As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates Deputy 3/5 and Planday 3/5 in Employee Scheduling. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Deputy scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (Roster building & demand planning, Works council & employee data, Pricing transparency, plus 2 more). Planday scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Working-time law & collective agreements and Payroll handoff & integrations). Provenance — Deputy: Rest of world, Australia; Planday: EU origin, foreign-owned. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The table puts Deputy ahead on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0, six judges lean Deputy), staff self service (6.5 vs 6.0, three lean Deputy, three tie), and — with five judges leaning Deputy on each — pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8), sovereignty (2.8 vs 0.3) and codetermination and privacy (4.8 vs 3.7). Planday leads working time rules (5.5 vs 4.3, six judges lean Planday); payroll and integrations splits 6.2 vs 6.3, with three judges tying, two leaning Planday and one Deputy. Weighted totals split by judge: shift manager (6 vs 5.5), frontline employee (5.9 vs 5.6) and skeptic (5.2 vs 4.9) favor Deputy; payroll officer (5.5 vs 6.1) and works council (4.6 vs 5) favor Planday; one judge's total is not shown. Deputy lists jurisdiction AU and a self-serve data processing agreement; we found no public information on data residency or hosting. Planday's jurisdiction, residency, hosting, open-source and data-processing entries read unknown.
Choose Deputy if
You need demand-driven auto-scheduling — forecasted sales, delivery orders and foot traffic feed the plan, with hour and wage budgets tracked in real time; six judges lean Deputy on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0).
You need to compute much of the invoice from published per-user prices — Lite $5, Core $6.50, Pro $9 per user per month, USD excl. all applicable taxes; five judges lean Deputy on pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8).
You need a self-serve data processing agreement and a listed legal entity jurisdiction (AU) before signing — Planday's data processing agreement and jurisdiction entries read unknown.
You need the stronger panel read on codetermination and privacy — five judges lean Deputy (4.8 vs 3.7); its works-council advocate still sat a point lower, citing biometric clocking and location-verified clock-ins with defaults unstated.
Your team weighs staff self service heavily — Deputy's mean is 6.5 vs 6.0, with three judges leaning Deputy and three tying.
Choose Planday if
You need the stronger read on working time rules — six judges lean Planday (5.5 vs 4.3), though its help pages state a rule cannot block creating or assigning a rule-breaking shift and no statutory limits like the ArbZG eleven-hour rest period are publicly named.
You need DATEV Lohn und Gehalt payroll integration — documented salary codes, per-employee salary identifiers and payslips imported back for staff; Planday's payroll and integrations mean is 6.3 vs Deputy's 6.2, with two judges leaning Planday and three tying.
Your payroll team's priorities match the payroll-officer lens — that judge's weighted total favors Planday 6.1 to 5.5.
Your works council holds approval power — the works-council judge's weighted total favors Planday 5 to 4.6, even as five judges lean Deputy on codetermination and privacy overall.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Frontline Employee
Works part-time shifts next to a second job or a degree and never opens a laptop at work. Judges the product by its phone app: can she mark availability, swap a shift without three calls, see her hours, and read it in her own language. A roster she learns about from a photo in a group chat has failed.
Deputy
This judge's pick
Planday
Criterion by criterion
Roster building & demand planning
Deputy
The planner side is strong: forecasting pulls named demand sources — sales, delivery orders, foot traffic — into auto-built schedule templates, one-click auto-scheduling weighs availability, training and cost, and hour-and-wage budgets show real-time variance while building. That is demand-based planning with automatic proposals and labour cost against budget; we found no public information on cross-location staff sharing or on the proposal explaining which rule drove each assignment.
Planday
Week and day templates that can publish straight to staff, open shifts created from templates, and employees filtered by department, employee group and skills with colour-coded conflicts — plus an auto-schedule tool on the Pro plan and revenue forecasting and labour costs named in the tier lists. But we found no public information on staffing requirements per shift, costs checked against a budget while planning, or cross-location staff sharing, so this reads as suggestions the manager accepts or rejects, not a closed loop.
Working-time law & collective agreements
Deputy
Minimum rest between shifts, maximum weekly hours and break timing are named guardrails, with missed breaks flagged and attested and early return to work prevented — enforcement during planning, not just an export. The break-law material is written for US states and the feature lists speak of fair workweek and US pay rates; we found no public information on ArbZG, Tarifvertrag surcharges, Minijob earnings limits, youth protection or per-person contract-hours tracking.
Planday
Named checks exist — daily and weekly hour caps, hours off between shifts, consecutive-day limits forcing an off day — shown to the planner as cautions and conflicts before publishing, configurable per employee group and shift type, with a separate contract-rules feature and an Excel infraction report. The vendor itself states a working time rule cannot block creating or assigning a shift, and we found no public information naming ArbZG, the 11-hour rest period, Minijob ceilings, Tarifvertrag surcharges or youth protection.
Mobile self-service for deskless staff
Deputy
The phone is the product: schedules reach my device with automatic reminders, I can mark unavailable days, request time off, swap directly with suitable teammates and get mobile alerts when a shift opens — plus clock-in with a location check, pay stubs in the app, and a news feed that keeps shift talk out of my private group chats. We found no public information on interface languages, offline clock-in, or rest-period checks before a swap is approved, so it sits below the very top.
Planday
This is what decides it for someone like me: availability is set in the phone app with bulk edits and comments, open shifts sit in a red widget on the app's home screen and are only shown if my department, skills and conflicts allow, and a colleague selling a shift becomes one I can claim — with in-app messenger and newsfeed keeping shift talk out of group chats. Requests still wait for manager approval, a manager can lock availability periods and assign me despite it, and we found no public information on push notifications of changes, the app's languages, or employees exporting their own data.
Works council & employee data
Deputy
Custom access levels and a privacy centre publishing a data processing addendum and a sub-processor list give the basics, with a 30-day export window and deletion after termination written into the agreement. We found no public information on a per-person audit log, hiding absence reasons from colleagues, tracking off by default, configurable deletion periods, or materials a works council would need to approve introduction.
Planday
What is documented is roles: Administrator, schedule manager and 'any' employee access levels across the help pages, with custom permissions and user roles on the Pro plan. We found no public information on a data processing agreement, audit logs of who viewed whose data, retention of availability or absence data, location tracking, or any documentation a works council would need under BetrVG § 87.
Payroll handoff & integrations
Deputy
Approved timesheets, pay rates and leave go to Paycor in one click after individual or bulk approval, POS sales data feeds the schedule, and there is a documented API alongside payroll, point-of-sale and HR integration categories. Only one payroll destination is named and it is US-only with a fee that "varies by business size"; we found no public information on DATEV, wage-type mapping per surcharge, or an HR master-data sync.
Planday
The DATEV Lohn und Gehalt guide goes deep: salary codes for normal hours, extra hours and payroll supplements mapped per employee and per employee group, an export scoped to all staff or specific groups, and payslips imported back so employees see them in Planday. Around it sit 17 payroll, 21 POS and several HR integration collections plus an Open API — though we found no public information on a lock step before transmission, POS feeding the forecast, or retro corrections after the close.
European sovereignty
Deputy
The marks belong to an Australian company and every footer shows a San Francisco address; a self-serve data processing addendum and a published sub-processor list exist. We found no public information on where employee data is hosted or on any EU hosting claim — thin for a tool that would hold my availability and where I clocked in.
Planday
We found no public information on where employee data is hosted, on subprocessors, or on a data processing agreement — the captured vendor pages cover features and prices only, and the dimensions of this criterion stand as unknown rather than proven either way. A buyer with availability and absence data of staff on the line will have to ask Planday directly.
Pricing transparency
Deputy
Every main tier is public per user per month with annual and monthly figures, a stated 10% annual discount, and taxes stated as excluded — and the Analytics+, Messaging+ and HR add-ons each carry a public dollar figure. The payroll add-on "varies by business size", Flexi and charity pricing are by enquiry, and we found no public information on how seasonal or inactive staff are counted or on minimum terms.
Planday
You can do the maths for two of the three tiers: Starter at €2.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat with minimum 5 users, Plus at €4.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat plus a €25.00 monatliche Abogebühr with minimum 10, a user defined as anyone with a login and billed in packs of five, payable monthly or quarterly. Pro is 'Individuelle Preisgestaltung', SMS and onboarding are named as extra costs without amounts, and we found no public information on VAT treatment or minimum terms.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Deputy
Planday
Legal entity
Incorporated in AU
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
Fact
Deputy
Planday
Pricing · Pro price
excl. all applicable taxes · billed upfront or in monthly installments · 91
As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Deputy or Planday European?
Deputy is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Australia). Planday is European (EU origin, foreign-owned). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Deputy and Planday have a free plan?
As of 17 Nov 2026, Deputy’s own pages state a free plan; Planday’s pages as captured do not. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.