As of 6 Nov 2026, the panel rates GitGuardian 3/5 and GitHub Advanced Security 3/5 in Code Security & Quality (SAST/SCA). Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick GitGuardian and 4 pick GitHub Advanced Security. GitGuardian scores higher on 4 of 6 criteria (European sovereignty, Platforms, deployment & administration, Source-code handling, security & compliance, plus 1 more). GitHub Advanced Security scores higher on 2 of 6 criteria (Code analysis (SAST & code quality) and Dependencies (SCA), licences & secrets). Provenance — GitGuardian: EU-Made, France; GitHub Advanced Security: Rest of world, United States. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
No overall winner emerges: the benches split by criterion and by judge. GitGuardian leads on sovereignty (8.0 versus 5.8, six judges to zero), integration and administration (7.7 versus 7.2, three leans to zero with three ties), trust and compliance (7.2 versus 6.7) and developer workflow (6.3 versus 6.0). GitHub Advanced Security leads on code analysis (4.0 versus 0.0, six judges to zero), pricing transparency (6.0 versus 4.0, six to zero) and dependencies and secrets (6.7 versus 6.5, three leans to one, two ties). Weighted totals split the judges four to two in GitHub Advanced Security's favour — the lead developer, appsec engineer, engineering manager and skeptic — while the platform engineer (6.6 versus 6.3) and product security officer (6.1 versus 6.0) go to GitGuardian. On sovereignty, GitHub Advanced Security's data residency attribute reads non-EU; GitGuardian's verdict records a Paris entity, Frankfurt hosting for EU customers and a self-hosted edition.
Choose GitGuardian if
You need EU-based contracting and hosting: sovereignty leans GitGuardian six judges to zero (8.0 versus 5.8), its verdict records GitGuardian SAS of Paris with EU customers hosted in Frankfurt, and GitHub Advanced Security's data residency attribute reads non-EU.
Your team must keep code and findings on your own infrastructure: sovereignty is the six-to-zero GitGuardian criterion, and its verdict records a self-hosted edition.
Your platform team is measured on integrations and administration: the criterion leans GitGuardian three to zero with three ties (7.7 versus 7.2).
Your audit calendar makes trust and compliance decisive: it leans GitGuardian three to zero with three ties (7.2 versus 6.7).
Your developers weigh the daily workflow most: developer workflow leans GitGuardian three judges to one (6.3 versus 6.0).
Choose GitHub Advanced Security if
You need documented static analysis: code analysis leans GitHub Advanced Security six judges to zero (4.0 versus 0.0); GitGuardian's verdict records its captured pages documenting only hardcoded-credential detection, with no public information on data-flow or taint analysis or OWASP/CWE rule sets.
Your procurement requires published unit prices: pricing transparency leans GitHub Advanced Security six to zero (6.0 versus 4.0), quoting "$ 30 USD per active committer/month" for Code Security and "$ 19 USD" for Secret Protection; GitGuardian's Growth tier is contact sales.
You need dependency alerting plus history-wide secret scanning: dependencies and secrets leans GitHub Advanced Security three judges to one with two ties (6.7 versus 6.5), and its verdict documents Dependabot alerts and secret scanning of the entire git history on all branches with push protection.
You rank code analysis and published pricing above hosting region: GitHub Advanced Security takes both criteria six judges to zero, against GitGuardian's six-to-zero sovereignty lean, and four of six judges' weighted totals (lead developer, appsec engineer, engineering manager, skeptic) land on its side.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Engineering Manager
Head of engineering at a B2B SaaS company in Munich with six teams and a ten-year-old Java and Kotlin codebase. Wants technical debt and code health shown per team and hotspot, a quality gate on new code that every team keeps, trends to show the board that the rewrite budget worked, findings routed to Jira, single sign-on and roles per team, and to know what the AI-written code the teams now merge does to the numbers.
GitGuardian
GitHub Advanced Security
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Code analysis (SAST & code quality)
GitGuardian
The captured pages market a "native SAST for GitHub" but define it as detecting hardcoded credentials in real time, which is secrets detection rather than source-code analysis; we found no public information on taint or data-flow analysis, rule sets mapped to OWASP or CWE, per-language depth, or complexity, duplication and technical-debt metrics. For my Java and Kotlin teams this tool would tell me about leaked credentials, nothing about code health per team and hotspot.
GitHub Advanced Security
Code scanning with CodeQL's "industry-leading semantic code analysis" for vulnerabilities and coding errors is confirmed, with multi-repository variant analysis and a public preview that reviews pull requests for AI-application risks. But the captured pages give no information on which languages are supported at what depth, a published rule catalogue mapped to OWASP or CWE, custom rules, or the complexity, duplication, maintainability and technical-debt measures I would need to show per-team code health and hotspots.
Dependencies (SCA), licences & secrets
GitGuardian
Secret detection is the core and is documented in depth: 550+ specific detectors plus generic high-entropy patterns, validity checks through non-intrusive HTTP calls, a published 91 percent true positive rate refined against a four-billion-commit dataset, scans across the full git history, and push-time protection via pre-commit, pre-push and pre-receive hooks. Secrets are also found outside git in Slack, Jira, Confluence, documents and container registries, with rotation and revocation guidance and secrets-manager sync. We found no public information on dependency analysis, licence detection or SBOM export, so for supply-chain composition I would still need a second tool.
GitHub Advanced Security
Dependabot brings vulnerability alerts, grouped upgrade pull requests, reachability analysis in public preview and SBOM export, and the secrets side is genuinely deep — the entire Git history plus issues, discussions, wikis and gists are scanned, with validity checks, custom and generic patterns, a 150-plus-provider partner programme and push protection. We found no public information on the captured pages about licence detection and policies, the ecosystems and lockfiles covered, malicious-package and end-of-life detection, or the vulnerability database and how fast it is updated.
Developer workflow, quality gates & fixes
GitGuardian
Developers meet findings where they work: GitHub check runs on every pull-request commit, scans that can be set as a required status check to block merges, workflows that fail on leaks, CI integrations for Jenkins, GitHub Actions, GitLab CI/CD, Azure Pipelines, Bitbucket Pipelines, Circle, Drone and Travis, and git hooks at pre-commit, pre-push and pre-receive. We found no public information on IDE plugins, suppression and ignore rules with reasons, deduplication across tools, or AI autofix with the model behind it stated.
GitHub Advanced Security
The gate story is real: rulesets stop merges that add high-severity alerts, alerts auto-close when the code is fixed, scans run on push or schedule through GitHub Actions, and Copilot Autofix claims automatic fixes for 90% of alert types in JavaScript, TypeScript, Java and Python — Java coverage matters to my teams. The documented path is GitHub-native only; we found no public information on IDE plugins matching server rules, triage and suppression with reasons, a new-code baseline, or typical scan times.
Platforms, deployment & administration
GitGuardian
This covers most of what I need to run it across six teams: native support for GitHub, GitHub Enterprise, GitLab, Bitbucket Cloud and Data Center and Azure DevOps, a documented REST API with reference, Jira Cloud and Jira Data Center plus ServiceNow for triage, SAML 2.0 single sign-on that can be enforced with SCIM provisioning and team-default permissions, audit logs, and a self-hosted edition on Helm or KOTS including our existing Kubernetes. Incident trends over up to three years and per-developer analytics give portfolio views; we found no public information on SARIF or CSV export of findings.
GitHub Advanced Security
Administration is strong at the enterprise level: SAML single sign-on, SCIM provisioning, Enterprise Managed Users, an audit log API, an enterprise account managing multiple organisations, webhooks plus a documented REST API for code-scanning alerts, and SARIF interoperability with third-party analysers; an Enterprise Server edition appears in the plan and licensing pages. For my specific wants the captured pages give no information on Jira routing of findings, granular roles per team, or portfolio dashboards with trends across repositories.
Source-code handling, security & compliance
GitGuardian
Code handling is documented concretely: only patches of commits with detected secrets are collected, the EU SaaS stores data in Frankfurt, and a self-hosted edition can keep code and findings on our own network. SOC 2 Type II has been maintained since 2022 with the auditor named, encryption in transit and at rest is stated, logs are kept 365 days, all customer data is removed at the end of the relationship, supported frameworks include PCI DSS, ISO 27001, NIS2, DORA and SOX, and the status page shows the EU platform at 100 percent uptime. We found no public information on a published SLA, on whether customer code trains AI models, or on the model provider behind the AI risk-scoring features.
GitHub Advanced Security
Private repository contents are contractually confidential, AI training on customer content is licensed but with an account-settings opt-out and no sharing with third-party model providers, SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type II reports come annually alongside FedRAMP Tailored, a published data processing agreement and EU standard contractual clauses, and a public status page shows per-component 90-day uptimes. We found no public information on the captured pages about code retention periods, encryption in transit and at rest, a published availability SLA, or findings reports mapped to OWASP, CWE, PCI DSS or the Cyber Resilience Act.
European sovereignty
GitGuardian
The contracting entity is GitGuardian SAS of Paris, the EU SaaS runs in AWS Frankfurt as a named region, a data processing addendum and a subprocessors page are published, and SOC 2 is stated — and the documented self-hosted edition on our own Kubernetes keeps code and findings entirely in our chain. The subprocessors' own locations and any AI models used are not shown in the captures, and US hosting is a separate platform with no migration between regions, so the chain is strong but not evidenced end to end.
GitHub Advanced Security
There is an EU data-residency option on named Microsoft Azure infrastructure, GitHub B.V. in Amsterdam acts as a data controller, and a published subprocessor list gives names and processing locations with 30 days' advance notice of changes. Against that, the contract runs with GitHub, Inc. under US federal and California law, personal data is by default stored in a variety of locations including the United States, and the AI-inference and support subprocessors — OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI, Zendesk and others — are almost all US-based, so the chain is only as European as the paid residency option you buy.
Pricing transparency
GitGuardian
The Starter free plan is published with real limits — up to 25 developers, unlimited real-time scanning, up to 500 historical scan detections and 10K API calls per month — and seat counting is explained through read access to VCS members for billing purposes. Beyond that the Growth and Enterprise plans are contact sales, and we found no public information on per-developer prices for the paid tiers, monthly versus annual terms, or VAT treatment, so I cannot compute an annual cost from the public pages.
GitHub Advanced Security
The add-on prices a buyer needs are public and per-scanner: "GitHub Code Security" at "$ 30 USD per active committer/month" and "GitHub Secret Protection" at "$ 19 USD per active committer/month", on top of published platform tiers, a free tier with Dependabot included, and a 30-day trial covering Enterprise, Copilot and Advanced Security. What is missing for a full annual computation: how an active committer is counted, annual versus monthly terms, VAT treatment, the price of the self-hosted Enterprise Server licence, and the cost of Actions minutes beyond the monthly allowance that code scanning consumes.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
GitGuardian
GitHub Advanced Security
Legal entity
Incorporated in FR
Incorporated in US
Hosting location
Not determined
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Self-hostable
Self-hostable
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
Questions about GitGuardian and GitHub Advanced Security
Which is better, GitGuardian or GitHub Advanced Security?
As of 6 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick GitGuardian and 4 pick GitHub Advanced Security. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is GitGuardian or GitHub Advanced Security European?
GitGuardian is European (EU-Made, France). GitHub Advanced Security is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United States). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do GitGuardian and GitHub Advanced Security store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — GitGuardian: its pages as captured do not say. GitHub Advanced Security: Outside the EU by default; pages mention the EU and Australia.
Do GitGuardian and GitHub Advanced Security have a free plan?
As of 6 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.