Panel rating · 6 judges · How to read the stars

Category median

Sovereignty: 2 of 6 dimensions proven

0–5 in half steps. 5 means the rubric's top anchor is met on the evidence.

by Element (New Vector Ltd) · element.io

Compare with Mattermost → Report an error on this page Is this your product? →

Link to this page

Element: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai Element: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai (dark)

Add ?theme=dark to the image address for dark backgrounds. The badge shows the category and the month of the latest evaluation, and EU-Made where that is the product’s provenance. It never shows a score.

Element at a glance

Vendor
Element (New Vector Ltd)
Headquarters
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
Data hosting
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
Free plan
Yes, per the vendor’s own page source, captured 16 Nov 2026
Panel verdict
The AI panel rates Element 3.5/5, the mean of 6 judges. Element is a business instant messaging platform built on the Matrix open standard, and the highest scores go to encryption and access and deployment control, at 9 to 10. how scores are made
As of
Vendor pages captured 19 Oct 2026 to 16 Nov 2026; evaluated by the panel 17 Nov 2026. all sources

Element alternatives, European ones first →

Read this page as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The Skeptic

Weighted verdict

Reads for the message-history cap, the tier where SSO appears, and what "unlimited" excludes. Has seen "end-to-end encrypted" mean direct messages only, on request, with search disabled — and wants that sentence found rather than assumed.

Same scores as the panel view — this lens weights them the way this judge cares.

Scored by The Skeptic

Panel median The Skeptic This judge’s scores over the panel median. Each label opens its reasoning below.
Scores per criterion, in stars out of 5
Criterion Panel median The Skeptic
Channels, threads & search 3.5 of 5 3 of 5
Encryption & access control 5 of 5 4.5 of 5
Retention, discovery & co-determination 3 of 5 3 of 5
Deployment & data custody 4.5 of 5 4.5 of 5
Integrations & extensibility 3.5 of 5 3 of 5
European sovereignty 3 of 5 3 of 5
Pricing transparency 1.5 of 5 1.5 of 5

Channels, threads & search

How this is scored

The daily surface: channel model, threading, mentions, files, and whether search can find a decision made eighteen months ago.

0 — Not a team chat: no persistent channels or group conversations, only notifications or one-off messages.

3 — Group chats or channels and direct messages, file sharing, and search over messages.

5 — Public and private channels, threaded replies, mentions and reactions, file sharing with previews, and search across message history.

8 — Cross-organisation or guest channels with clear boundaries, message editing history, pinned and saved items, search with filters by channel, person and date, and unlimited history or a documented history limit per plan.

10 — The archive is a working knowledge base: search that ranks well across years, threads that stay readable, channel lifecycle management (archive, rename, merge) without losing history, and export of a conversation in a form a human can read.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Threads, reactions, attachments and read receipts are listed plainly, search inside encrypted rooms is stated, and "Unlimited data history" is claimed outright — that part I checked for the cap and found none. But the captured pages show no message editing history, no pinned or saved items, and no search filters by channel, person and date, which is how you actually find a decision from eighteen months ago; Spaces shareable externally with customers and partners give real cross-organisation rooms. 2 5 6

Report an error

Encryption & access control

How this is scored

What is encrypted and against whom, plus who can reach which room. Judged on documented mechanism, since "encrypted" in this category usually means the vendor holds the keys.

0 — The vendor states that messages are transmitted or stored unencrypted.

3 — Encryption in transit stated, with admin and member roles.

5 — Encryption in transit and at rest stated, admin roles and private channels, guest accounts limited to the channels they are invited to, and SSO or two-factor authentication.

8 — Optional end-to-end encryption for direct messages or private rooms with the trade-offs named, or customer-managed encryption keys; device or session management an admin can revoke, granular permissions per channel, and documented key handling.

10 — End-to-end encryption as a first-class mode — documented or open cryptography, cross-device key management that ordinary users survive, identity verification, and the vendor stating plainly what it cannot decrypt.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The sentences I hunt for exist verbatim: end-to-end encryption by default, "Messages can only be decrypted by participants in the conversation", and "end-to-end encrypted information is never accessed by our teams or shared externally". The cryptography is open and named — Olm and Megolm on the Matrix standard — publicly audited by NCC Group, with cross-signed device verification by QR code or emoji, single sign-on via OIDC, SCIM and LDAP, and two-factor authentication. What I found no public information on is key backup or recovery for an ordinary user who loses a device, so I stop one short of the top. 2 3 6

Report an error

Retention, discovery & co-determination

How this is scored

The archive as a legal object: retention policies, export for discovery, audit, and the monitoring features a works council will ask to have switched off under BetrVG §87(1) no. 6.

0 — A messenger with no organisation-level administration: each user controls their own history, and the organisation has no central export or retention.

3 — Admin export of workspace data or a history setting, with users controlling their own status.

5 — Configurable retention for messages and files, admin export of workspace data in a documented format, and an audit log or activity log of administrative actions.

8 — Per-channel retention executed per policy, legal-hold and eDiscovery export including edits and deletions, a full admin audit trail, and presence, read receipts or activity analytics switchable off organisation-wide.

10 — Built to pass a works agreement and a subpoena on the same day: granular retention with documented deletion, discovery export a lawyer can use, complete audit, and individual productivity scoring stated as not part of the product.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Rules-based retention for messages and media is documented, deletion behaviour is documented down to a 7-day purge window before permanent removal, and auditing is sold as capturing "an official record of conversations for compliance". I found no mention of legal hold, a discovery export including edits and deletions, or a full administrative audit trail, and read receipts are offered with no stated organisation-wide off-switch — the works-council question gets half an answer. 2 3 6 10

Report an error

Deployment & data custody

How this is scored

Whether the customer can hold their own archive: self-hosting, private cloud, open source, federation, and what an exit actually looks like.

0 — The terms state that the customer's messages cannot be exported or are not returned when the account ends.

3 — Cloud service with an admin export of messages and files.

5 — Cloud service with a documented full export of messages, files and channel structure, or a choice of hosting region, a dedicated instance or a private-cloud option.

8 — A self-hosted edition close to feature parity, or an open-source core with a documented upgrade path, plus complete export including files and metadata.

10 — Custody is the customer's: open-source or source-available server, self-hosting supported as a first-class deployment, open protocol or federation, and a migration path in and out that the vendor documents rather than resists.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Self-hosting is the product, not an afterthought: a free self-hosted community edition for up to 100 users, official helm charts, on-premise or private cloud with vendor support, air-gapped installs, federation on an open protocol, and a stated ability to easily migrate data against vendor lock-in. Two caps a buyer should read: AGPLv3 covers "the majority of Element software" with enterprise features on subscription, and the community homeserver is stated as not for use in production environments — the free path stops short of production. 2 8 9 11 12

Report an error

Integrations & extensibility

How this is scored

Bots, webhooks, app framework, identity — whether the chat becomes the place work is noticed, and whether that is buildable without a partner agreement.

0 — A closed messenger: no integrations, webhooks, bots or API.

3 — Incoming webhooks or a handful of named integrations.

5 — An app directory or a list of native integrations with common tools, a documented API, incoming webhooks and bots or slash commands.

8 — A proper app framework with interactive components, event subscriptions with retries, SSO and SCIM provisioning, documented rate limits and a sandbox.

10 — A platform: versioned API with a deprecation policy, an app directory or plugin system with permissions a customer can audit, and integrations the vendor maintains rather than lists.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Webhooks, bots for GitHub, GitLab, JIRA and RSS, and widgets that "embed full-blown interactive apps" into rooms are all documented, alongside single sign-on via OIDC, SCIM and LDAP for identity. I found no public information on a documented API statement, rate limits, a sandbox, or any API versioning and deprecation policy. 2 10 12

Report an error

European sovereignty

How this is scored

Where the archive and its metadata live, who the contracting entity is, which subprocessors touch it. Independently sourced by the sovereignty pipeline; scored here as this buyer weighs it. Dimensions the evidence does not establish are unknown, not non-EU.

0 — Proven non-EU on every dimension the evidence covers: non-EU vendor and contracting entity and non-EU hosting, with no EU option stated.

3 — One European element proven — EU data residency for message content, an EU contracting entity or EU representative, or a published DPA — with the rest of the chain unstated.

5 — EU hosting stated as standard or selectable and an EU contracting entity or EU representative, with a DPA offered; the subprocessor chain (notifications, AI features, analytics) is unstated or partly non-EU.

8 — EU hosting on named infrastructure covering content and metadata, EU contracting entity, subprocessor list published with locations, any non-EU processing named with its legal basis.

10 — Sovereign end to end and evidenced: vendor, entity, hosting and every subprocessor European, certification published, and a self-hosted option that removes the question.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Hosting for the managed service sits on named AWS regions in Amsterdam and Stockholm with customer region choice, and the subprocessor list is published by name and purpose — Cloudflare, LiveKit, MapTiler, Twilio, Salesforce, Salesloft, Hubspot, Quaderno — but with no locations given. The data controller on the captured pages is the UK company Element Creations Ltd with the ICO as supervisory authority, in-house analytics are hosted in London, and the German and French subsidiaries exist but their contracting role is unstated. Self-hosting and air-gapped deployment let a customer remove the question entirely, which keeps this above the middle. 3 4 11

Report an error

Pricing transparency

How this is scored

Whether a buyer can compute the annual invoice for their headcount — including the retention, compliance and guest features they actually need — from public pages alone.

0 — No public prices at all; every tier is a sales conversation.

3 — A public "from" price or one priced tier per user.

5 — Per-user prices public for the main tiers with the billing period stated and the main features per tier listed.

8 — Every tier priced publicly with per-user maths, history and storage limits, feature boundaries (retention, SSO, eDiscovery), minimum term and VAT treatment stated; self-hosted licensing priced too where offered.

10 — Complete price computability: annual invoice derivable for a given headcount and deployment choice, including guest users, storage and any per-instance licence.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The only figure on any captured page is the free-to-use self-hosted community edition for up to 100 users; the professional tiers say "Priced per seat/month" and "Priced per deployment" with no amounts, route commercial buyers to "Talk to an expert", and reference unspecified "price minimums" for additional servers. A buyer cannot compute an annual invoice for any paid deployment from these pages. 2 8 12

Report an error

European sovereignty — proven facts

2 of 6 dimensions proven

Built only from facts shown on the vendor's own pages. A dimension we could not prove is left open, not scored as zero.

Hosting location Not determined — uncited Report an error
Hosting options Self-hostable 1/1 pts 2 Report an error
Open source Open source (copyleft) unverified
Why unverified?

The AGPL licence is stated for the Community edition; enterprise components (Synapse Pro, Element Server Suite Pro) are sold on subscription and their licence is not named.

1/1 pts 2 Report an error
Data processing agreement Not determined — uncited Report an error
Transfer impact assessment Not determined — uncited Report an error

Questions about Element

Is Element European?

Yes, though not from the EU. whats-best.ai classifies Element as UK / wider Europe.

Where does Element store data?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026.

Does Element have a free plan?

Yes. Element has a free plan, per the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026.

What are the best alternatives to Element?

As of 19 Nov 2026, the panel rates Stackfield (3.5/5), Mattermost (3.5/5) and Wire (Messaging) (3.5/5) highest among the other 27 Business Instant Messaging products evaluated. Ratings that look equal are rounded to half stars; the order uses the unrounded rating, then the name. The highest-rated European alternative is Stackfield (EU-Made, Germany). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made. The full list, with European products first: Element alternatives.

Where this could be wrong

What we left out

A claim that does not survive our checks costs us the claim, not the page. This is what was taken off this one.

Sources (12)

The pages every claim on this page was read from — each one checked, dated, and kept verifiable.

  1. 1 Vendor homepage element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 19 Oct 2026 Details →
  2. 2 Pricing element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  3. 3 Privacy policy element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  4. 4 Legal notice element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  5. 5 Channels, threads & search — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  6. 6 Encryption & access control — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  7. 7 Encryption & access control — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  8. 8 Deployment & data custody — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  9. 9 Deployment & data custody — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  10. 10 Integrations & extensibility — found from sitemap element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  11. 11 Self-hosting / on-premises installation docs — found from the homepage element.io Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  12. 12 Code repository (open-source licence) — found from the homepage github.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 1 Nov 2026 Details →