As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Element 3.5/5 and Mattermost 3.5/5 in Business Instant Messaging. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Element scores higher on 2 of 6 criteria (European sovereignty and Encryption & access control). Mattermost scores higher on 4 of 6 criteria (Retention, discovery & co-determination, Channels, threads & search, Integrations & extensibility, plus 1 more). Provenance — Element: UK / wider Europe; Mattermost: Rest of world. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
On weighted totals the six benches split: Element leads for the security officer (7 vs 6.9), the works council (6.7 vs 6.3) and the platform engineer (7.7 vs 7.3); Mattermost for the team lead (7.4 vs 6.7), the compliance counsel (7.5 vs 6.5) and the skeptic (6.6 vs 6.3). Element leads encryption and access (9.7 vs 7.5, six judges), sovereignty (5.8 vs 2.7, six judges) and pricing transparency (3.0 vs 0.8; not weighted for Mattermost, which publishes no prices). Mattermost leads messaging core (7.3 vs 6.5, five judges, one tie) and governance and discovery (7.8 vs 6.0, six judges) — its verdict credits legal hold and eDiscovery automation, where we found no public information for Element. Deployment control (9.2 vs 9.3) and integrations (6.8 vs 7.0) each show one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties. No overall winner: the lean flips bench by bench.
Choose Element if
You need end-to-end encryption on by default — encryption and access leans Element 9.7 to 7.5 with six judges; the verdict credits the audited Olm and Megolm protocols, while we found no public information on end-to-end encryption for Mattermost.
Your organization wants hosting options in Europe — sovereignty leans Element 5.8 to 2.7 with six judges, and the verdict credits customer-selectable AWS hosting in Amsterdam and Stockholm.
You want the platform published as open source — Element's open-source attribute reads copyleft.
You must run air-gapped or in a private cloud with vendor support — Element's verdict sells self-hosting on-premise, in a private cloud or air-gapped with vendor support.
You want a free starting tier — Element's Community edition is free to use for up to 100 self-hosted users.
Choose Mattermost if
You need legal hold, eDiscovery automation and compliance exports — governance and discovery leans Mattermost 7.8 to 6.0 with six judges.
Your archive tooling expects specific formats — Mattermost's verdict lists exports to CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML or Proofpoint, with edits and deletions tracked by message identifier and queries logged.
You want the stronger messaging core — five judges lean Mattermost, 7.3 to 6.5, with one tie.
Your engineers want a customer-owned MySQL or PostgreSQL database and air-gapped runbooks with a bill of materials — deployment control stands at 9.3 to 9.2, one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Platform Engineer
Would rather run it than rent it, and wants to know whether that is a supported deployment or a hobby build. Cares about open protocols, federation, a plugin system with real permissions, and an upgrade path that does not orphan the customisations.
Element
This judge's pick
Mattermost
Criterion by criterion
Channels, threads & search
Element
Threads, reactions, attachments, polls and voice messages are documented, Spaces build enterprise-wide hierarchies that can be shared externally under SSO-assigned permissions, search runs even inside encrypted rooms, and history is stated as unlimited. The captured pages are silent on message editing history, pinned and saved items, and search filters by channel, person or date, which is what keeps this short of the top.
Mattermost
Channels public and private, threaded discussions, previews, guest accounts, and full searchable history with all messages and files retained by default — the daily surface is documented, and edits and deletions survive into exports. The search scale limit of three million posts is stated up front, and moving a thread between channels exists but is marked beta. I found no public information on pinned or saved items or on end-user search filters by channel, person and date, so this sits a notch under the top.
Encryption & access control
Element
End-to-end encryption is the default with decryption restricted to conversation participants, built on the named Olm/Megolm protocols and publicly audited by NCC Group, with cross-signed device verification via QR or emoji and per-device decryption. The vendor states plainly that end-to-end encrypted information is never accessed by its teams, and SSO arrives via OIDC/SAML with SCIM provisioning and granular Space-level permissions.
Mattermost
Transport and at-rest encryption are documented honestly, including the plain admission that the database itself carries no internal encryption so search and compliance reporting of message histories keep working. Bring-your-own-key encryption is an optional add-on at the top plan, with MFA, SSO, certificate authentication, session duration configuration and role-based permissions with custom definitions. We found no public information on end-to-end encryption, which caps this below first-class.
Retention, discovery & co-determination
Element
Rules-based retention policies for messages and media, compliance auditing, audit bots and corporate moderation are all documented, and redacted or deprovisioned data is permanently deleted after seven days. I found no public information on legal hold or eDiscovery export, and read receipts appear as a feature without a documented organisation-wide switch-off, so a works council negotiation would start from unanswered questions.
Mattermost
Retention is configurable and stated as per-channel, legal hold and eDiscovery automation are listed features, and the export formats are the ones lawyers' tools ingest — CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML, Proofpoint — with edits, deletions and message tracking across batches, plus audit history on every compliance query and download. Compliance queries filter by date range, user and keyword. We found no public information on switching presence, read receipts or activity analytics off organisation-wide, which is the first thing a works council will ask about, so I hold this one notch below the top band.
Deployment & data custody
Element
Custody is the customer's: AGPL-licensed server components, self-hosting on-premise or in a private cloud with the vendor's own support team, LTS releases every six months with backported security fixes, official Helm charts for GitOps deployment, air-gapped installs, open-protocol federation, and data migration stated as protection against vendor lock-in. The free Community homeserver is flagged as not for production, so the supported self-hosted path is the subscription Pro edition — documented, not a hobby build.
Mattermost
This is the custody story I look for: the same server installed via Kubernetes, Linux or containers with the support boundaries stated plainly, an air-gapped runbook with bill of materials and registry mirroring, full source code, self-hosted subscriptions, and your own MySQL or PostgreSQL database under your internal controls. Federation runs over the Matrix protocol, and exit is a documented operation — export past history by command line, backup strategy set before users arrive — rather than a negotiation. The docs even say container-only installs are not supported for production, which is the kind of honesty that makes an operator trust the rest.
Integrations & extensibility
Element
Webhooks, named bots for GitHub, GitLab, JIRA and RSS, interactive widgets embedded directly in rooms, and full identity plumbing through OIDC, SAML, LDAP and SCIM; the open Matrix standard plus 148 public repositories means extensibility is buildable without a partner agreement. The captured pages are silent on documented rate limits, a sandbox, and app permissions a customer could audit.
Mattermost
A real plugin platform, a versioned REST API whose endpoints carry named permission requirements, Slack-compatible webhooks with admin-enforced channel locking, interactive dialogs and blocks, slash commands, MCP for the AI tooling, and Jira, GitHub, GitLab and ServiceNow maintained as integrations. Integration connections can be kept fully private, which I rate highly. We found no public information on documented rate limits, a sandbox, SCIM provisioning or an API deprecation policy, so this is a strong framework short of a full platform.
European sovereignty
Element
Customer deployments can select their geographical location on named AWS infrastructure, with the vendor's own servers in Amsterdam and Stockholm, and the subprocessor list is published with purposes — Cloudflare, Twilio, Salesforce, Hubspot, MapTiler, Quaderno, LiveKit — though without locations. The stated controller is the UK entity with French and German subsidiaries and the UK ICO as supervisory authority, and the self-hosted plus air-gapped options remove most of the custody question for a buyer who runs it themselves.
Mattermost
The vendor is a US entity in Palo Alto, transfers to the United States are stated, and the cross-border posture rests on the Data Privacy Framework with US-based dispute resolution; the captured pages list a Data Processing Addendum and a Subprocessor document, whose contents were not shown. Cloud regions run on Azure, Oracle, Google or AWS in tenancies the customer controls, and self-hosting with telemetry opt-out takes the archive off the vendor's infrastructure — but EU residency as a stated standard was not in anything I read. One European element, a published processing addendum, with the rest of the chain unstated.
Pricing transparency
Element
The free self-hosted Community edition up to 100 users is public, but the Pro edition is labelled per seat per month and the Sovereign edition per deployment, both without figures and both behind a talk-to-an-expert conversation, with price minimums referenced but not stated. I cannot compute an annual invoice for a headcount from these pages.
Mattermost
Every paid tier routes through sales: Professional says contact sales, Enterprise says get pricing, Enterprise Advanced says request quote, and the FAQ names seat overages and licence models as questions without showing the answers. A free limited-use evaluation edition and a one-hour trial are the only things priced publicly. As a buyer I cannot compute any annual invoice for my headcount from these pages.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Element
Mattermost
Legal entity
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Self-hostable
Self-hostable
Open source
Open source (copyleft)
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Element or Mattermost European?
Element is European (UK / wider Europe). Mattermost is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Element and Mattermost have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.