As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mollie 3/5 and PAYONE 2.5/5 in Payment. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mollie and 0 pick PAYONE. Mollie scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency, Settlement, reconciliation & API, Licence, risk & account terms, plus 2 more). PAYONE scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Checkout, SCA & fraud). Provenance — Mollie: EU-Made, Netherlands; PAYONE: EU-Made, France. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Mollie's means run higher in five of seven criteria: payment methods 7.0 to 5.7, settlement and reconciliation 7.0 to 4.2, licence and account terms 6.8 to 4.0 and pricing transparency 7.7 to 4.0 — six judges lean Mollie on each of those four — plus recurring billing 6.0 to 5.7, where two judges lean Mollie and four tie. PAYONE holds checkout and SCA at 7.2 to 6.0, six judges leaning PAYONE and none leaning Mollie. Sovereignty is 4.0 apiece with six ties; jurisdiction attributes read NL for Mollie and FR for PAYONE, while data residency, hosting options, the data processing agreement and the transfer impact assessment read unknown for both — we found no public information on where either processes payment data. Mollie leads the five weighted totals shown, 5.9 to 6.7 against 4.5 to 5.2. The lean flips by criterion, so this page declares no overall winner.
Choose Mollie if
Your finance team needs settlement reports that itemise fees per payout, export as CSV, PDF, MT940 and CODA, and payouts that land in 1–3 business days via SEPA — settlement and reconciliation leans Mollie 7.0 to 4.2 with six judges.
You need to budget payment costs from a public per-method rate card before signing — pricing transparency leans Mollie 7.7 to 4.0 with six judges.
Your checkout depends on breadth of payment methods at launch — payment methods leans Mollie 7.0 to 5.7 with six judges.
You need a provider licensed by De Nederlandsche Bank with legal entity jurisdiction NL — licence and account terms leans Mollie 6.8 to 4.0 with six judges.
Choose PAYONE if
You sell low-value items and rely on SCA exemptions — checkout and SCA leans PAYONE 7.2 to 6.0 with six judges, on documented low-value exemptions below 30 € with the five-transaction and 100 € caps.
You need automatic soft-decline recovery with liability written down for both exemption flows — the same checkout and SCA lean applies.
Your audits require acquirer transaction risk analysis inside the exemption decisioning — again checkout and SCA, 7.2 to 6.0, six judges leaning PAYONE.
Your compliance file requires a legal entity jurisdiction of France — PAYONE's sovereignty attribute reads FR.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The E-Commerce Lead
Sells to customers in eight EU countries and is measured on conversion. Wants the local methods each market actually uses named per country, a checkout that stays on her domain, and 3-D Secure that challenges only when it must. Reads "100+ payment methods" as a count, not a list.
Mollie
This judge's pick
PAYONE
Criterion by criterion
Payment methods & local coverage
Mollie
This is a named list, not just a count: BLIK, TWINT, Przelewy24, EPS, Bancontact, Bizum, Multibanco, Belfius, KBC and MB Way sit alongside cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and SEPA Direct Debit, and the pricing pages group methods per market — Klarna carries separate rates per country group and Wero is shown for Germany, France and Belgium with 0,32 € for domestic Netherlands, while checkout method ordering is tuned per country with A/B testing. I found no public information on a per-method matrix of currencies, refund support and recurring support; recurring is documented only as requiring SEPA Direct Debit or a credit card.
PAYONE
The developer docs are plannable for two families — Klarna with twelve named countries, seven currencies, refunds and capture rules, and SEPA Direct Debit with its country list and mandate lifecycle — plus girocard participation terms and Visa, MasterCard and American Express named in passing. For the rest of my markets, we found no public information naming iDEAL, Bancontact, EPS, BLIK or TWINT, and the homepage sells "alle gängigen Bezahlverfahren" with contactless via smartphone as the only wallet signal.
Checkout, SCA & fraud
Mollie
The checkout is hosted with logo and pay-button colour configurable and using it is optional with a custom checkout supported, but I found no public information on a checkout that runs on my own domain. I found no public information on SCA exemption handling, per-integration PCI scope, exposed risk scores or authorisation-rate reporting, and the captured pages describe chargeback liability differently — one says 3DS2 helps avoid liability for certain fraud chargebacks, while the terms make me fully liable for chargebacks including those resulting from Dynamic 3DS.
PAYONE
The Exemption Engine requests frictionless first, applies the low-value exemption below 30 € and acquirer transaction risk analysis, and auto-recovers via soft decline when the issuer refuses, with SCA exclusions like MOTO detected automatically and fraud scoring modules alongside hosted, tokenized, server-to-server and mobile integration modes. Liability is written down both ways — the issuer covers fraud on 3-D Secure while the merchant carries fraudulent exemptions. We found no public information on authorisation-rate reporting by method or issuer country, PCI scope per integration beyond "Low PCI requirements", or an embedded checkout on the merchant's own domain.
Subscriptions & recurring payments
Mollie
The mandate flow is proper: a first payment takes customer consent and creates a mandate via the Mandates API, the Subscriptions API then spawns scheduled charges automatically with create, update and cancel endpoints, variable amounts and credit top-ups are supported, and failed payments are retried up to five times, once a day, before the subscription is cancelled with the mandate revoked; recurring is included at no extra cost. For scale I found no public information on trials, proration, dunning, a card account updater, or any process for exporting my payment tokens to another provider.
PAYONE
SEPA mandates are first-class: create standalone or inside a payment, reuse via an existing mandate reference also for card-on-file, revoke through a dedicated endpoint, RECURRING mandates valid for an indefinite run, a 36-month lifecycle and an 8-week contestation window, with webhooks delivering declines. For subscription logic itself — trials, proration, plan changes, smart retries, dunning, account updater, or exporting payment tokens to another provider — we found no public information.
Settlement, reconciliation & API
Mollie
Each Settlement Report breaks a payout into revenue, deductions and costs — with payment method fees, chargeback fees, refund fees and notification fees itemised — and exports come in CSV, PDF, MT940 and CODA so my finance team can match bank lines; there is a Settlements API with per-transaction detail, an accounting connection powered by Bizcuit, payouts stated as 1–3 business days via SEPA, and API rate limits visible in the dashboard. I found no public information on configurable payout schedules, API versioning or idempotency, a deprecation policy, or interchange and scheme fees itemised per transaction.
PAYONE
The developer platform is real — documented APIs, webhooks, status transitions with a five-day finality rule and a test environment with test cases — but the money side gives me FAQ titles only: viewing payouts, payout timing, changing the payout cycle, and limits and fees with no values stated, plus merchant customer portals. The payout cadence, fee itemisation per transaction and reconciliation exports to match a bank statement did not appear in the captured pages.
Licence, risk & account terms
Mollie
The regulated chain is named and numbered: Mollie B.V. is licensed for payment services under the Dutch Financial Supervision Act, supervised by De Nederlandsche Bank under number F0038, and all customer payments are received by Stichting Mollie Payments, a safeguarding foundation also included in DNB supervision, with PCI DSS level 1 certification published. Reserve amounts may be set on transaction volume and refund ratios with possible minimum and maximum amounts, but I found no public information on reserve release timelines, passporting per country, or a chargeback fee amount, and the terms make me fully liable for chargebacks with a right to set off against my balance.
PAYONE
The licence layer is properly public: PAYONE GmbH of Frankfurt, registered at Amtsgericht Frankfurt under HRB 116860, licensed and supervised by BaFin as an E-Geld-Institut, owned by Worldline and the DSV-Gruppe. The bad-day terms thin out after that — chargebacks appear in support FAQs but the captures show no published fee, and for safeguarding of merchant funds, reserves, and freeze or termination notice periods we found no public information; online contract termination exists as a service option.
European sovereignty
Mollie
Contracting lands on Mollie B.V. in Amsterdam with a DNB licence, though UK customers may be contracted with the FCA-registered Mollie UK Ltd. The processing location of payment data is not stated on the pages I read; transfers outside the EEA are confirmed with EU standard contractual clauses as the safeguard, and subprocessors appear only as categories — infrastructure plus customer-service, marketing, CRM and email SaaS — with Ekata (Mastercard) named for onboarding fraud checks and no locations given. I found no public information on hosting locations or a data processing agreement covering payment processing.
PAYONE
European at the entity layer: a German contracting entity, a BaFin licence, European ownership through Worldline of Paris and the German DSV-Gruppe, all group companies seated within the EU/EEA, and GDPR information documents for merchants and end customers. The captured pages do not state where payment and cardholder data are processed or stored, and we found no public information on a data processing agreement; the third-country transfers mentioned rely on standard contractual clauses and adequacy decisions.
Pricing transparency
Mollie
I can nearly compute my own invoice from public pages: cards are split into consumer, commercial and non-EEA rates (Mastercard EEA consumer cards at 1,80 % + 0,25 €, non-EEA cards at 3,25 % + 0,25 €), local methods each carry a rate from iDEAL | Wero at 0,42 € to BLIK at 1,60 % + 0,25 €, Klarna and Wero are priced per country group, and the two per cent currency markup, the 1 % foreign-currency payout fee and five free payouts a month are all stated, with no monthly fee, no minimum and no fixed term on the standard plan and IC++ available from a 100.000 € monthly volume. Rates exclude VAT. The gaps: I found no public chargeback fee, volume rates are individual rather than published tiers, and PayPal is quoted as "PayPal-Gebühren + 0,10 €", which I cannot compute from Mollie's pages.
PAYONE
Packages are priced publicly — Starter at 49,00 € one-off and 0,00 € monthly with "0,99 € + Disagio" per transaction, Pro at 99,00 € one-off and 19,00 € per month with "ab 0,09 € + Disagio" — but no Disagio percentage appears in the captured pages, so an effective rate for my card and country mix cannot be computed. Payout limits and fees are an FAQ topic without values, the Individual package is "individuell" throughout, and the POS price lists are PDF downloads whose contents the captures do not show.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Mollie
PAYONE
Legal entity
Incorporated in NL
Incorporated in FR
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mollie higher: 3/5 against 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mollie and 0 pick PAYONE. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Mollie or PAYONE European?
Mollie is European (EU-Made, Netherlands). PAYONE is European (EU-Made, France). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.