As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates d.vinci 3/5 and softgarden 2/5 in Recruiting. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick d.vinci and 4 pick softgarden. d.vinci scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (AI screening transparency & control, Pricing transparency, European sovereignty, plus 2 more). softgarden scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Retention, deletion & talent-pool consent and Applicant management & hiring workflow). Provenance — d.vinci: EU-Made, Germany; softgarden: EU-Made, Germany. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The benches split, and no overall winner emerges. d.vinci holds the higher means on AI screening control (8.0 vs 5.0; four judges lean d.vinci, two ties), pricing transparency (5.2 vs 2.7; five lean d.vinci), sovereignty (7.0 vs 4.8), job distribution (6.7 vs 4.8; 2–2 with two ties) and integrations and handover (6.0 vs 4.5; three lean softgarden). softgarden leads candidate pipeline (4.7 vs 4.3) and applicant data governance (4.0 vs 3.5), four judges leaning its way on each. On weighted totals, softgarden is higher for four judges — Employer Branding (6.4 vs 5.8), Works Council (7 vs 5.6), HR IT Integrator (6.3 vs 5.9), Skeptic (6.7 vs 6) — and d.vinci for the Talent Acquisition Lead (5.5 vs 0) and Data Protection Officer (6.1 vs 0), whose softgarden rationales, per the verdict, assessed the same pages without saying why. Both list German legal-entity jurisdiction, EU-only data residency and a self-serve data-processing agreement.
Choose d.vinci if
You need documented control over AI screening: d.vinci's mean is 8.0 vs softgarden's 5.0, with four judges leaning d.vinci and none leaning softgarden; the verdict cites a published, regularly updated AI guideline, the vendor's own EU AI Act high-risk classification, named providers (Azure AI, OpenAI via VONQ, DeepL), AI servers stated to be in the EU and a stated human final decision.
Your procurement needs published from-prices across the stack: d.vinci lists ab 785 € pro Monat for the core system and fully tiered career pages from 399€/Monat to 1.399€/Monat, each zzgl. MwSt., while softgarden's pages price only Core ("ab 199 € / Monat") with All-in-One individually priced; five judges lean d.vinci on pricing transparency (5.2 vs 2.7).
Your buying committee weights the sovereignty criterion: d.vinci's mean there is 7.0 vs 4.8, with two judges leaning d.vinci, one softgarden and three ties; the verdict cites AI servers stated to be in the EU.
You need onboarding and a career-page builder alongside applicant management in one purchase: d.vinci's published scope covers applicant management, onboarding and a career-page builder priced on employee count.
Choose softgarden if
Your team needs candidate-pipeline handling: softgarden's mean is 4.7 vs 4.3 and four judges lean its way on that criterion.
Your data-protection review turns on product-level applicant-data tools: softgarden's mean is 4.0 vs 3.5 with four judges leaning its way; d.vinci's verdict notes its published material stops short of product-level deletion settings, access logs, scorecards or a decision trail.
You post jobs across many boards at once: softgarden multiposts to more than 1,200 job boards plus social media and Google Ads — job distribution drew an 8 from the Works Council Advocate and 7s from three other judges, though the criterion's leans split 2–2 with two ties.
You need named German data centres and a stated absence of third-country transfers of applicant data: softgarden's verdict records both, alongside its German legal-entity jurisdiction and EU-only data residency.
You want AI screening switched off unless you turn it on: softgarden's assistant is disabled by default and shows full, partial or no match per criterion — evidence two judges scored 8 on AI screening control, even though d.vinci's mean is higher there (8.0 vs 5.0).
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The HR IT Integrator
Has to connect the ATS to the HR system, the calendar and identity. Wants a documented API, SSO that is not an enterprise upsell, and a hire that arrives in Personio or SAP with its documents rather than as a PDF someone retypes. Judges integrations by who maintains them.
d.vinci
softgarden
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Applicant management & hiring workflow
d.vinci
Custom workflows and configurable roles and rights, unlimited users, centralised candidate communication, Microsoft Teams for video interviews and reporting that exports to Excel or BI tools make a working pipeline — and requisitions (Personalanforderungen) are explicitly part of it. I found no public information on interview scheduling with calendar integration, structured scorecards, or a per-candidate history of who changed which status, so a decision gets made but its trail is not evidenced. The structured evaluation apparatus around the prescreening engine is published in detail but that engine is marked coming soon.
softgarden
This is a real pipeline product: freely definable evaluation criteria as reusable templates, structured scorecards, private notes, interview invitations sent from the system, and bulk actions such as rejections and confirmation emails with AGG-compliant templates are all documented. The system history logs access attempts and every changing operation on records, which gets close to an attributable trail of decisions, and Time-to-Hire and Time-to-Interview dashboards exist. We found no public information on approval workflows for requisitions and offers, or on hiring-manager access restricted to their own vacancies.
Multiposting, career page & candidate experience
d.vinci
Multiposting runs to named boards including StepStone, Monster and Jobware, the Bundesagentur für Arbeit and Google for Jobs are covered, booking happens directly from the system, and the career pages are CI-conform, multilingual and barrier-free to a stated standard (WCAG 2.2 AA / BSFG), with WhatsApp, XING and LinkedIn apply paths for candidates on a phone. The captured pages give different figures for the reachable boards — over 500, over 1,500 international, and around 40 preconfigured interfaces — so I take the range rather than a number. I found no public information on budget tracking per board, source attribution per applicant or an embeddable widget, and one-click apply appears only on the roadmap.
softgarden
Multiposting to more than 1,200 job boards plus social media and Google Ads is documented, with Xing, LinkedIn and Indeed named for direct applications and a flow in which ads go online automatically after purchase completion. The career page builder is stated to meet WCAG under the new EU accessibility rules, is mobile-optimised, supports up to 18 languages with job embeds via iFrame or API, and conversion rates and entry channels are analysed per ad. We found no public information on Bundesagentur für Arbeit coverage, budget tracking per board, or candidates seeing their own status and withdrawing themselves.
Retention, deletion & talent-pool consent
d.vinci
GDPR compliance is stated, the data-processing agreement and TOMs are published, ISO 27001 has been held since 2011 with customer audits and customer pentests explicitly allowed, and the vendor documents the six-month deletion practice with a talent-pool consent exception and consent rules for referrals. What I found no public information on is a configurable automatic deletion run, a log of who viewed or exported an applicant file, a documented way to answer access and erasure requests, or retention rules per entity — what is published reads as legal guidance for employers rather than governance features of the product.
softgarden
Automated deletion of applicant data, configurable by the controller, with a recommended retention period of six months, plus a logged system history covering access attempts, record changes and PDF downloads of applications. Data-subject rights and a four-week answer deadline are documented, and special categories of personal data are recorded in the annex to the data processing agreement. We found no public information on talent-pool consent with expiry, retention rules per country or entity, or how deletion propagates to backups and the synced job boards.
AI screening transparency & control
d.vinci
This is the most complete AI disclosure I have read from a recruiting vendor: the vendor states outright that its AI counts as high-risk under the EU AI Act, every AI function carries a sparkle marker whose click explains purpose and data basis, prescreening reasoning is shown per criterion with recruiters setting Muss and Kann criteria, and candidates' information duty and the human final decision are both stated. Model providers are named (Azure AI, OpenAI via VONQ, DeepL), AI servers sit in the EU with logged access and encryption, customer data is stated not to train models, and bias management plus monitoring with synthetic-data tests are described. Two gaps hold me back: I found no public information on retaining logs of every AI-assisted decision for audit, and the default state of the switchable features is not stated — while the prescreening engine itself is marked coming soon.
softgarden
The AI Screening Assistant is documented as completely optional and disabled by default for all customers until activated in account settings, generates job-specific criteria the recruiter can adapt, and shows per candidate and per criterion whether the match is complete, partial or none — with the vendor stating the decision always stays with the human and no one is automatically excluded. The vendor also states GDPR conformity and alignment with the EU AI Act, that AI inputs and outputs are deleted immediately and not used to train models, and Textkernel appears as a named CV-parsing provider. We found no public information on informing candidates when AI is used, on protected attributes being excluded, or on bias testing and retained logs of AI-assisted decisions.
HR handover, integrations & API
d.vinci
The SAP HCM integration, built with partner sensatus, is exactly the handover I want: a final status change pushes all applicant data and application attachments, starts the master-data creation in an SAP Fiori form, and files contracts and application documents in the digital personnel file — a hire that arrives with its documents rather than as a PDF someone retypes. Beyond that the picture thins: Microsoft Teams for video interviews, an email interface to agencies and publishers, Excel and BI exports, and vague 'interfaces for connecting various partners'; I found no public information on connections to Personio or DATEV-connected systems, SSO, SCIM, e-signature, webhooks, or API documentation with published limits.
softgarden
Personio and SAP SuccessFactors are named integrations alongside automated interfaces to common ERP systems, single sign-on with the company identity provider, Microsoft Teams with Smart Calendar, and a marketplace of 65 automated integrations bookable as add-ons — which reads as vendor-maintained rather than customer-glued. Jobs can be embedded on our own site via iFrame or API. We found no public information on a documented general API with published limits, webhooks, SCIM, e-signature for offers and contracts, or whether the handover into the HR system carries the hire's documents and consent status.
European sovereignty
d.vinci
The contracting entity is d.vinci HR-Systems GmbH in Hamburg with a Hamburg data centre hosting development and support, an EU entity with a publishable AVV and TOMs, ISO 27001 certification, and AI servers stated to be in the EU with named providers including OpenAI via VONQ. The privacy policy discloses subprocessors with locations — including non-EU ones such as Dovetail in Australia and Figma on US servers — which is honest disclosure, though those read as the vendor's own website, webinar and support tools rather than processors touching applicant records. Not established on the captured pages: whether all customer data stays in that Hamburg centre, who the hosting infrastructure provider is, and how deletion propagates outward.
softgarden
A German contracting entity in Berlin, hosting in named ISO 27001-certified data centres run by WIIT and Equinix in Frankfurt and Düsseldorf, a self-serve data processing agreement that can be digitally signed, a statement that no third-country transfer of applicant data occurs, and a subprocessor list in the terms of use naming providers with locations including Textkernel for CV parsing. The same page discloses that support requests handled via Intercom can involve a transfer of the requesting user's business email address to the USA, so ancillary support data sits outside the no-transfer statement. We found no public information on ownership of the vendor or on where the ChatGPT-based text generation processes its input.
Pricing transparency
d.vinci
The career-page product is priced per tier with billing period and VAT treatment (Basic 399 €/Monat, Plus 699 €/Monat, Scale 1.399 €/Monat, each zzgl. MwSt), the applicant management is 'ab 785 € pro Monat' and onboarding 'ab 1.020 € pro Monat', and the stated pricing basis is the company's employee count. But the captured pages do not publish the employee-count bands, so the real annual invoice is not computable from them, and implementation workshop costs are flagged without figures while job-board connection costs are left to negotiation with each board. Partially offsetting: support is included in the price, the base multiposting is stated free, and a free test is offered.
softgarden
One tier is priced publicly — Core from 199 € / Monat, with all prices stated exclusive of VAT and a stated basis of five included jobs and unlimited users — while the All-in-One tier is individually priced around hiring volume, so the annual invoice is not computable from public pages alone. Job-ad packages are advertised at up to 47 % savings against the list price with up to four free job platforms, but we found no public posting costs per board, no add-on prices for the marketplace interfaces, and no stated minimum term.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
d.vinci
softgarden
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Incorporated in DE
Hosting location
EU only
EU only
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates d.vinci higher: 3/5 against 2/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick d.vinci and 4 pick softgarden. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is d.vinci or softgarden European?
d.vinci is European (EU-Made, Germany). softgarden is European (EU-Made, Germany). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do d.vinci and softgarden store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — d.vinci: In the EU. softgarden: In the EU; pages mention Germany.