As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Ahrefs 3/5 and Semrush 3.5/5 in SEO. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Ahrefs scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency). Semrush scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (Reporting, integrations & API, Rank tracking & index quality, Crawling & technical audit, plus 3 more). Provenance — Ahrefs: Rest of world, Singapore; Semrush: Rest of world, United States. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Semrush is ahead on six of seven criteria: reporting and API (8.0 vs 5.8), rank and index data (7.5 vs 5.8), technical audit (7.3 vs 5.8), data portability (6.2 vs 5.3), keyword and content (6.5 vs 5.7) and sovereignty (2.0 vs 0.8). Six judges lean Semrush on reporting and API, rank and index data, technical audit and sovereignty, none the other way; keyword and content has four leaning Semrush with two ties, data portability five with one tie. Pricing transparency reverses: six judges lean Ahrefs (7.8 vs 5.3) on public prices from Starter € 27 /mo to Advanced € 419 /mo, while Semrush quotes Advanced as Custom and Enterprise as a demo request. Both list non-EU data residency; Ahrefs's jurisdiction is Singapore with a self-serve DPA, Semrush's the United States with DPA unknown. On the published weighted totals, Semrush's figures run higher.
Choose Ahrefs if
You need to price your tier from public pages before any sales contact: Ahrefs publishes Starter € 27 /mo, Lite € 119 /mo, Standard € 229 /mo and Advanced € 419 /mo with tracked-keyword, crawl-credit, export-row and API limits per tier, and six judges lean Ahrefs on pricing transparency (7.8 vs 5.3).
Your procurement must execute a data processing agreement without a sales cycle: Ahrefs's sovereignty attributes list a self-serve DPA, while Semrush's DPA is listed as unknown.
Your legal review looks for Standard Contractual Clauses, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative: Ahrefs's verdict records SCCs, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative in Cork.
You are buying at Starter through Advanced tiers, so the published per-tier prices and limits cover your decision and the differing Enterprise figures across the captured pages (€ 1,394 /mo with annual commitment on one, talk to sales on another) do not reach your tier.
Choose Semrush if
You build reporting pipelines on the API: reporting and API scores 8.0 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on published per-endpoint unit costs — 20 units per keyword-metrics request, 40 per line for broad match — a documented v3-to-v4 migration path and white-labelled reports.
Your work leans on index scale and history: rank and index data scores 7.5 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on a vendor-published index of 26.4 billion keywords, 43 trillion backlinks and 142 geo databases, updated daily with history back to January 2012.
Site audits drive your workflow: technical audit scores 7.3 vs 5.8, with six judges leaning Semrush and none leaning Ahrefs.
Sovereignty is scored in your evaluation but EU data residency is not a hard requirement: both products list non-EU data residency, and sovereignty leans Semrush six to zero (2.0 vs 0.8).
You need regular exports for downstream analysis: data portability leans Semrush on five judges' cards with one tie (6.2 vs 5.3), noting the verdict's premium-priced historical pulls and one-month caching cap.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Content Strategist
Decides what gets written and can only commission so much. Wants topic clusters, honest opportunity sizing, cannibalisation caught before it happens, and briefs scored against what actually ranks rather than against keyword density.
Ahrefs
Semrush
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Crawling & technical audit
Ahrefs
Site Audit runs its own crawler with speed settings, page and time limits, scheduled runs by day and timezone, regex include/exclude and URL rewrite rules, HTTP-authenticated crawling and a JavaScript rendering toggle, plus PageSpeed Insights scoring against the user's own Google key and always-on auditing on the paid add-ons. That clears real-scale crawling comfortably, but we found no public information on issues grouped by severity with fix hints, indexation or canonical diagnosis, structured-data validation, or comparing the crawl against what Google fetched.
Semrush
The documented audit covers crawlability and indexability, Core Web Vitals scored against Google's published good and poor ratings at the 75th percentile, mobile parity and rendering, structured data, canonicals and internal linking — with crawl snapshots, issue-level detail, page-level inspection and a prioritized fix list rather than a raw issue count. Multi-million-page crawling is stated at the Enterprise tier. We found no public information on crawl budget analysis or regression detection that would tie a change to a specific deploy, so it stays a strong audit rather than a diagnostic.
Keyword research & content guidance
Ahrefs
Keywords Explorer is documented with difficulty, clicks and CPC, search-intent filtering, SERP features per keyword on every plan, SERP history, and an AI Content Helper and Grader sold as a paid add-on — a decent briefing toolkit. The pieces I commission against go unevidenced: we found no public information on topic clustering, competitor keyword gap analysis or cannibalisation detection, and the captured help pages list the question of which languages are supported without showing an answer, so the German-language data depth is unknown.
Semrush
Keyword data runs to 26.4 billion keywords across 142 geo databases with volume, difficulty, CPC and trend insights, SERP features per keyword including AI Overviews, a question filter and relevance scores on related keywords — and, the part I care most about, keyword cannibalisation analysis and content optimisation are named in the Pro tier. We found no public information on topic clustering, content briefs scored on entity coverage, or SERP composition tracked over time, so opportunity sizing against what actually ranks isn't evidenced.
Rank tracking & index quality
Ahrefs
The vendor publishes more about its own data than most: AhrefsBot described among the world's most active crawlers, backlink data refreshed every 15 to 30 minutes with a full refresh taking about two months, crawl prioritisation explained by Domain Rating, historical data tiered from six months to unlimited, and SERP-feature positions tracked per feature. Rank Tracker updates weekly on every plan, and we found no public information on daily or city-level tracking, country and device selection, new and lost backlinks, or a published index size.
Semrush
Daily position updates for any keyword at any location, city and country level on desktop and mobile, with change alerts, and an index whose size and freshness are published — 26.4B keywords, 43T backlinks, 808M domain profiles, 142 geo databases, updated daily — plus historical data back to January 2012 and methodological disclosure such as unpersonalised-result filtering and the average-position cap at 21. Full historical export in the customer's hands and reconciliation against Search Console aren't documented, which is the gap between a very large index and accountability for it.
Reporting, integrations & API
Ahrefs
Scheduled Report Builder dashboards with per-plan widget limits, Looker Studio from the Advanced plan, a documented version-3 API with published rows-per-request caps and monthly integration units on all paid plans, and Enterprise SSO with uncapped API make this a workable data source. The agency hand-off is the weak point: the vendor's own help pages state they do not currently allow white-label reports, and we found no public information on BigQuery or data-warehouse export.
Semrush
White-labelling, Google Analytics and Search Console integrations, twenty-plus external integrations, and an API whose costs are published per endpoint — 20 units per keyword-metrics request, 40 per line for broad match, some endpoints free — with a checkable unit balance, documented partial-result behaviour, rate limits and a v3-to-v4 migration path with deprecation noted. We found no public information on data-warehouse or BigQuery export or on client-access management, so the evidence shows a strong data source with branded reporting rather than a full agency-ready destination.
Data portability & exit
Ahrefs
Export rows are capped and published per tier — 500,000 rows a month on Lite rising to from ten million on Enterprise, with per-report row caps — and a versioned rank-tracker API plus tiered historical data mean the archive is largely retrievable while you subscribe. We found no public information on export formats, on exporting beyond the monthly row caps, or on any retention period after cancellation.
Semrush
Exit terms are stated plainly: thirty days after suspension notice to back up data before removal, no erasure sooner than thirty days after termination, and API export in JSON or CSV including a CSV export of the API query log. The catch for anyone wanting to mirror years of history is that API use is limited to internal business purposes, caching is capped at one month without written consent, inquiries are capped at ten per second, and historical data costs more API units than regular data — retrievable, but not mirrorable.
European sovereignty
Ahrefs
The contracting entity is Ahrefs Pte. Ltd. of Singapore and the privacy policy states that personal data is transferred to and stored in the United States — a proven non-EU chain on both entity and hosting. A Cork-based EU representative, Standard Contractual Clauses and a self-serve data processing agreement exist, but none of that moves the entity or the storage into Europe.
Semrush
The contracting company is Semrush Inc., a Delaware corporation in Boston, and personal data may be transferred to the United States under Standard Contractual Clauses; the European presence — Semrush CZ s.r.o. in Prague as joint controller and contact for European data protection requests, with GDPR in scope — is real but sits beside a US contracting chain. We found no public information on where customer data is hosted, on a data processing agreement, or on a transfer impact assessment.
Pricing transparency
Ahrefs
Every tier carries a public price — Starter €27/mo, Lite €119/mo, Standard €229/mo, Advanced €419/mo — alongside tracked-keyword, crawl-credit and API limits per tier, additional users at €37.4 to €93 per user per month, published per-check overages on the AI prompt packages, itemised add-ons from €18.7 to $299, and prices stated exclusive of consumption tax. The invoice stays short of fully computable: Enterprise keyword and crawl figures are floors rather than priced overages, the annual saving is stated as up to 17% rather than a per-tier annual figure, and the captured pages give different figures for Enterprise — one showing €1,394/mo with annual commitment required, another directing buyers to sales.
Semrush
Tier limits are public — keywords tracked daily from 500 to 5,000+ and websites from 5 to 40+, billed monthly or annually in advance — add-ons carry exact prices (Base Report €9.59/mo, additional users starting at €43/mo), API units are priced per endpoint, fees are stated exclusive of taxes, and trial, cancellation, auto-renewal and late-fee terms are all documented. But the captured pricing pages show no headline price for the paid tiers — Advanced is quoted as Custom and Enterprise as a demo request — and we found no public information on overage rates or minimum term, so a real annual invoice isn't computable from public pages alone.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Ahrefs
Semrush
Legal entity
Incorporated in SG
Incorporated in US
Hosting location
Outside the EU
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Semrush higher: 3.5/5 against 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Ahrefs or Semrush European?
Ahrefs is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Singapore). Semrush is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United States). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Ahrefs and Semrush store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Ahrefs: Outside the EU by default. Semrush: Outside the EU by default.
Do Ahrefs and Semrush have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.