As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Element 3.5/5 and Mattermost 3.5/5 in Business Instant Messaging. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Element scores higher on 2 of 6 criteria (European sovereignty and Encryption & access control). Mattermost scores higher on 4 of 6 criteria (Retention, discovery & co-determination, Channels, threads & search, Integrations & extensibility, plus 1 more). Provenance — Element: UK / wider Europe; Mattermost: Rest of world. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
On weighted totals the six benches split: Element leads for the security officer (7 vs 6.9), the works council (6.7 vs 6.3) and the platform engineer (7.7 vs 7.3); Mattermost for the team lead (7.4 vs 6.7), the compliance counsel (7.5 vs 6.5) and the skeptic (6.6 vs 6.3). Element leads encryption and access (9.7 vs 7.5, six judges), sovereignty (5.8 vs 2.7, six judges) and pricing transparency (3.0 vs 0.8; not weighted for Mattermost, which publishes no prices). Mattermost leads messaging core (7.3 vs 6.5, five judges, one tie) and governance and discovery (7.8 vs 6.0, six judges) — its verdict credits legal hold and eDiscovery automation, where we found no public information for Element. Deployment control (9.2 vs 9.3) and integrations (6.8 vs 7.0) each show one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties. No overall winner: the lean flips bench by bench.
Choose Element if
You need end-to-end encryption on by default — encryption and access leans Element 9.7 to 7.5 with six judges; the verdict credits the audited Olm and Megolm protocols, while we found no public information on end-to-end encryption for Mattermost.
Your organization wants hosting options in Europe — sovereignty leans Element 5.8 to 2.7 with six judges, and the verdict credits customer-selectable AWS hosting in Amsterdam and Stockholm.
You want the platform published as open source — Element's open-source attribute reads copyleft.
You must run air-gapped or in a private cloud with vendor support — Element's verdict sells self-hosting on-premise, in a private cloud or air-gapped with vendor support.
You want a free starting tier — Element's Community edition is free to use for up to 100 self-hosted users.
Choose Mattermost if
You need legal hold, eDiscovery automation and compliance exports — governance and discovery leans Mattermost 7.8 to 6.0 with six judges.
Your archive tooling expects specific formats — Mattermost's verdict lists exports to CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML or Proofpoint, with edits and deletions tracked by message identifier and queries logged.
You want the stronger messaging core — five judges lean Mattermost, 7.3 to 6.5, with one tie.
Your engineers want a customer-owned MySQL or PostgreSQL database and air-gapped runbooks with a bill of materials — deployment control stands at 9.3 to 9.2, one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Works Council Advocate
Knows that a chat log is a record of who spoke to whom at what hour. Wants presence a person controls, no individual activity scoring anywhere, retention that deletes rather than hides, and analytics that can be switched off across the organisation.
Element
This judge's pick
Mattermost
Criterion by criterion
Channels, threads & search
Element
Threads, reactions, attachments and search that works inside encrypted rooms are documented, with unlimited history and Spaces that can be shared across organisational boundaries under permissions tied to single sign-on. We found no public information on message editing history, pinned items, or search filters by channel, person and date, which keeps this above the middle but not at the top.
Mattermost
Public and private channels, threaded discussions, file previews and full searchable history are documented, with a thread API, guest accounts and shared channels across organisations, and a stated search scale of three million posts with enterprise search beyond. We found no public information on pinned and saved items or on end-user search filters by channel, person and date, so I stop below the level where the archive works as a knowledge base.
Encryption & access control
Element
End-to-end encryption is the default, built on the open Matrix standard with Olm and Megolm and a public NCC Group audit, with device verification by QR code or emoji and per-device decryption. The vendor states plainly that end-to-end encrypted information is never accessed by its teams and that only conversation participants can decrypt — exactly the posture a works council needs when it discusses things management must not be able to read.
Mattermost
The mechanism is written down rather than asserted: TLS with named ciphers, at-rest encryption through disk, database and S3 methods, MFA with SSO and certificate login, session duration an administrator configures, and permissions set per channel. The vendor also states plainly that the database holds message text readable so that search and compliance reporting function, and bring-your-own keys appears only as an optional add-on on the top plan — honest, and exactly the point a works agreement has to weigh.
Retention, discovery & co-determination
Element
Rules-based retention for messages and media is documented, deletion is stated as permanent after seven days, auditing and moderation sit in the admin configuration, and the vendor states it does not profile homeserver users, which I welcome. We found no public information on legal-hold or eDiscovery export, and read receipts are listed as a feature while we found no public information on switching them off organisation-wide — that is the first question I would put to the vendor before any works agreement.
Mattermost
Retention configurable per plan, per-channel retention, legal hold and eDiscovery exports in CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay and Proofpoint formats that track every edit and deletion by message ID, with all queries and downloads logged in an audit history — this is a serious legal archive. My reservation as a works council: the documented default retains every message including deletions, and we found no public information on switching presence, read receipts or activity analytics off across the organisation, or on whether individual productivity scoring forms any part of the product.
Deployment & data custody
Element
Custody can genuinely sit with the customer: an AGPL-licensed homeserver, downloadable installation files, official Helm charts, on-premise or private-cloud hosting with vendor support, air-gapped installation, and federation on an open standard. The production-grade Pro components are subscription-sold with their licence not named and the Community homeserver is stated as not for production use, which is the one boundary on an otherwise customer-held archive.
Mattermost
Custody is genuinely the customer's: one and the same server installs by Kubernetes, Linux or containers on your own infrastructure, air-gapped operation is documented down to a bill of materials and registry mirroring, the customer owns the MySQL or PostgreSQL database, full source code is available, and federation runs over the Matrix protocol. Migration in is documented through Slack-compatible webhooks; for migration out I see export tooling and the customer-owned database rather than a documented importable archive.
Integrations & extensibility
Element
Webhooks, bots for GitHub, GitLab, JIRA and RSS, and interactive widgets embedded in rooms are listed, alongside identity integration through single sign-on, OIDC, LDAP, SCIM and SAML. We found no public information on documented rate limits, a sandbox, or event subscriptions with retries, so this falls short of the platform tier.
Mattermost
A documented REST API with permission checks, an MCP server, webhooks with administrator-enforced channel locking, slash commands, a plugin platform, interactive blocks and dialogs, plus named integrations for Jira, GitHub, GitLab and ServiceNow. We found no public information on SCIM provisioning, documented rate limits or a sandbox environment, which keeps this below the full platform level.
European sovereignty
Element
Hosting runs on AWS in Amsterdam and Stockholm with customer region choice, the group has French and German subsidiaries alongside a UK parent and a US entity, and subprocessors are named with their purposes while we found no locations stated for them; the data processing agreement itself was not among the captured pages. Self-hosting and air-gapped deployment let a customer take the whole question into its own hands, which is why this lands mid-scale rather than low.
Mattermost
The one proven European element is procedural: a Data Processing Addendum and a subprocessor document are listed among the legal documents, and GDPR appears among supported compliance programs. The contracting entity is Mattermost, Inc. of Palo Alto, the privacy policy states processing in the United States with reliance on the EU–US Data Privacy Framework, and we found no public information on where hosted message content resides — for a council that cares where the log lives, self-hosting is the only lever these pages prove.
Pricing transparency
Element
The Community edition is fully priced at zero for up to one hundred users with tier boundaries and server minimums public, but the Pro seats and the per-deployment Sovereign edition carry no figures and point to talking to an expert. A works council could not compute the annual invoice for its headcount from these pages.
Mattermost
We found no public prices: Professional says Contact Sales, Enterprise says Get Pricing, Enterprise Advanced says Request Quote, and an FAQ names the questions on seat overages and SaaS without showing answers. Only a free limited-use evaluation edition is public, so an annual invoice cannot be computed for any headcount.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Element
Mattermost
Legal entity
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Self-hostable
Self-hostable
Open source
Open source (copyleft)
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Element or Mattermost European?
Element is European (UK / wider Europe). Mattermost is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Element and Mattermost have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.