As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates d.vinci 3/5 and softgarden 2/5 in Recruiting. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick d.vinci and 4 pick softgarden. d.vinci scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (AI screening transparency & control, Pricing transparency, European sovereignty, plus 2 more). softgarden scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Retention, deletion & talent-pool consent and Applicant management & hiring workflow). Provenance — d.vinci: EU-Made, Germany; softgarden: EU-Made, Germany. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The benches split, and no overall winner emerges. d.vinci holds the higher means on AI screening control (8.0 vs 5.0; four judges lean d.vinci, two ties), pricing transparency (5.2 vs 2.7; five lean d.vinci), sovereignty (7.0 vs 4.8), job distribution (6.7 vs 4.8; 2–2 with two ties) and integrations and handover (6.0 vs 4.5; three lean softgarden). softgarden leads candidate pipeline (4.7 vs 4.3) and applicant data governance (4.0 vs 3.5), four judges leaning its way on each. On weighted totals, softgarden is higher for four judges — Employer Branding (6.4 vs 5.8), Works Council (7 vs 5.6), HR IT Integrator (6.3 vs 5.9), Skeptic (6.7 vs 6) — and d.vinci for the Talent Acquisition Lead (5.5 vs 0) and Data Protection Officer (6.1 vs 0), whose softgarden rationales, per the verdict, assessed the same pages without saying why. Both list German legal-entity jurisdiction, EU-only data residency and a self-serve data-processing agreement.
Choose d.vinci if
You need documented control over AI screening: d.vinci's mean is 8.0 vs softgarden's 5.0, with four judges leaning d.vinci and none leaning softgarden; the verdict cites a published, regularly updated AI guideline, the vendor's own EU AI Act high-risk classification, named providers (Azure AI, OpenAI via VONQ, DeepL), AI servers stated to be in the EU and a stated human final decision.
Your procurement needs published from-prices across the stack: d.vinci lists ab 785 € pro Monat for the core system and fully tiered career pages from 399€/Monat to 1.399€/Monat, each zzgl. MwSt., while softgarden's pages price only Core ("ab 199 € / Monat") with All-in-One individually priced; five judges lean d.vinci on pricing transparency (5.2 vs 2.7).
Your buying committee weights the sovereignty criterion: d.vinci's mean there is 7.0 vs 4.8, with two judges leaning d.vinci, one softgarden and three ties; the verdict cites AI servers stated to be in the EU.
You need onboarding and a career-page builder alongside applicant management in one purchase: d.vinci's published scope covers applicant management, onboarding and a career-page builder priced on employee count.
Choose softgarden if
Your team needs candidate-pipeline handling: softgarden's mean is 4.7 vs 4.3 and four judges lean its way on that criterion.
Your data-protection review turns on product-level applicant-data tools: softgarden's mean is 4.0 vs 3.5 with four judges leaning its way; d.vinci's verdict notes its published material stops short of product-level deletion settings, access logs, scorecards or a decision trail.
You post jobs across many boards at once: softgarden multiposts to more than 1,200 job boards plus social media and Google Ads — job distribution drew an 8 from the Works Council Advocate and 7s from three other judges, though the criterion's leans split 2–2 with two ties.
You need named German data centres and a stated absence of third-country transfers of applicant data: softgarden's verdict records both, alongside its German legal-entity jurisdiction and EU-only data residency.
You want AI screening switched off unless you turn it on: softgarden's assistant is disabled by default and shows full, partial or no match per criterion — evidence two judges scored 8 on AI screening control, even though d.vinci's mean is higher there (8.0 vs 5.0).
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Talent Acquisition Lead
Fills sixty roles a year across three locations with a team of two. Wants pipelines hiring managers actually use, scorecards that make a decision defensible, and multiposting that reaches the German boards without a separate login. Unmoved by a match score she cannot explain to a candidate.
d.vinci
This judge's pick
softgarden
Criterion by criterion
Applicant management & hiring workflow
d.vinci
This is a full applicant management system: workflows and roles/rights are configurable, personnel requisitions and recruiting KPIs are reported, unlimited users can be invited, and Microsoft Teams video interviews are supported. We found no public information on interview scheduling with calendar integration, email templates, structured scorecards, or a per-candidate history of who changed which stage — and without a scorecard I cannot make a rejection defensible. That puts the daily workflow clearly above basics but short of what my hiring managers would actually live in.
softgarden
The applicant-tracking pages document custom stored workflows, structured scorecards with predefined criteria, interview invitations sent from the system, bulk rejections with automated confirmation mails, private notes and reusable rating templates — the kit my two-person team needs to run sixty hires a year defensibly. The privacy pages add a system history logging access attempts and changes to records, and the site publishes recruiting KPIs including time-to-interview and time-to-hire. I found no public information on hiring-manager access restricted to their own vacancies, approval workflows for requisitions and offers, or drop-off reporting per stage, so I stop short of the top.
Multiposting, career page & candidate experience
d.vinci
Publishing runs directly out of the system with preconfigured interfaces to around 40 boards including StepStone and Jobware, a Bundesagentur für Arbeit connection, and Google for Jobs support — the no-second-login setup I want — and the career pages are certified WCAG 2.2 AA, multilingual on higher tiers, with applications via XING, LinkedIn and WhatsApp profiles. We found no public information on budget tracking or booking per board inside the system, source attribution per applicant, or candidates seeing their own status; tracking statistics appear only as planned, and the captured pages give different figures for the number of job boards available.
softgarden
Multiposting to more than 1,200 job boards with direct applications from Xing, LinkedIn and Indeed covers the German market from one login, ads go online automatically right after purchase, and up to four job platforms are included free with ad packages promising up to 47 percent savings versus list price. The career page is strong for my taste: a WCAG-compliant builder, up to 18 languages, embedding via iFrame or API, mobile-optimised with WhatsApp and video applications. I found no public information on the Bundesagentur für Arbeit or Google for Jobs by name, on budget tracking per board inside the system, or on source attribution per applicant.
Retention, deletion & talent-pool consent
d.vinci
GDPR compliance is stated for the applicant system, retention is described as limited to purpose and statutory periods, and the vendor publishes a data protection certificate, an annual data protection officer report and TOM documents. The six-month deletion practice and the consent needed before keeping someone in a talent pool are explained as legal guidance on the vendor's own site, but we found no public information on automatic deletion deadlines configured in the product, consent expiry with re-consent requests, or a log of who viewed an applicant file — the things my company is actually liable for.
softgarden
Automated deletion of applicant data configurable by the customer (six months recommended), logged access attempts, logged downloads of PDF application summaries, and a documented process for data-subject requests answered within four weeks — that is the liability-side evidence I look for before signing. The data processing agreement annex covers special categories, a subcontractor list is published in the terms of use, and DEKRA-certified privacy management is stated. I found no public information on talent-pool consent with expiry or automated re-consent, retention rules per country or entity, or how deletion propagates to backups and synced boards.
AI screening transparency & control
d.vinci
The most forthright AI position I have scored: a published, regularly updated AI policy, the vendor's own classification of its recruitment AI as high-risk under the EU AI Act, AI servers in the EU with logged access and regular backups, named providers in Azure AI, OpenAI via VONQ and DeepL, a statement that customer data is not used to train models, a sparkle icon marking every AI function with an explanation of what it does on click, per-criterion reasoning behind the fit classifications, bias management with regular model review, and the explicit rule that no autonomous decision happens without human review. The prescreening feature is described in detail on one page and marked coming soon on another, so the captured pages give different statuses for it; we found no statement that AI features are off by default — the vendor calls AI native to the product — and no documented retention of logs per AI-assisted decision.
softgarden
This is a match score I can explain to a candidate: the screening assistant is disabled by default for all customers until activated in account settings, matches against criteria the recruiter defines per job (up to ten more can be added), and shows full, partial or no match per criterion and per candidate, with the statement that no one is automatically screened out. Inputs and outputs are deleted immediately and not used to train models, GDPR conformity and alignment with the EU AI Act are stated, and no third-country transfer of applicant data occurs. I found no public information on informing candidates when AI is used, exclusion of protected attributes, bias testing, or retained logs of AI-assisted decisions.
HR handover, integrations & API
d.vinci
The SAP HCM integration, built with partner sensatus, transfers all applicant data and application attachments on a final status change and starts master-data creation in an SAP Fiori form, with contracts and documents filed in a digital personnel file — a genuine handover without retyping. Beyond that we have Microsoft Teams video interviews, prepared interfaces to around 40 job boards, partner interfaces and reporting via Excel or BI tools; we found no public information on connections to other HR systems common in DACH such as Personio or DATEV-connected tools, on SSO or SCIM, e-signature for contracts, webhooks, or an API with published limits.
softgarden
Named handover targets include Personio and SAP SuccessFactors alongside automated interfaces to common ERP systems, within a vendor-maintained marketplace of 65 automated integrations; single sign-on, Microsoft Teams video interviews and an Assessment API with job embedding via iFrame or API are also documented. That covers the DACH names I would insist on. I found no public information on SCIM, webhooks, e-signature for offers and contracts, or an API with published rate limits.
European sovereignty
d.vinci
The contracting entity is d.vinci HR-Systems GmbH in Hamburg (HRB 93221), the data centre, development and support all sit in Hamburg, an AVV and TOM are offered, and ISO 27001 has been held since 2011 with customer audits explicitly allowed. The AI providers are named and the AI servers are stated to be in the EU; the privacy policy also publishes named processors with locations, though those cover services such as website analytics, Figma, Zendesk and Dovetail rather than the applicant product itself. We found no public information on the hosting provider behind the Hamburg data centre or on the job-board subprocessors that applicant data reaches.
softgarden
German contracting entity in Berlin, hosting in named German data centres (WIIT in Frankfurt and Düsseldorf, Equinix), a stated absence of third-country transfers of applicant data, and a self-serve data processing agreement that treats the customer company as controller for applicant data — the core of what I need to put in front of a works council. Subprocessors are listed in the published terms with names including Textkernel for parsing, and ISO 9001, ISO 27001 and DEKRA certification are published. Ownership, the hosting provider behind the AI features, and locations for every subprocessor are not established by the captured pages, and the privacy page itself notes support requests via Intercom can involve a US transfer of the requesting user's business email, so I stay below the top.
Pricing transparency
d.vinci
From-prices are published per module — applicant management from 785 € per month, onboarding from 1020 € per month, career pages from 399 € per month — with monthly billing, the pricing basis stated as employee count, and the three career-page tiers fully priced at 399 €, 699 € and 1.399 € per month plus VAT. But the employee-count scale behind the applicant management from-price is not published, implementation workshop costs are mentioned without amounts, and we found no public information on minimum terms — so I cannot compute the annual cost for my three locations from public pages alone. Base multiposting is stated as free, with pay-per-use beyond it and board connection costs negotiated directly with the boards.
softgarden
Core is published at "ab 199 € / Monat" with five included jobs, unlimited users and prices "zzgl. MwSt.", while All-in-One is "Individuelle Preisgestaltung" matched to hiring volume — one tier priced with its basis and VAT treatment, the flagship tier on request. Four job platforms are free and ad packages promise savings, but package and marketplace add-on prices are not shown. I found no public information on the minimum contract term.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
d.vinci
softgarden
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Incorporated in DE
Hosting location
EU only
EU only
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Published, self-serve
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates d.vinci higher: 3/5 against 2/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 2 of the 6 judges pick d.vinci and 4 pick softgarden. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is d.vinci or softgarden European?
d.vinci is European (EU-Made, Germany). softgarden is European (EU-Made, Germany). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do d.vinci and softgarden store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — d.vinci: In the EU. softgarden: In the EU; pages mention Germany.