithmetic, not the law: automatic break deduction configurable by length of recorded working time in the time-tracking settings, a monthly working time account comparing planned against actual times and calculating overtime, and marketing prose that 'intelligente Tools' prevent double bookings and overtime. We found no public information naming the Arbeitszeitgesetz, the 11-hour rest period, a daily or weekly maximum, Minijob earnings limits, youth or maternity protection, or any collective agreement; the tariff-adjacent 'Zuschläge' line in Premium carries no rule set, and no page states whether a check blocks a shift or merely warns the planner.
Mobile self-service for deskless staff
Aplano
The employee side is the strongest part: roster, team and week views, availability with start and end times, absence requests with automatic vacation-account updates, swaps and open-shift applications, in-app chat, push on plan changes, and stamping by phone, geofencing or a shared tablet station with manager confirmation. We found no public information on offline stamping, a multilingual interface, or whether swap approvals check qualifications and rest periods before an admin confirms.
Staffomatic
A native iOS and Android app carries the roster, absence requests, availability, shift swap and open-shift applications, with push notifications on schedule changes, a language selector and integrated team messaging; clock-in runs by app and on the separate terminal app, and admins can do the entire planning from the smartphone. We found no public information on swaps or open shifts being resolved under the rule set — qualifications and rest periods checked before approval — or on offline handling, so the self-service surface is broad while the rule check underneath it is undocumented.
Works council & employee data
Aplano
Employee, manager and administrator permission types run through every plan, the privacy policy states deletion once data is no longer needed plus 14-day retention for website logs, and app use is reserved to customers with an Article 28 data-processing agreement. We found no public information on hiding absence reasons from colleagues, on switching the geolocation stamp-in off (it is marketed as a feature), on an audit trail of who viewed an individual's data, or on documentation a works council could use for BetrVG § 87.
Staffomatic
The three roles are real: managers are confined to their assigned locations with admin-trimmable rights, employees see only locations and work areas they are assigned to, and detail visibility — including who was assigned to or applied for a shift and absence categories — is configurable; deletion periods are stated (server logs after 14 days, applicant data six months) and each plan keeps a Protokoll for 30, 60 or 90 days. We found no public information on a data processing agreement, on location or GPS tracking and whether it can be switched off, on an audit log of who viewed or changed an individual's data, or on any documentation offered for works-council approval under co-determination law.
Payroll handoff & integrations
Aplano
The payroll path is a file export: evaluations export as CSV, PDF, multi-PDF and Excel in the Pro plan only, with a CSV employee-list import/export in every tier. We found no public information on DATEV or any other named payroll system, wage types mapped to surcharges, POS or HR integrations, or a documented API.
Staffomatic
The DATEV export is the genuine article: working time accounts exported as DATEV-conform files for upload to DATEV Unternehmen online and exclusively for DATEV Lohn & Gehalt, each surcharge mappable to a DATEV wage type, absence types and per-employee cost centres mapped, and only closed periods exportable — but it sits in Premium only, on top of the working time account, and the vendor states plainly that no wage functions are included. Beside it stand a Personio interface (annual subscription only), CSV/Excel exports serving as the 'Grundlage für die Lohnabrechnung' and for a tax adviser, and an API named for Professional and Premium whose documentation the pages only point at.
European sovereignty
Aplano
The contracting entity is German — Aplano GmbH of Berlin, registered at the Hamburg court — app use requires a data-processing agreement, and website subprocessors are listed individually in the privacy policy. But the only hosting statement on the captured pages covers the vendor's own website (Firebase), and we found no public information on where the planner's customer data — availability, absence and geolocation stamp-ins — is hosted, nor on certifications or the push services used.
Staffomatic
A German UG in Hamburg with commercial register and VAT ID, a German server centre under 24-hour monitoring, server management through a German partner, an external data protection officer, and a privacy policy that names its subprocessors — including non-EU ones such as HubSpot Inc. (USA) and JOIN Solutions AG (Switzerland) — with EU standard contractual clauses stated as the transfer mechanism. We found no public information naming the data-centre provider, on a data processing agreement, on hosting options for the product itself beyond the German server centre, or on any certification.
Pricing transparency
Aplano
All three plans are priced publicly — Basic 2€, Core 0,50€, Pro 4,50€ pro Mitarbeiter & Monat — with a one-month minimum term, headcount adjustable at any time, deactivated users not billed, and a 14-day Pro trial without payment details, which answers the seasonal-staff question. We found no public information on VAT treatment, a price for the fingerprint/RFID terminal hardware, or which tier the time clock sits in beyond the exports being limited to Pro.
Staffomatic
Every tier is priced publicly per person and month — Basic 2,00, Professional 4,00, Premium 6,00, from at least ten persons, no base fee — with VAT treatment ('Nettopreise zzgl. gesetzl. MwSt.'), billing terms (annual: 12 months in advance; monthly: cancel monthly, up to 17% discount), multiple locations without surcharge and a 14-day trial without payment data all stated. The captured pages give different figures for the entry price (2,00 € on the pricing page, 'ab 2,40 € im Monatsabo' on the feature page), the Basic add-ons for absences and time tracking carry no price, and we found no public information on how seasonal or inactive staff are counted or on a calculator producing the annual invoice.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Aplano
Staffomatic
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Incorporated in DE
Hosting location
Outside the EU
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Aplano and 6 pick Staffomatic. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Aplano or Staffomatic European?
Aplano is European (EU-Made, Germany). Staffomatic is European (EU-Made, Germany). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Aplano and Staffomatic store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Aplano: Outside the EU by default. Staffomatic: Default not stated; pages mention Germany.