As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Ahrefs 3/5 and Semrush 3.5/5 in SEO. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Ahrefs scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency). Semrush scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (Reporting, integrations & API, Rank tracking & index quality, Crawling & technical audit, plus 3 more). Provenance — Ahrefs: Rest of world, Singapore; Semrush: Rest of world, United States. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Semrush is ahead on six of seven criteria: reporting and API (8.0 vs 5.8), rank and index data (7.5 vs 5.8), technical audit (7.3 vs 5.8), data portability (6.2 vs 5.3), keyword and content (6.5 vs 5.7) and sovereignty (2.0 vs 0.8). Six judges lean Semrush on reporting and API, rank and index data, technical audit and sovereignty, none the other way; keyword and content has four leaning Semrush with two ties, data portability five with one tie. Pricing transparency reverses: six judges lean Ahrefs (7.8 vs 5.3) on public prices from Starter € 27 /mo to Advanced € 419 /mo, while Semrush quotes Advanced as Custom and Enterprise as a demo request. Both list non-EU data residency; Ahrefs's jurisdiction is Singapore with a self-serve DPA, Semrush's the United States with DPA unknown. On the published weighted totals, Semrush's figures run higher.
Choose Ahrefs if
You need to price your tier from public pages before any sales contact: Ahrefs publishes Starter € 27 /mo, Lite € 119 /mo, Standard € 229 /mo and Advanced € 419 /mo with tracked-keyword, crawl-credit, export-row and API limits per tier, and six judges lean Ahrefs on pricing transparency (7.8 vs 5.3).
Your procurement must execute a data processing agreement without a sales cycle: Ahrefs's sovereignty attributes list a self-serve DPA, while Semrush's DPA is listed as unknown.
Your legal review looks for Standard Contractual Clauses, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative: Ahrefs's verdict records SCCs, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative in Cork.
You are buying at Starter through Advanced tiers, so the published per-tier prices and limits cover your decision and the differing Enterprise figures across the captured pages (€ 1,394 /mo with annual commitment on one, talk to sales on another) do not reach your tier.
Choose Semrush if
You build reporting pipelines on the API: reporting and API scores 8.0 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on published per-endpoint unit costs — 20 units per keyword-metrics request, 40 per line for broad match — a documented v3-to-v4 migration path and white-labelled reports.
Your work leans on index scale and history: rank and index data scores 7.5 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on a vendor-published index of 26.4 billion keywords, 43 trillion backlinks and 142 geo databases, updated daily with history back to January 2012.
Site audits drive your workflow: technical audit scores 7.3 vs 5.8, with six judges leaning Semrush and none leaning Ahrefs.
Sovereignty is scored in your evaluation but EU data residency is not a hard requirement: both products list non-EU data residency, and sovereignty leans Semrush six to zero (2.0 vs 0.8).
You need regular exports for downstream analysis: data portability leans Semrush on five judges' cards with one tie (6.2 vs 5.3), noting the verdict's premium-priced historical pulls and one-month caching cap.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The In-House SEO Lead
Owns organic traffic for one large German site and reports on it monthly. Wants German-language keyword data that is not an afterthought, rankings she can defend when they disagree with Search Console, and audit findings specific enough to become a developer ticket.
Ahrefs
Semrush
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Crawling & technical audit
Ahrefs
The crawler is documented in real depth — scheduled audits by day, time and timezone, per-plan crawl credits, a JavaScript execution toggle, PageSpeed Insights scoring with the user's own Google API key, regex include/exclude, and sitemap or custom URL-list seed sources — which sits comfortably above a plain broken-link checker. But I found no public information on issues grouped by severity with fix hints, indexation or canonical diagnosis, structured-data validation, Search Console or log-file comparison, or crawl-to-crawl regression tracking, so nothing evidences findings specific enough to hand a developer as a ticket.
Semrush
The audit modules run from crawlability and indexability through Core Web Vitals measured against Google's own good, needs-improvement and poor boundaries at the 75th percentile, mobile parity and rendering, canonicals, structured data and internal linking, with a prioritized fix list and crawl snapshots retrievable over time; Enterprise is described as multi-million-page crawling. For developer tickets I get real specificity — JSON-LD drafting and validation delegated to a dedicated schema skill, plus title and meta-description guidance in pixels and characters. We found no public information on log-file analysis or prioritisation by traffic impact, and the AI-assistant route is documented as read-only, unable to launch a crawl.
Keyword research & content guidance
Ahrefs
Keyword difficulty, CPC, clicks, Parent Topic, search intent filtering, trending-keyword growth metrics and eighteen tracked SERP features including AI Overview are all documented, and SERP history plus a SERP comparison module arrive on higher tiers. Content guidance exists but only as a paid Content Kit add-on, and I found no public information establishing the depth of German-language keyword data, competitor keyword gap analysis or cannibalisation detection — the things my monthly German report actually runs on.
Semrush
Keyword discovery is deep — over 26 billion keywords with volume, difficulty and CPC in Keyword Overview, SERP feature detection including AI Overviews, Local Pack and People Also Ask, and broad-match, related, question and relevance-scored variations via the keyword endpoints, with content optimization and keyword cannibalization analysis listed at the Pro level. As the buyer for a German site, I have to note the pages describe coverage only as hundreds of locations worldwide; we found no public information confirming German-language data depth specifically, nor on intent classification or topic clustering.
Rank tracking & index quality
Ahrefs
Index accountability is partly there: the backlink database is refreshed with fresh data every 15 to 30 minutes with a full update taking about two months, and the crawl methodology (priority by Domain Rating, update speed by URL Rating) is documented, which helps me defend numbers in front of stakeholders. Rank tracking, however, is documented as weekly-only with no stated country, device or city-level options, no published index size, and historical data capped by plan (six months on Lite up to five years on Advanced, unlimited on Enterprise) rather than for the life of the account.
Semrush
The vendor publishes its index scale — 26.4 billion keywords, 43 trillion backlinks, 142 geo databases — and states daily position updates for any keyword at any location with city-level and device splits, SERP feature attribution, and monthly keyword snapshots back to January 2012. I value the candour of the methodology notes: average positions cap anything beyond rank 20 at 21, and personalized results are filtered out. We found no public information on the backlink index refresh cadence, on ranking-history retention for the life of the account, or on how disagreements with Search Console are handled.
Reporting, integrations & API
Ahrefs
Scheduled Report Builder with per-plan report and widget limits, a Looker Studio connector on Advanced, and a versioned API (v3.0.0) with rows-per-request and monthly integration-unit limits published give me most of my reporting chain. The vendor itself states that white-labelling reports is not available at present, and I found no public information on Google Search Console or Google Analytics integration or data-warehouse export.
Semrush
This is the strongest area: an API in versions 3 and 4 with a documented migration path and key dates, deprecated endpoints listed by name, rate limiting published, and per-endpoint credit costs in plain units — 20 units per keyword-metrics request, 40 per line of broad-match data — alongside OAuth 2.0 and a free unit-balance check. Reporting brings white-labeling, Google Analytics and Search Console integration in the paid report add-ons, and 20+ external integrations plus MCP connectors the vendor maintains for AI tools. We found no public information on data-warehouse or BigQuery export, and tools with external users on the API are directed to sales.
Data portability & exit
Ahrefs
Export is real and generously metered — 500,000 rows per month on Lite rising to from 10 million on Enterprise, plus a documented Rank Tracker API I could mirror data through. But exports are quoted as row counts rather than formats, historical data is itself capped by plan, and I found no public information on a retention period after cancellation or a full-account export on exit.
Semrush
Exit terms are at least written down: data may be erased no earlier than thirty days after termination, with a thirty-day backup window after suspension. The API can export historical data and return it in JSON or CSV, but historical requests cost more units, caching retrieved data beyond one month requires written consent, and forwarding is limited to ten inquiries per second — so continuously mirroring my multi-year rank history into my own store is a negotiation, not a setting.
European sovereignty
Ahrefs
The contracting entity is Ahrefs Pte. Ltd. in Singapore and the privacy policy states that personal data is transferred to and stored in the United States, so the chain is proven non-EU at both ends. European machinery does exist — an EU representative in Cork, Standard Contractual Clauses (2021/914/EU), a data processing agreement and a published subprocessor list — which lifts this just above the floor without changing where the account data lives.
Semrush
The contracting entity is Semrush Inc., a Delaware corporation with Massachusetts law in its terms, and the privacy policy discloses possible transfers of personal data to the United States and to group members outside the EEA and UK, mitigated through Standard Contractual Clauses. A Prague entity, Semrush CZ s.r.o., is named for European data protection requests as joint controller — the one European element in the chain. No page states where the service's data is hosted, and we found no public information on a data processing agreement.
Pricing transparency
Ahrefs
Tier prices with billing period, VAT treatment ("The prices shown are exclusive of tax. Consumption tax will be added separately"), per-seat costs per plan, and keyword, crawl, export and API limits are all public, with add-ons and per-check overage rates priced for the prompt packages. The captured pages give different figures for the Enterprise tier — one shows €1,394/mo with annual commitment required while others say talk to sales — and overage rates are published only for prompt checks, not for keywords or crawl credits, so a complete annual invoice is not computable for every configuration.
Semrush
Per-tier limits are unusually well published — keywords tracked daily and websites monitored per plan, AI prompts per day, add-ons priced to the cent in euros, additional users starting at €43/mo, fees stated exclusive of taxes, and API endpoints priced in units per request or line. What stops me computing the real annual invoice: we found no public information on the headline prices of the paid subscription tiers — only the $0 free tier and Custom for Advanced — nor on crawl or page limits per plan, or overage rates.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Ahrefs
Semrush
Legal entity
Incorporated in SG
Incorporated in US
Hosting location
Outside the EU
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Semrush higher: 3.5/5 against 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Ahrefs or Semrush European?
Ahrefs is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Singapore). Semrush is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United States). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Ahrefs and Semrush store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Ahrefs: Outside the EU by default. Semrush: Outside the EU by default.
Do Ahrefs and Semrush have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.