As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates Agorapulse 3.5/5 and Fanpage Karma 3/5 in Social Media Marketing. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Agorapulse and 0 pick Fanpage Karma. Agorapulse scores higher on 6 of 6 criteria (Engagement & community inbox, Approvals, roles & brand safety, Publishing & calendar, plus 3 more). Provenance — Agorapulse: EU-Made, France; Fanpage Karma: EU-Made, Germany. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Agorapulse's means are higher on the seven criteria scored, and the leans sit with it: 6 judges lean Agorapulse on publishing (7.0 vs 5.8), the engagement inbox (7.7 vs 5.8), collaboration and governance (7.7 vs 5.8) and pricing transparency (5.8 vs 2.8); 5 lean Agorapulse with 1 tie on platform coverage (7.0 vs 6.2); and 4 lean Agorapulse with 2 ties on analytics and reporting (7.5 vs 6.8) and on sovereignty (5.0 vs 4.2). Fanpage Karma draws 0 leans on each criterion — the table's departures from Agorapulse are ties, not reversals. Fanpage Karma's best criterion is analytics and reporting at 6.8, where its verdict cites five of six judges at 7; pricing transparency is unweighted in its verdicts, as the vendor publishes no prices. Both products' data residency attribute reads EU-only; Fanpage Karma lists a self-serve data processing agreement, Agorapulse's entry reads unknown.
Choose Agorapulse if
You need an inbox that collects comments, direct messages, mentions, reviews and ad comments with assignment and sentiment tracking — 6 judges lean Agorapulse on the engagement inbox (7.7 vs 5.8).
Your approval workflows need unlimited steps, external shared-calendar reviewers and read-only locked posts — 6 judges lean Agorapulse on collaboration and governance (7.7 vs 5.8).
You need published prices before a sales call — Agorapulse prices three tiers publicly per user per month billed annually, and 6 judges lean it on pricing transparency (5.8 vs 2.8).
You publish across many networks — 6 judges lean Agorapulse on publishing (7.0 vs 5.8) and 5 on platform coverage (7.0 vs 6.2).
Your reviewers require a French legal entity with EU-only data residency — Agorapulse's jurisdiction attribute reads FR, its residency attribute reads EU-only, and 4 judges lean it on sovereignty (5.0 vs 4.2).
Choose Fanpage Karma if
You need a self-serve data processing agreement — Fanpage Karma's sovereignty attributes list one, while Agorapulse's entry reads unknown.
Your work is analytics-first — five of six judges scored Fanpage Karma 7 on analytics and reporting, its best criterion, where 2 judges scored the two products tied.
Your reports must export to Excel or CSV — Fanpage Karma's verdict lists exports to PDF, Excel, PowerPoint and CSV.
You must contract with a German legal entity — Fanpage Karma's jurisdiction attribute reads DE, and its data residency attribute reads EU-only.
You want to start without payment details — Fanpage Karma's free tier covers unlimited profiles and team members at 100 posts per profile per month, no payment details required, and its pricing routes through a demo rather than a published price.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Brand Governance Officer
Answers to the board for what appears on the corporate account. Wants enforced approval before anything publishes, an audit trail of who wrote and released it, granular permissions, and no shared credentials anywhere in the design.
Agorapulse
This judge's pick
Fanpage Karma
Criterion by criterion
Publishing & calendar
Agorapulse
The calendar is a genuine working surface — month, week, list and Instagram grid views, filters and saved views, keyword search, bulk actions of up to two hundred posts, calendar notes and a ten-thousand-post display ceiling — with per-network formats including stories, reels and shorts, a queued state, and a visible failed-to-publish status. We found no public information on best-time suggestions, link shortening with UTM tags, or a documented retry on failure, which is what keeps it short of the top band.
Fanpage Karma
A centralized calendar is documented for scheduling posts, stories, reels and videos across Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Threads, TikTok, YouTube and Bluesky, with automated publishing stated for all seven, plus media library, campaigns and labels. The analytics pages also document top-performing posting times as discovery. We found no public information on bulk upload, link shortening with UTM tags, or what happens when a scheduled post fails, so dependability at volume is not documented.
Engagement & community inbox
Agorapulse
The inbox behaves like a service queue: comments, direct messages, mentions, reviews and ad comments in one place, with assignment and review, saved replies, sentiment tracking, automated moderation rules, hide and delete handling, bulk actions, per-network sync windows and a CSV export of conversations. We found no public information on response-time or SLA tracking, escalation to a helpdesk, or a per-person history spanning networks.
Fanpage Karma
Engage is documented as community management for inquiries, posts and comments across platforms and by email, with all profiles in a single inbox, templates, automated workflows and AI-drafted replies. We found no public information on assignment ownership with read or done states, response-time tracking, spam handling, per-person conversation history, or escalation to a helpdesk, so the service-desk level is not documented.
Analytics & reporting
Agorapulse
Reporting has agency-grade structure: a custom Report Studio on a widget grid with templates including a Meta organic-paid split, competitor benchmarking, audience demographics widgets, PDF and PPTX exports with scheduled automated exports, and plan-based retention of six, twelve or twenty-four months that extends beyond the networks' own sync windows, with the per-network differences in historical sync documented openly. We found no public information on white-labelling beyond a report image or logo, or on UTM-based attribution into web analytics, and retention is capped by plan and starts only around profile connection.
Fanpage Karma
Analytics covers own and third-party profiles across the major networks with unlimited-profile benchmarking, competitor and historical comparison, Meta Ads ROI analysis, and customizable reports exportable as PDF, Excel, PowerPoint or CSV and shareable online with clients. We found no public information on white-label client reporting, UTM-based attribution into web analytics, or retention beyond the one year of data storage stated for the free tier.
Approvals, roles & brand safety
Agorapulse
This is the discipline I answer to the board for: two levels of roles (organisation-level, plus per-profile Admin, Editor, Moderator, Guest) with a permissions matrix spanning inbox, publishing, analytics, library, drafts and queues; unlimited-step approval workflows scoped to selected profiles; posts automatically locked read-only once a workflow applies; internal notes hidden from external reviewers; and help pages that explicitly tell teams not to connect accounts with a shared personal Facebook profile. What holds it below the top band is that the documented audit trail is application-level logging rather than a shown per-user history of edits, approvals and publications, and admins and editors can still publish directly, so approval is not enforced for every role — and workflow creation sits behind the Custom plan.
Fanpage Karma
Approval workflows are documented and real: simple approval processes with colleagues and clients, guest users who can gather feedback and approve content, idea voting, and separate workspaces for each brand with unlimited team members. We found no public information on an enforced approval gate that blocks unapproved posts from reaching a network, granular permissions per social account, content locking after approval, or an audit trail of who wrote, changed and released each item — and without that trail I could not sign this off for a regulated account.
Network coverage & API resilience
Agorapulse
Coverage is broad and honestly documented: Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok, YouTube, Threads, Bluesky, Pinterest and Google Business through official platform APIs, with per-network capabilities and limitations spelled out in the help centre (carousel unsupported on Facebook, no Threads analytics, Bluesky constraints) and a system status page published. X is reachable only through paid add-ons per connected profile, and we found no public information on an integration changelog, advance notice of platform deprecations, or full export of the customer's own publishing and engagement archive.
Fanpage Karma
Automated publishing is documented for seven networks including the newer Threads and Bluesky, analytics covers Facebook, X, Instagram, YouTube, Pinterest and LinkedIn, and other networks can be scheduled and then published via the Publish app. We found no public information on a changelog or status page for integrations, advance notice of platform deprecations, official partner status, or export of the customer's own publishing and engagement archive.
European sovereignty
Agorapulse
The contracting entity is Agorapulse SAS of Paris under French data-protection law with a stated controller-processor split, and customer data is hosted in the AWS Ireland region — two European elements proven. But the service runs on a US-operated cloud, the privacy policy names third-party service providers whose locations are not disclosed, and we found no public information on a data processing agreement, so the chain is only partly established.
Fanpage Karma
A German contracting entity is proven — Fanpage Karma is a product of uphill GmbH, Oranienstr. 188, 10999 Berlin, registered at Amtsgericht Berlin — with a named data protection officer, a data processing agreement listed under Rechtliches, TLS encryption, IP masking, and international transfers only under standard contractual clauses or equivalent safeguards. The captured privacy policy names no server or hosting location, its data-residency statement is a negative assertion with exceptions on customer request, and we found no public information on a subprocessor list with locations or published certification.
Pricing transparency
Agorapulse
Three tiers are publicly priced per user per month on annual billing (Standard 79.00, Professional 119.00, Advanced 149.00 EUR, with ten social profiles per user on Standard), feature boundaries are documented across the help centre, and the X add-ons are priced at $/€29 and $/€69 per connected profile per month — so a buyer can see the inbox begins on Standard and approvals from single-step on Professional with workflow creation on Custom. The Custom tier carries no public price, and we found no public information on the cost of an extra account or seat, terms beyond annual billing, or VAT treatment.
Fanpage Karma
The only priced offering on the captured pages is the free tier with its limits stated — unlimited profiles, unlimited team members, "100 posts per profile per month", one year of data storage — alongside "Publish is now free" and "Start for Free" with no payment details required. We found no public prices for any paid tier, no billing period and no per-account or per-seat cost, so a real annual invoice for paid functionality cannot be computed from the captured pages.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Agorapulse
Fanpage Karma
Legal entity
Incorporated in FR
Incorporated in DE
Hosting location
EU only
EU only
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates Agorapulse higher: 3.5/5 against 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Agorapulse and 0 pick Fanpage Karma. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Agorapulse or Fanpage Karma European?
Agorapulse is European (EU-Made, France). Fanpage Karma is European (EU-Made, Germany). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Agorapulse and Fanpage Karma store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Agorapulse: In the EU; pages mention Ireland. Fanpage Karma: In the EU.