As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Element 3.5/5 and Mattermost 3.5/5 in Business Instant Messaging. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Element scores higher on 2 of 6 criteria (European sovereignty and Encryption & access control). Mattermost scores higher on 4 of 6 criteria (Retention, discovery & co-determination, Channels, threads & search, Integrations & extensibility, plus 1 more). Provenance — Element: UK / wider Europe; Mattermost: Rest of world. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
On weighted totals the six benches split: Element leads for the security officer (7 vs 6.9), the works council (6.7 vs 6.3) and the platform engineer (7.7 vs 7.3); Mattermost for the team lead (7.4 vs 6.7), the compliance counsel (7.5 vs 6.5) and the skeptic (6.6 vs 6.3). Element leads encryption and access (9.7 vs 7.5, six judges), sovereignty (5.8 vs 2.7, six judges) and pricing transparency (3.0 vs 0.8; not weighted for Mattermost, which publishes no prices). Mattermost leads messaging core (7.3 vs 6.5, five judges, one tie) and governance and discovery (7.8 vs 6.0, six judges) — its verdict credits legal hold and eDiscovery automation, where we found no public information for Element. Deployment control (9.2 vs 9.3) and integrations (6.8 vs 7.0) each show one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties. No overall winner: the lean flips bench by bench.
Choose Element if
You need end-to-end encryption on by default — encryption and access leans Element 9.7 to 7.5 with six judges; the verdict credits the audited Olm and Megolm protocols, while we found no public information on end-to-end encryption for Mattermost.
Your organization wants hosting options in Europe — sovereignty leans Element 5.8 to 2.7 with six judges, and the verdict credits customer-selectable AWS hosting in Amsterdam and Stockholm.
You want the platform published as open source — Element's open-source attribute reads copyleft.
You must run air-gapped or in a private cloud with vendor support — Element's verdict sells self-hosting on-premise, in a private cloud or air-gapped with vendor support.
You want a free starting tier — Element's Community edition is free to use for up to 100 self-hosted users.
Choose Mattermost if
You need legal hold, eDiscovery automation and compliance exports — governance and discovery leans Mattermost 7.8 to 6.0 with six judges.
Your archive tooling expects specific formats — Mattermost's verdict lists exports to CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML or Proofpoint, with edits and deletions tracked by message identifier and queries logged.
You want the stronger messaging core — five judges lean Mattermost, 7.3 to 6.5, with one tie.
Your engineers want a customer-owned MySQL or PostgreSQL database and air-gapped runbooks with a bill of materials — deployment control stands at 9.3 to 9.2, one judge leaning Mattermost, five ties.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Skeptic
Reads for the message-history cap, the tier where SSO appears, and what "unlimited" excludes. Has seen "end-to-end encrypted" mean direct messages only, on request, with search disabled — and wants that sentence found rather than assumed.
Element
Mattermost
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Channels, threads & search
Element
Threads, reactions, attachments and read receipts are listed plainly, search inside encrypted rooms is stated, and "Unlimited data history" is claimed outright — that part I checked for the cap and found none. But the captured pages show no message editing history, no pinned or saved items, and no search filters by channel, person and date, which is how you actually find a decision from eighteen months ago; Spaces shareable externally with customers and partners give real cross-organisation rooms.
Mattermost
Channels, threaded discussions, file previews and "full searchable history" are documented, and by default all deployments retain all messages including edits and deletes — the cap I read for turns out to be a search cap: core search tops out at 3 million posts before Enterprise Search is recommended. Guest accounts, per-channel permissions and edit/deletion tracking in exports are listed. We found no public information on pinned or saved items, or on end-user search filtered by channel, person and date.
Encryption & access control
Element
The sentences I hunt for exist verbatim: end-to-end encryption by default, "Messages can only be decrypted by participants in the conversation", and "end-to-end encrypted information is never accessed by our teams or shared externally". The cryptography is open and named — Olm and Megolm on the Matrix standard — publicly audited by NCC Group, with cross-signed device verification by QR code or emoji, single sign-on via OIDC, SCIM and LDAP, and two-factor authentication. What I found no public information on is key backup or recovery for an ordinary user who loses a device, so I stop one short of the top.
Mattermost
The sentence I look for is present: "Mattermost does not offer encryption within the database," stated openly to preserve search and compliance reporting — so there is no end-to-end mode, and the vendor says so rather than hiding it. What is documented is solid: TLS with AES-256, at-rest encryption via disk or S3-managed keys, MFA, SSO, certificate-based authentication, role- and attribute-based controls, session duration configuration, and bring-your-own-keys as an optional add-on on the top plan rather than a first-class mode.
Retention, discovery & co-determination
Element
Rules-based retention for messages and media is documented, deletion behaviour is documented down to a 7-day purge window before permanent removal, and auditing is sold as capturing "an official record of conversations for compliance". I found no mention of legal hold, a discovery export including edits and deletions, or a full administrative audit trail, and read receipts are offered with no stated organisation-wide off-switch — the works-council question gets half an answer.
Mattermost
Retention policy, legal hold and eDiscovery automation are listed plan features, the default is to retain everything including edits and deletes, and compliance export produces CSV, Actiance XML, Global Relay EML or Proofpoint output with messages tracked by ID across edits, deletions and batches — an export a lawyer can work with. Every compliance query and download is logged in an audit history. We found no public information on switching presence, read receipts or activity analytics off organisation-wide, or on individual productivity scoring.
Deployment & data custody
Element
Self-hosting is the product, not an afterthought: a free self-hosted community edition for up to 100 users, official helm charts, on-premise or private cloud with vendor support, air-gapped installs, federation on an open protocol, and a stated ability to easily migrate data against vendor lock-in. Two caps a buyer should read: AGPLv3 covers "the majority of Element software" with enterprise features on subscription, and the community homeserver is stated as not for use in production environments — the free path stops short of production.
Mattermost
Custody is the customer's on the evidence: all documented deployment methods install the same server on your Kubernetes cluster, Linux or containers, air-gapped operation has its own runbook with registry mirroring, you own the database, and full source code is offered. Federation via Matrix interoperability and Slack-compatible webhook formats give paths in and out, though a complete vendor-documented migration path in both directions is only partly evidenced.
Integrations & extensibility
Element
Webhooks, bots for GitHub, GitLab, JIRA and RSS, and widgets that "embed full-blown interactive apps" into rooms are all documented, alongside single sign-on via OIDC, SCIM and LDAP for identity. I found no public information on a documented API statement, rate limits, a sandbox, or any API versioning and deprecation policy.
Mattermost
A documented REST API with bearer authentication, an MCP server, incoming and outgoing webhooks with admin-enforced channel locking, slash commands, interactive Blocks and dialogs, a plugin platform and named DevSecOps integrations clear the bar comfortably. We found no public information on SCIM provisioning — Active Directory and LDAP sync is what is documented — nor on documented rate limits, a sandbox, or event subscription retries.
European sovereignty
Element
Hosting for the managed service sits on named AWS regions in Amsterdam and Stockholm with customer region choice, and the subprocessor list is published by name and purpose — Cloudflare, LiveKit, MapTiler, Twilio, Salesforce, Salesloft, Hubspot, Quaderno — but with no locations given. The data controller on the captured pages is the UK company Element Creations Ltd with the ICO as supervisory authority, in-house analytics are hosted in London, and the German and French subsidiaries exist but their contracting role is unstated. Self-hosting and air-gapped deployment let a customer remove the question entirely, which keeps this above the middle.
Mattermost
The contracting entity is Mattermost, Inc. of Palo Alto, information may be processed and stored in the United States, the Sites use Google Analytics, transfers rest on the Data Privacy Framework and Standard Contractual Clauses, and the optional hosted push notification service may collect usernames, full names, channel names and message preview snippets. A Data Processing Addendum and a Subprocessor document are listed among the legal documents — the one European element we could find — while data residency, subprocessor locations and the addendum's terms are not shown on the captured pages. Self-hosting lets the customer place the archive, but that is the customer's geography, not the vendor's chain.
Pricing transparency
Element
The only figure on any captured page is the free-to-use self-hosted community edition for up to 100 users; the professional tiers say "Priced per seat/month" and "Priced per deployment" with no amounts, route commercial buyers to "Talk to an expert", and reference unspecified "price minimums" for additional servers. A buyer cannot compute an annual invoice for any paid deployment from these pages.
Mattermost
The captured pricing pages name Professional, Enterprise and Enterprise Advanced and route all three to Contact Sales, Get Pricing and Request Quote; we found no public price for any plan. Feature boundaries per plan and a 250-user maximum on Professional are listed publicly, and a free evaluation edition and a 1-hour trial exist, but the FAQ answers on licensing, seat overages and SaaS are not shown — so an annual invoice is not computable from these pages.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Element
Mattermost
Legal entity
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Self-hostable
Self-hostable
Open source
Open source (copyleft)
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Element and 3 pick Mattermost. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Element or Mattermost European?
Element is European (UK / wider Europe). Mattermost is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Element and Mattermost have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.