As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates Deputy 3/5 and Planday 3/5 in Employee Scheduling. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Deputy scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (Roster building & demand planning, Works council & employee data, Pricing transparency, plus 2 more). Planday scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Working-time law & collective agreements and Payroll handoff & integrations). Provenance — Deputy: Rest of world, Australia; Planday: EU origin, foreign-owned. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The table puts Deputy ahead on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0, six judges lean Deputy), staff self service (6.5 vs 6.0, three lean Deputy, three tie), and — with five judges leaning Deputy on each — pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8), sovereignty (2.8 vs 0.3) and codetermination and privacy (4.8 vs 3.7). Planday leads working time rules (5.5 vs 4.3, six judges lean Planday); payroll and integrations splits 6.2 vs 6.3, with three judges tying, two leaning Planday and one Deputy. Weighted totals split by judge: shift manager (6 vs 5.5), frontline employee (5.9 vs 5.6) and skeptic (5.2 vs 4.9) favor Deputy; payroll officer (5.5 vs 6.1) and works council (4.6 vs 5) favor Planday; one judge's total is not shown. Deputy lists jurisdiction AU and a self-serve data processing agreement; we found no public information on data residency or hosting. Planday's jurisdiction, residency, hosting, open-source and data-processing entries read unknown.
Choose Deputy if
You need demand-driven auto-scheduling — forecasted sales, delivery orders and foot traffic feed the plan, with hour and wage budgets tracked in real time; six judges lean Deputy on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0).
You need to compute much of the invoice from published per-user prices — Lite $5, Core $6.50, Pro $9 per user per month, USD excl. all applicable taxes; five judges lean Deputy on pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8).
You need a self-serve data processing agreement and a listed legal entity jurisdiction (AU) before signing — Planday's data processing agreement and jurisdiction entries read unknown.
You need the stronger panel read on codetermination and privacy — five judges lean Deputy (4.8 vs 3.7); its works-council advocate still sat a point lower, citing biometric clocking and location-verified clock-ins with defaults unstated.
Your team weighs staff self service heavily — Deputy's mean is 6.5 vs 6.0, with three judges leaning Deputy and three tying.
Choose Planday if
You need the stronger read on working time rules — six judges lean Planday (5.5 vs 4.3), though its help pages state a rule cannot block creating or assigning a rule-breaking shift and no statutory limits like the ArbZG eleven-hour rest period are publicly named.
You need DATEV Lohn und Gehalt payroll integration — documented salary codes, per-employee salary identifiers and payslips imported back for staff; Planday's payroll and integrations mean is 6.3 vs Deputy's 6.2, with two judges leaning Planday and three tying.
Your payroll team's priorities match the payroll-officer lens — that judge's weighted total favors Planday 6.1 to 5.5.
Your works council holds approval power — the works-council judge's weighted total favors Planday 5 to 4.6, even as five judges lean Deputy on codetermination and privacy overall.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Skeptic
Has read a great many pages saying the product "supports" the Arbeitszeitgesetz and wants to know whether it blocks a violation, warns about it, or merely exports it. Reads for which tier the time clock and the DATEV export sit in, how seasonal staff are counted per employee, and what the forecasting "AI" actually uses as input.
Deputy
This judge's pick
Planday
Criterion by criterion
Roster building & demand planning
Deputy
Auto-scheduling fills shifts from named demand inputs — forecasted sales, delivery orders, foot traffic — with priorities such as lowest cost and minimum coverage rules, and hour and wage budgets with real-time variance tracking sit in the planner while forecast is compared against actual sales in the same product. The engine is sold as "AI" with the forecasting method undocumented, and we found no public information on cross-location staff sharing, so the loop is not closed to the top level.
Planday
Week and day templates publish to staff, open shifts appear while planning, and assignment suggestions filter by department, employee group and skills, each with a short note explaining the recommendation — though no employee is assigned automatically and the auto-schedule tool is documented only as a Pro-plan title. The revenue forecast appears as a feature word with revenue integration in Plus, but we found no public information on staffing requirements per shift, a demand figure driving a proposed roster, or labour cost shown against budget while planning.
Working-time law & collective agreements
Deputy
The pages show named guardrails — minimum rest between shifts and maximum weekly hours — plus break templates for "strict break law states", enforcement of break timing, flagging of missed breaks with employee attestation, and a captured compliance record; the surrounding language is US-shaped (fair workweek, built-in US pay rates). We found no public information on the ArbZG rest period, Minijob earnings limits, Tarifvertrag surcharges, youth protection, per-employee contract-hour tracking, or whether a check blocks the roster or only warns.
Planday
The rule engine is genuinely configurable — maximum hours per day or week, hours off between shifts, consecutive working days, shift duration — applied per employee group and type, with Caution and Critical-conflict statuses shown while assigning. But the captured pages state plainly that a working time rule "cannot block you from creating or assigning a shift, even if it breaks its guidelines", offering an Excel report of infractions afterwards, and the rules are the company's own guidelines; we found no public information naming the Arbeitszeitgesetz, the 11-hour rest period, Minijob earnings ceilings, youth protection or collective-agreement surcharges.
Mobile self-service for deskless staff
Deputy
The app covers the roster with automatic reminders, leave and availability requests with manager approval, shift swaps with "suitable team members", open-shift offers with mobile alerts, clock-in with location verification, a news feed, and in-app pay stubs — a genuine phone-first package. We found no public information on swaps being resolved against qualifications and rest periods before approval, offline clock-in handling, or language coverage.
Planday
The mobile app carries availability with bulk edits and comments, open shifts in a widget on the overview screen with a request button, and colleagues' sold shifts to claim; open-shift visibility is gated by department, employee group, skills and schedule conflicts before a manager approves. Punch Clock is named in the features list, but we found no public information on clock-in by shared terminal, offline handling, or multilingual coverage.
Works council & employee data
Deputy
Custom access levels exist but are listed as a Pro-plan feature; a data processing agreement is published and incorporated into the subscription terms, a sub-processor list sits in the privacy centre, GDPR Article 9 data is contractually excluded, and customer data may be deleted on termination. We found no public information on an audit log of who viewed an individual's data, configurable deletion periods, default-off location tracking, or documentation supporting a works agreement under co-determination law.
Planday
Every help article stamps its access level — Administrator, Schedule manager, Any — and the Pro plan sells custom permissions and user roles, which evidences differentiated rights down to the individual feature. We found no public information on a data processing agreement, retention or deletion periods for availability and absence data, an audit log of who viewed an employee's data, or documentation a works council would need under §87 BetrVG.
Payroll handoff & integrations
Deputy
Verified timesheets are approved individually or in bulk and then sent to a named payroll system (Paycor) in one click, with a documented API and a POS connection feeding sales data into scheduling and forecasting — an approval step before transmission, though the payroll add-on is described as available on annual Core and Pro plans in the US only. We found no public information on DATEV or another German payroll connection, or on wage types mapped per surcharge such as night, Sunday or holiday.
Planday
The DATEV Lohn und Gehalt guide is deep — an.INI import, Berater and Mandanten numbers, salary codes distinguishing normal hours, extra hours and payroll supplements, per-employee salary identifiers and employee-group overrides — and payslips import back for employees, with seventeen payroll and twenty-one POS integration articles plus an Open API how-to around it. We found no public information on a lock step before transmission, on POS data feeding the forecast, or on how the payroll connectors are maintained.
European sovereignty
Deputy
The trademark owner is the Australian Deputechnologies Pty Ltd, the address shown throughout the captured pages is a US corporation in San Francisco, and a data processing agreement plus sub-processor list are published. We found no public information on where employee data is hosted, an EU contracting entity, or transfer safeguards — a real question for a tool that records when and where staff worked.
Planday
The captured vendor information names Planday A/S in Copenhagen (CVR 27666248), acquired by Xero of New Zealand in 2021, with legal documents hosted on Xero infrastructure — a named EU vendor whose ownership chain runs outside it. The captured pages state nothing about where employee data is hosted, a data processing agreement or subprocessors; we found no public information on any of these.
Pricing transparency
Deputy
Each plan is priced per user per month with annual and monthly figures and taxes stated as excluded (Lite "$5 per user per month", Core "$6.50", Pro "$9"), time clocking sits inside the tiers rather than as an add-on, and the add-ons carry figures (Analytics+ $1.50, HR $2, Messaging+ $1.95 per user per month); the payroll add-on instead states its "Monthly base and per employee fee varies by business size", and we found no public information on how inactive or seasonal staff are counted. The captured pricing pages also give different figures for the plan set between the visible plans and the machine-readable offers, which include a Premium figure.
Planday
Starter at €2.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat from 5 users and Plus at €4.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat plus €25.00 monatliche Abogebühr from 10 users are published with monthly or quarterly billing, and the counting is explicit: a user is anyone with a login, billed in packs of five rounded up. Pro is "Individuelle Preisgestaltung", and we found no public information on VAT treatment, minimum term, or the amounts of the per-SMS fee and paid onboarding — so a buyer can compute Starter and Plus but not the whole invoice.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Deputy
Planday
Legal entity
Incorporated in AU
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
Fact
Deputy
Planday
Pricing · Pro price
excl. all applicable taxes · billed upfront or in monthly installments · 91
As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Deputy or Planday European?
Deputy is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Australia). Planday is European (EU origin, foreign-owned). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Deputy and Planday have a free plan?
As of 17 Nov 2026, Deputy’s own pages state a free plan; Planday’s pages as captured do not. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.