As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mollie 3/5 and PAYONE 2.5/5 in Payment. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mollie and 0 pick PAYONE. Mollie scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency, Settlement, reconciliation & API, Licence, risk & account terms, plus 2 more). PAYONE scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Checkout, SCA & fraud). Provenance — Mollie: EU-Made, Netherlands; PAYONE: EU-Made, France. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Mollie's means run higher in five of seven criteria: payment methods 7.0 to 5.7, settlement and reconciliation 7.0 to 4.2, licence and account terms 6.8 to 4.0 and pricing transparency 7.7 to 4.0 — six judges lean Mollie on each of those four — plus recurring billing 6.0 to 5.7, where two judges lean Mollie and four tie. PAYONE holds checkout and SCA at 7.2 to 6.0, six judges leaning PAYONE and none leaning Mollie. Sovereignty is 4.0 apiece with six ties; jurisdiction attributes read NL for Mollie and FR for PAYONE, while data residency, hosting options, the data processing agreement and the transfer impact assessment read unknown for both — we found no public information on where either processes payment data. Mollie leads the five weighted totals shown, 5.9 to 6.7 against 4.5 to 5.2. The lean flips by criterion, so this page declares no overall winner.
Choose Mollie if
Your finance team needs settlement reports that itemise fees per payout, export as CSV, PDF, MT940 and CODA, and payouts that land in 1–3 business days via SEPA — settlement and reconciliation leans Mollie 7.0 to 4.2 with six judges.
You need to budget payment costs from a public per-method rate card before signing — pricing transparency leans Mollie 7.7 to 4.0 with six judges.
Your checkout depends on breadth of payment methods at launch — payment methods leans Mollie 7.0 to 5.7 with six judges.
You need a provider licensed by De Nederlandsche Bank with legal entity jurisdiction NL — licence and account terms leans Mollie 6.8 to 4.0 with six judges.
Choose PAYONE if
You sell low-value items and rely on SCA exemptions — checkout and SCA leans PAYONE 7.2 to 6.0 with six judges, on documented low-value exemptions below 30 € with the five-transaction and 100 € caps.
You need automatic soft-decline recovery with liability written down for both exemption flows — the same checkout and SCA lean applies.
Your audits require acquirer transaction risk analysis inside the exemption decisioning — again checkout and SCA, 7.2 to 6.0, six judges leaning PAYONE.
Your compliance file requires a legal entity jurisdiction of France — PAYONE's sovereignty attribute reads FR.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Skeptic
Knows the headline rate covers the cheapest card in the cheapest country. Reads for the currency conversion markup, the chargeback fee, the payout delay and the clause that lets the provider freeze funds without a reason — and treats a missing licence number as an answer.
Mollie
This judge's pick
PAYONE
Criterion by criterion
Payment methods & local coverage
Mollie
The named list is broad and real: bank methods from BLIK, Przelewy24 and EPS to TWINT and iDEAL, wallets including Apple Pay and Google Pay, five buy-now-pay-later brands and SEPA Direct Debit, with country-level pricing published for Klarna, Wero, Alma, Billie, Billink and Riverty and multi-currency acceptance stated. Two gaps hold it back from the top: we found no public information stating refund and recurring support method by method — recurring is documented for cards, SEPA Direct Debit, PayPal and directdebit-mandate methods only — and the list of settlement currencies is referenced in the terms but never shown.
PAYONE
Cards (American Express, MasterCard, Visa), SEPA Direct Debit with a long country list, and Klarna's named variants (Pay Now, Pay Later, Pay in 3/4, Billie, Fair Financing) are documented with their currencies, and girocard participation terms are published — that reaches the local-methods level. Wallets appear only as generic contactless payment by smartphone with no Apple Pay or Google Pay named, and we found no public information on iDEAL, Bancontact, EPS, BLIK, TWINT or a per-method matrix of refund and recurring support; girocard is evidenced through a terms document rather than a stated method list.
Checkout, SCA & fraud
Mollie
We found no public information on SCA exemptions — low-value, transaction risk analysis, merchant-initiated — being applied or documented, nor on network tokens, an account updater, risk scores shown to the merchant or authorisation-rate reporting; liability shift is documented only for fraud chargebacks under 3-D Secure, while the merchant remains fully liable for chargebacks generally.
PAYONE
The exemption documentation is unusually candid — low-value thresholds, acquirer transaction risk analysis, the 500 € cap, out-of-scope cases listed, automatic soft-decline recovery when an issuer rejects frictionless flow, and the plain warning that the merchant is liable for fraudulent exemptions, with the issuer covering fraud on authenticated 3-D Secure payments. Four integration modes including hosted checkout and a tokenisation page are named with 3-D Secure steps handled automatically; what I cannot see is the PCI DSS scope of each integration type, an account updater or network tokens, or authorisation-rate reporting.
Subscriptions & recurring payments
Mollie
First-payment consent creates a mandate reachable through a Mandates API, the Subscriptions API schedules, updates and cancels subscriptions, failed payments are retried up to five times once a day, and variable-amount recurring charges run via the Payments API — for cards, SEPA Direct Debit and PayPal, with card and PayPal even supporting a zero-amount first payment. We found no public information on trials, proration, dunning, a card account updater or any process for exporting payment tokens to another provider, and the documentation states plainly that webhooks for subscription status changes are not provided.
PAYONE
SEPA mandates are documented end to end — creation via API or hosted checkout, a dedicated revocation endpoint, a 36-month lifecycle with automatic revocation, recurring mandates valid for an indefinite number of subsequent transactions, a contestation period cut to 8 weeks for valid mandates, and failed payments surfacing through webhook status codes. The subscription layer is thin: we found no public information on trials, proration, plan changes, dunning, an account updater, or a process for exporting payment tokens to another provider.
Settlement, reconciliation & API
Mollie
Each payout comes with a Settlement Report splitting revenue, deductions and itemised costs — payment method fees, chargeback fees, refund fees, notification fees — exportable in CSV, PDF, MT940 and CODA, backed by a Settlements API that drills from aggregated totals to single transactions, a Bizcuit bank connection into accounting software, and a stated 1–3 business day SEPA payout. We found no public information on configurable payout schedules, API versioning or idempotency, and rate limits are shown per account in the dashboard rather than published; a status page is linked but incident history is not documented in what we read.
PAYONE
The payout story on the captured pages is a FAQ index — 'When will I receive my payouts?', 'How can I change my payout cycle?', 'Are there limits or fees for withdrawals?' — with no payout schedule, settlement currency or fee value stated, while the developer side is solid with a documented API, webhooks and a test environment with test cases. We found no public information on fee itemisation per transaction, reconciliation exports that match a bank line, accounting integrations, or a public status page.
Licence, risk & account terms
Mollie
The licence chain is properly written down: Mollie B.V. as an e-money institution under the Dutch Financial Supervision Act, DNB number F0038, Amsterdam chamber of commerce 302.04.462, funds received by the DNB-supervised Stichting Mollie Payments, PCI-DSS level 1 certification, and a UK payment-institute subsidiary at FCA FRN 977968. On a bad day the terms read less comfortingly: reserves are decided at Mollie's discretion from volume and refund ratios, with possible minimum and maximum amounts but no release timelines, the prohibited-activities list can change at any time without prior notice, unpaid invoices allow termination with immediate effect, and Mollie may set off what you owe against any balance. We found no published chargeback fee figure, no passporting statement per country, and no appeal route in the captured terms.
PAYONE
The imprint names the regulated entity, its supervisor and its licence type — PAYONE GmbH, admitted and supervised by BaFin as an E-Geld-Institut — together with the commercial register entry, and chargeback handling is addressed in the support FAQs with a CreditorID service that reduces chargeback risk. But the pages I read publish no chargeback fee, no safeguarding statement for merchant funds, and no reserve, freeze or termination terms — the general terms exist as downloads whose contents the captured pages do not show.
European sovereignty
Mollie
The contracting and regulated entity is European — Mollie B.V., Keizersgracht 126, Amsterdam, licensed and supervised by De Nederlandsche Bank — but the privacy policy itself states that transfers outside the EEA take place under EU standard contractual clauses, and we found no public information on where payment and cardholder data are processed or stored. Subprocessors are disclosed only as categories — infrastructure, customer service, marketing, CRM, email — plus one named fraud-prevention processor without locations, Mollie describes itself as data processor only for its invoicing product, and UK customers may additionally contract with Mollie UK Ltd under the FCA.
PAYONE
A German contracting and regulated entity with a BaFin e-money licence, European ownership — Worldline of Paris and the Deutscher Sparkassen Verlag — and a privacy policy stating that all group companies are seated in the EU/EEA, with standard contractual clauses and adequacy decisions for third-country transfers. But the processing location of payment and cardholder data is not stated, no subprocessor list with locations for the processing chain is published — the listed tools are website analytics — and no data processing agreement offer is evidenced.
Pricing transparency
Mollie
Rates are published per method to the cent — iDEAL | Wero 0,42 €, BLIK 1,60 % + 0,25 €, TWINT 2,30 % + 0,25 €, Przelewy24 2,20 % + 0,25 € — with cards tiered into EEA consumer 1,80 % + 0,25 €, EEA commercial 2,90 % + 0,25 € and non-EEA 3,25 % + 0,25 €, a two per cent currency conversion markup, 1 % per foreign-currency payout, 0,25 € per payout after five free ones a month, and no minimum fees or fixed terms. What we could not find: a chargeback fee figure — the fee appears only as a named cost category — Apple Pay priced only by the underlying card, PayPal only as PayPal-Gebühren + 0,10 €, and IC++ pricing available solely as an individual quote from 100.000 € volume.
PAYONE
The E-Com plans publish their billing periods honestly — 49,00 € one-time setup with 0,00 € monthly for Starter, 99,00 € setup and 19,00 € per month for Pro, transaction prices '0,99 € + Disagio' and 'ab 0,09 € + Disagio' — but the Disagio itself, the rate that decides the real cost, is not quantified on the captured pages, and the top tier is priced 'individuell'. We found no public information on currency conversion markups, chargeback fees or payout fee values — the payout FAQ raises limits and fees without stating them — and downloadable price schedules for the card and POS tariffs exist whose contents the pages do not show.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Mollie
PAYONE
Legal entity
Incorporated in NL
Incorporated in FR
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Mollie higher: 3/5 against 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Mollie and 0 pick PAYONE. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Mollie or PAYONE European?
Mollie is European (EU-Made, Netherlands). PAYONE is European (EU-Made, France). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.