As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates JTL-Shop 3.5/5 and Shopify 2.5/5 in E-Commerce Platforms & Shop Systems. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 5 of the 6 judges pick JTL-Shop and 0 pick Shopify, 1 calls it a tie. JTL-Shop scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (Tax & German legal correctness, Data ownership & exit, Order operations & back office, plus 3 more). Shopify scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Catalogue & checkout). Provenance — JTL-Shop: EU-Made, Germany; Shopify: Rest of world, Canada. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The split runs along the stack, not between the two. Shopify takes the storefront: five judges lean Shopify on catalog and checkout (mean 6.7 to 6.3), four on extensibility (JTL-Shop's mean is higher, 6.7 to 6.5); pricing transparency leans Shopify three to one, two ties. JTL-Shop takes the back office: tax and legal is six leans to none (8.0 to 3.8), data control and exit the same (6.8 to 3.2), operations four leans, two ties (8.2 to 6.3). Sovereignty splits: two judges lean JTL-Shop, one Shopify, three tie (3.2 to 2.5). JTL-Shop contracts from a German entity; the captured pages give no public information on data residency, hosting or a data processing agreement. Shopify contracts from Canada, with non-EU data residency and a self-serve data processing agreement. Weighted totals tie at 7 for the merchant judge; JTL-Shop is ahead for the remaining five, including 6.2 to 0 for one judge.
Choose JTL-Shop if
You file OSS with the BZSt and need automatic monitoring of the 10,000 € Lieferschwelle, IOSS and GoBD-conform invoicing with DATEV export — tax and legal leans JTL-Shop with six judges.
You need your store data exportable with a clear exit path rather than retention for two years before deletion begins — data control and exit leans JTL-Shop with six judges.
You need a German contracting entity and a named data protection officer on record — JTL-Shop's legal entity jurisdiction is DE.
You fulfil orders across 30+ marketplaces and want automatic intake into one ERP with real-time payment matching and central shipping and returns — operations leans JTL-Shop with four judges, none for Shopify.
Choose Shopify if
You sell B2B and need customer-specific pricing and payment terms at the catalog level — catalog and checkout leans Shopify with five judges.
Your developers extend the storefront and app surface — extensibility leans Shopify with four judges.
You need to compute most of your annual bill from a public pricing page before committing — pricing transparency leans Shopify three judges to one.
You accept a Canadian contracting entity with non-EU data residency and want a self-serve data processing agreement.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Data Protection Officer
The shop holds customers, addresses and buying histories, and the checkout is full of third parties. Wants the subprocessor list, consent handling that survives a complaint, deletion that executes against order history, and an answer on where the CDN and analytics sit.
JTL-Shop
This judge's pick
Shopify
Criterion by criterion
Catalogue & checkout
JTL-Shop
Payment in the shop is documented through named routes — PayPal, cards and invoice via JTL Pay (beta) plus 20+ payment integrations including instalment purchase — and pricing goes beyond flat rates with article-level special prices, discount tiers and customer-group segmentation; multilingual shops with ECB-synced currencies are also documented. I found no public information on guest checkout, abandoned-cart recovery or rule-driven promotions, which keeps this below the top band.
Shopify
Checkout is the centrepiece here: abandoned-checkout recovery, discount codes and gift cards, instalments through Shop Pay Installments, Klarna and Affirm, B2B catalogues with customer pricing and payment terms, per-market currency pricing, and checkout customisation that is limited on lower tiers and full on Plus. Default payment methods include PayPal Express Checkout, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Meta Pay and Amazon Pay alongside cards, and Klarna rates are published per plan. I found no public information on A/B-testing the checkout, which is what the top level would require.
Tax & German legal correctness
JTL-Shop
VAT work is unusually well documented: OSS calculation with complete BZSt filings and automatic monitoring of the 10.000 € Lieferschwelle, IOSS for third-country imports up to 150 €, foreign VAT registrations across the EU, UK and Switzerland, GoBD-conform invoice creation and archiving, XRechnung and ZUGFeRD, and DATEV export out of the box — largely run through the countX-powered Tax product rather than left to the merchant. I found no public information on VIES validation of VAT IDs or on small-business (Kleinunternehmer) handling.
Shopify
The German pricing page promises automated VAT calculation, VAT-ID checking, tax exemptions and invoicing, and the tax product covers United States sales tax with liability monitoring; a free Manual Tax option lets merchants set their own rates. But the tax terms put determination, collection, reporting and remitting solely on the merchant, deliver the tool as-is with no tax advice under Ontario law, and I found no public information on the German checkout requirements such as order-button wording, withdrawal policy or price indications, nor on OSS reporting or XRechnung/ZUGFeRD e-invoicing.
Extensibility & developer surface
JTL-Shop
The developer surface is real: Smarty 3 templating, a plugin system that adds functionality without modifying store code, 700+ extensions, English-documented REST APIs for the ERP (closed beta), marketplace connection and fulfilment network, database-level access through views and stored procedures, a public Git repository for the shop and a public issue tracker. I found no public information on a headless storefront API or on documented rate limits.
Shopify
REST and GraphQL APIs with published rate limits, a storefront API for headless builds, Hydrogen storefronts that can be self-hosted or deployed to Oxygen with preview environments, development stores for testing, the open-source Liquid template language, metafields, and an app store with more than 21,000 apps. The core is hosted-only, checkout is contractually tied to Shopify, and I found no public information on version control for themes.
Order operations & back office
JTL-Shop
Orders from the shop flow automatically into the ERP where payment, shipping and returns are managed centrally; intake covers Amazon, eBay and OTTO marketplaces plus POS and connectors for Shopware 6, Shopify, WooCommerce and PrestaShop, with DATEV export out of the box, a named JERA accounting interface, real-time bank matching, multi-level dunning, status e-mails and a BI dashboard. I found no public information on dropshipping or on partial shipments and partial refunds.
Shopify
Everything after checkout is deeply covered: order editing, draft orders and invoices, partial refunds and partial shipments via split and merge, exchanges, order routing, up to 1,000 inventory locations, purchase orders and transfers, named carriers UPS, USPS, DHL Express and Canada Post with bulk label printing, marketplace intake from Amazon, Walmart, eBay and Etsy, dropshipping through Collective, and more than 200 real-time reports. ERP, PIM, CRM and CMS connections are described only as categories; I found no public information naming maintained interfaces to accounting systems such as DATEV.
Data ownership & exit
JTL-Shop
A free local installation on the merchant's own Windows machine or server, database backup and re-import, and database-level access via views and stored procedures make ownership structural rather than merely promised, and the shop source sits in a public Git repository. But the migration story runs one way — CSV import via JTL-DataTransfer and a migration team into JTL are documented — and I found no public information on a migration path out or on data return and deletion at cancellation, exactly the terms I would insist on before signing.
Shopify
The merchant keeps ownership of their materials but grants a transferable, sub-licensable licence that survives removal of the store, and on closure Shopify retains store information for two years before deletion begins — deletion or anonymisation on account closure is stated, but with that delay attached. Migration into Shopify is documented in detail, including CSV import of products and customers with the stated limitation that orders and blog posts cannot be moved that way; I found no public information on exporting a full store out of the platform, and the developer terms bar apps whose primary purpose is migrating merchants off Shopify.
European sovereignty
JTL-Shop
The contracting entity is proven German — JTL-Software-GmbH, register court Mönchengladbach HRB 12450 — with a named external data protection officer at Proliance GmbH, a privacy policy covering data subject rights and objection, a stated no-disclosure-without-consent rule and a native consent manager for shop and plugins. I found no public information on where the cloud hosting sits, on a subprocessor list with locations, on where analytics or CDN processing happen, or on a data processing agreement — the checkout chain stays dark, which caps this score.
Shopify
Shopify is a Canadian company, and for EEA users the data is received by the Irish subsidiary and then transferred to other Shopify locations including Canada and the USA, on Google Cloud Platform infrastructure. Subprocessors are published only by category — cloud hosting, content delivery, data analysis, internal logging, fulfilment, email — so I cannot see where the CDN or analytics in the checkout path actually sit; a data processing addendum exists and binding corporate rules are approved, which is what keeps this just above the bottom level.
Pricing transparency
JTL-Shop
The main editions are publicly priced with inclusions — Start at 0 € / Monat, Advanced ab 99 € / Monat, Pro ab 329 € / Monat — alongside monthly and annual billing with up to 17 % annual saving, published extra-order rates per tier (Ab 0,22 €, 0,16 € or 0,11 € je weiterem Auftrag), priced add-ons such as Dispositionsproduktion 29 € / Monat and Workbench 125 € per user per month, and a stated absence of transaction fees on shop sales. Enterprise is priced on request, and I found no public information on VAT treatment or minimum term, so a complete annual figure is not fully derivable.
Shopify
The main tiers are priced publicly with monthly and annual figures, per-tier card fees quoted exactly as '2,1 % + 0,30 €' through to '1,3 % + 0,30 €', external-provider transaction fees from 2 % down to 0,2 %, published Klarna, Sofort and USDC rates, POS Pro at 79 € EUR/month per location, marketplace overage of 1 % capped at 99 $ USD/month, and Shopify Tax free on the first $100,000 of lifetime sales then a 0.35% calculation fee (0.25% for Plus) — with VAT-exclusive treatment and the one- or three-year Plus commitment stated. Plus itself appears only as a from price of 'Ab 2.100 € EUR/Monat', the tax terms state pricing is set out in the Shopify Admin, and typical app costs are not enumerated, so the full annual cost is not quite computable from public pages.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
JTL-Shop
Shopify
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Incorporated in CA
Hosting location
Not determined
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates JTL-Shop higher: 3.5/5 against 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 5 of the 6 judges pick JTL-Shop and 0 pick Shopify, 1 calls it a tie. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is JTL-Shop or Shopify European?
JTL-Shop is European (EU-Made, Germany). Shopify is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Canada). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do JTL-Shop and Shopify store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — JTL-Shop: its pages as captured do not say. Shopify: Outside the EU by default.
Do JTL-Shop and Shopify have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.