As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Ahrefs 3/5 and Semrush 3.5/5 in SEO. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Ahrefs scores higher on 1 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency). Semrush scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (Reporting, integrations & API, Rank tracking & index quality, Crawling & technical audit, plus 3 more). Provenance — Ahrefs: Rest of world, Singapore; Semrush: Rest of world, United States. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Semrush is ahead on six of seven criteria: reporting and API (8.0 vs 5.8), rank and index data (7.5 vs 5.8), technical audit (7.3 vs 5.8), data portability (6.2 vs 5.3), keyword and content (6.5 vs 5.7) and sovereignty (2.0 vs 0.8). Six judges lean Semrush on reporting and API, rank and index data, technical audit and sovereignty, none the other way; keyword and content has four leaning Semrush with two ties, data portability five with one tie. Pricing transparency reverses: six judges lean Ahrefs (7.8 vs 5.3) on public prices from Starter € 27 /mo to Advanced € 419 /mo, while Semrush quotes Advanced as Custom and Enterprise as a demo request. Both list non-EU data residency; Ahrefs's jurisdiction is Singapore with a self-serve DPA, Semrush's the United States with DPA unknown. On the published weighted totals, Semrush's figures run higher.
Choose Ahrefs if
You need to price your tier from public pages before any sales contact: Ahrefs publishes Starter € 27 /mo, Lite € 119 /mo, Standard € 229 /mo and Advanced € 419 /mo with tracked-keyword, crawl-credit, export-row and API limits per tier, and six judges lean Ahrefs on pricing transparency (7.8 vs 5.3).
Your procurement must execute a data processing agreement without a sales cycle: Ahrefs's sovereignty attributes list a self-serve DPA, while Semrush's DPA is listed as unknown.
Your legal review looks for Standard Contractual Clauses, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative: Ahrefs's verdict records SCCs, a published subprocessor list and an EU representative in Cork.
You are buying at Starter through Advanced tiers, so the published per-tier prices and limits cover your decision and the differing Enterprise figures across the captured pages (€ 1,394 /mo with annual commitment on one, talk to sales on another) do not reach your tier.
Choose Semrush if
You build reporting pipelines on the API: reporting and API scores 8.0 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on published per-endpoint unit costs — 20 units per keyword-metrics request, 40 per line for broad match — a documented v3-to-v4 migration path and white-labelled reports.
Your work leans on index scale and history: rank and index data scores 7.5 vs 5.8 with six judges leaning Semrush, on a vendor-published index of 26.4 billion keywords, 43 trillion backlinks and 142 geo databases, updated daily with history back to January 2012.
Site audits drive your workflow: technical audit scores 7.3 vs 5.8, with six judges leaning Semrush and none leaning Ahrefs.
Sovereignty is scored in your evaluation but EU data residency is not a hard requirement: both products list non-EU data residency, and sovereignty leans Semrush six to zero (2.0 vs 0.8).
You need regular exports for downstream analysis: data portability leans Semrush on five judges' cards with one tie (6.2 vs 5.3), noting the verdict's premium-priced historical pulls and one-month caching cap.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Technical SEO
Lives in crawl data and log files. Wants JavaScript rendering, crawl budget analysed, indexation diagnosed rather than listed, and regressions caught between crawls. Treats an issue list sorted by count rather than by traffic impact as busywork.
Ahrefs
Semrush
This judge's pick
Criterion by criterion
Crawling & technical audit
Ahrefs
The documented crawler is configurable the way I want it: regex include/exclude and rewrite rules, robots.txt override with desktop/mobile user-agent switch, crawl speed control, HTTP-auth crawling, scheduled crawls against stated crawl credits, a JavaScript execution toggle for JS-heavy sites, and PageSpeed Insights scoring via the user's Google API key. But I found no public information on log-file or Search Console comparison, indexation or canonical diagnosis, crawl-to-crawl regression detection, or issues prioritised by traffic impact — so this is a well-configured crawler, not yet a diagnostic one.
Semrush
The audit scope runs deeper than a checklist: crawlability and indexability, redirects, canonicals, structured data, internal linking, AI crawler access, and Core Web Vitals scored against Google's good/needs-improvement/poor bands at the 75th percentile, with multi-million-page crawling at the Enterprise tier and Site Audit snapshots queryable through the API. Rendering shows up only as a module title, the fix list is described as prioritized without traffic impact ever being named as the basis, and we found no log-file analysis or regression detection between crawls on the captured pages. That places it below the diagnostic level but comfortably above a category-and-severity listing.
Keyword research & content guidance
Ahrefs
Keywords Explorer is documented with volume, difficulty, CPC, clicks, intent filtering, Parent Topic and SERP feature tracking across eighteen feature types with position attribution, and the Content Kit adds AI content grading alongside Content Explorer and SERP comparison on higher tiers. SERP history and the content tools appear as module names without documented depth, and I found no public information establishing the depth of the German-language data specifically.
Semrush
Keyword research is real: 26.4 billion keywords across 142 geo databases, volume, difficulty and CPC per keyword, SERP features including AI Overviews shown per keyword, broad-match and related endpoints with relevance scores and a question filter, plus cannibalisation analysis and content optimization listed at the Pro tier. We found no search intent classification among the documented metrics, and no German-market depth beyond an ISO country code parameter — no German-language specifics, clustering or content briefs on the captured pages. That lands it between solid multi-market research and the top band.
Rank tracking & index quality
Ahrefs
The backlink index's refresh cadence is published — fresh data every 15–30 minutes, full refresh in about two months — and crawler methodology is documented (popularity-weighted crawl priority, URL-rating-driven update speed), which is more accountability than most vendors offer. But ranking updates are weekly on every tier, historical data is tiered from six months to unlimited by plan rather than retained for the account's life, index size itself is not published, and the captured pages give different figures for the crawler's world activity rank.
Semrush
The vendor publishes their own numbers and stands behind them: 26.4B keywords, 43T backlinks, 142 geo databases, data crawled and updated daily, rankings at city and country level on desktop and mobile, SERP feature attribution per keyword, and historical snapshots back to January 2012 through the API. Methodology candour shows in small places — personalized results filtered out, and average positions capped at 21 when the true rank exceeds 20. Full historical export is bounded by pagination and unit costs, and we found nothing on the captured pages explaining discrepancies against Search Console.
Reporting, integrations & API
Ahrefs
Scheduled Report Builder with per-plan report and widget counts, a Looker Studio connector, and a versioned API with published rows-per-request and per-plan unit allowances are all documented. The vendor states plainly that reports cannot be white-labelled, which caps this for agencies, and I found no public information on Search Console or Google Analytics integration or any data-warehouse export.
Semrush
The API documentation reads like it was written for engineers: v3 and v4 with a migration path and key dates, rate limiting stated, credit costs published per endpoint (20 API units per keyword-metrics request, 40 units per line for broad match), a checkable unit balance, and documented error behaviour when units run short. Around it sit white-labeling on the Pro Report, Google Analytics and Search Console integrations, 20+ external integrations, project create-and-manage endpoints and an MCP connector for AI assistants. We found no data-warehouse or BigQuery export on the captured pages, and API use is licensed for internal business purposes only, with tools for external users routed to sales.
Data portability & exit
Ahrefs
Export capacity is published per plan — 500,000 to 10 million rows per month with per-report row caps — and the rank tracker API is documented at version 3.0.0, so a team can mirror history continuously. But historical data is retained by tier, six months on the entry paid plan, and I found no public information on a retention or grace period after cancellation.
Semrush
Export exists and the history is deep: json and csv response formats, historical data back to 2012, a 30-day window to back up data after suspension notice, and a stated minimum of 30 days after termination before erasure. But the exit is metered and gated — historical data requests cost more API units, deep pagination is capped so results past the 50,000th entry cannot be retrieved, and the terms allow caching received data for at most one month without written consent, which rules out continuously mirroring your own archive.
European sovereignty
Ahrefs
The contracting entity is Ahrefs Pte. Ltd. in Singapore and the privacy policy states personal data is transferred to and stored in the United States, so the chain is proven non-EU. The European touches are safeguards rather than sovereignty: a published data processing agreement, Standard Contractual Clauses, a subprocessor list with locations, and an EU representative in Cork.
Semrush
The contracting chain is American: Semrush Inc., a Delaware corporation headquartered in Boston, Massachusetts law for disputes, and disclosed transfers to the United States under Standard Contractual Clauses. No hosting or server location is named in the captures, so the fully-proven non-EU placement stays out of reach; a Prague entity acts as joint controller and EU contact and Google Ireland handles analytics, leaving a European thread in the chain.
Pricing transparency
Ahrefs
Nearly everything a buyer needs is public: per-tier prices with tracked keyword, crawl credit, API unit, export row and per-report limits, per-user costs per tier, add-ons priced per project, published overage rates on the AI prompt packages, an up-to-17% annual discount, and the statement that prices exclude tax. The wrinkle is that the captured pricing pages give different figures for Enterprise — one shows € 1,394 /mo with annual commitment required, another says contact sales — and I found no overage rate for crawl credits.
Semrush
Real pricing detail is public: per-tier keyword and website limits (500, 1,500 and 5,000+ keywords daily), billing monthly or annual in advance, add-on prices quoted exactly — Base Report at €9.59/mo, Pro Report at €19.18/mo, Lead Generation at €86.31/mo, additional users starting at €43/mo — fees exclusive of taxes, and API credit costs per endpoint. But we found no price for the main paid tiers on the captured pricing pages, Advanced is custom pricing behind a demo request, and we found no overage rates or crawl page limits. The annual invoice is therefore not computable from the captured pages alone.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Ahrefs
Semrush
Legal entity
Incorporated in SG
Incorporated in US
Hosting location
Outside the EU
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Semrush higher: 3.5/5 against 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 0 of the 6 judges pick Ahrefs and 6 pick Semrush. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Ahrefs or Semrush European?
Ahrefs is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Singapore). Semrush is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United States). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Ahrefs and Semrush store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Ahrefs: Outside the EU by default. Semrush: Outside the EU by default.
Do Ahrefs and Semrush have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.