Deputy vs Planday

Deputy

Rest of world

Sovereignty: 2 of 6 dimensions proven

Full evaluation →

Planday

EU origin, foreign-owned

Sovereignty: not determined

Full evaluation →

As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates Deputy 3/5 and Planday 3/5 in Employee Scheduling. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Deputy scores higher on 5 of 7 criteria (Roster building & demand planning, Works council & employee data, Pricing transparency, plus 2 more). Planday scores higher on 2 of 7 criteria (Working-time law & collective agreements and Payroll handoff & integrations). Provenance — Deputy: Rest of world, Australia; Planday: EU origin, foreign-owned. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.

The short answer

The table puts Deputy ahead on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0, six judges lean Deputy), staff self service (6.5 vs 6.0, three lean Deputy, three tie), and — with five judges leaning Deputy on each — pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8), sovereignty (2.8 vs 0.3) and codetermination and privacy (4.8 vs 3.7). Planday leads working time rules (5.5 vs 4.3, six judges lean Planday); payroll and integrations splits 6.2 vs 6.3, with three judges tying, two leaning Planday and one Deputy. Weighted totals split by judge: shift manager (6 vs 5.5), frontline employee (5.9 vs 5.6) and skeptic (5.2 vs 4.9) favor Deputy; payroll officer (5.5 vs 6.1) and works council (4.6 vs 5) favor Planday; one judge's total is not shown. Deputy lists jurisdiction AU and a self-serve data processing agreement; we found no public information on data residency or hosting. Planday's jurisdiction, residency, hosting, open-source and data-processing entries read unknown.

Choose Deputy if

  • You need demand-driven auto-scheduling — forecasted sales, delivery orders and foot traffic feed the plan, with hour and wage budgets tracked in real time; six judges lean Deputy on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.0).
  • You need to compute much of the invoice from published per-user prices — Lite $5, Core $6.50, Pro $9 per user per month, USD excl. all applicable taxes; five judges lean Deputy on pricing transparency (6.8 vs 5.8).
  • You need a self-serve data processing agreement and a listed legal entity jurisdiction (AU) before signing — Planday's data processing agreement and jurisdiction entries read unknown.
  • You need the stronger panel read on codetermination and privacy — five judges lean Deputy (4.8 vs 3.7); its works-council advocate still sat a point lower, citing biometric clocking and location-verified clock-ins with defaults unstated.
  • Your team weighs staff self service heavily — Deputy's mean is 6.5 vs 6.0, with three judges leaning Deputy and three tying.

Choose Planday if

  • You need the stronger read on working time rules — six judges lean Planday (5.5 vs 4.3), though its help pages state a rule cannot block creating or assigning a rule-breaking shift and no statutory limits like the ArbZG eleven-hour rest period are publicly named.
  • You need DATEV Lohn und Gehalt payroll integration — documented salary codes, per-employee salary identifiers and payslips imported back for staff; Planday's payroll and integrations mean is 6.3 vs Deputy's 6.2, with two judges leaning Planday and three tying.
  • Your payroll team's priorities match the payroll-officer lens — that judge's weighted total favors Planday 6.1 to 5.5.
  • Your works council holds approval power — the works-council judge's weighted total favors Planday 5 to 4.6, even as five judges lean Deputy on codetermination and privacy overall.

Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The Operations Director

Answers for labour cost across thirty locations in retail, hospitality or care. Wants demand-based planning from real POS or occupancy data, labour cost against budget while the plan is still editable, and staff shared across sites. Reads "AI-powered scheduling" as a request to see the method.

Deputy

Planday

This judge calls it a tie.

Criterion by criterion

Roster building & demand planning

Deputy

Demand planning is real here: forecasted sales, delivery orders and foot traffic feed auto-built templates, the POS integration feeds sales data into the schedule, and hour and wage budgets with real-time variance tracking put labour cost in front of the planner while the plan is still editable — my headline test, and it passes. Auto-fill weighs staff availability, training and cost with configurable priorities such as lowest cost, and real-time sales graphs compare forecast against actual. What I did not find: staff shared across sites, and every optimiser is called AI with no documented forecasting method, which I read as a vendor not yet willing to show its maths.

Planday

Week and day templates with draft-before-publish, eligibility filtered by department, employee group and skills, open shifts, and an auto-schedule tool gated to the Pro plan are documented, alongside revenue integration and reporting on Plus. Each suggested employee comes with a short note explaining the recommendation, though the top recommendation mode is described only as learning from patterns rather than a documented forecasting method. We found no public information on staffing requirements per shift, labour cost against budget while the plan is still editable, or staff shared across several locations.

Working-time law & collective agreements

Deputy

Named guardrails exist — minimum rest between shifts, maximum weekly hours, and break timing enforcement with missed-break flagging and employee attestation — but the entire compliance frame is US state break law and fair-workweek rules; we found no public information on ArbZG rest periods, Minijob earnings limits, Tarifvertrag surcharges or youth-protection limits. Nothing states whether a check blocks publishing or only warns, nor any per-employee contract-hours tracking.

Planday

Named, configurable rules are evidenced — maximum hours per day or week, hours off between shifts, consecutive working days — applied per employee group and shift type, with planner warnings such as exceeding contracted hours, and the vendor states plainly that a working time rule cannot block creating or assigning a shift. We found no public information tying checks to ArbZG rest periods, the Minijob earnings ceiling, Tarifvertrag surcharges or youth-protection limits.

Mobile self-service for deskless staff

Deputy

The app covers the shop floor well: schedules sent with automatic reminders, availability and leave requests with manager approval, direct shift swaps with suitable team members, open-shift mobile alerts, clock-in with location verification, news feed and messaging, and pay stubs in-app on web, iOS and Android. We found no public information on offline clock-in handling, multilingual coverage, or whether swaps are checked against qualifications and rest rules before approval.

Planday

The mobile app handles availability (whole days, preferred hours, shift types, bulk edits), open-shift requests whose visibility is gated by department, employee group, skills and schedule conflicts, and claiming of shifts sold by colleagues, with an in-app messenger and newsfeed alongside. Requests still require manager approval, and we found no public information on multilingual coverage, offline punch-clock handling, or employees viewing and exporting the data held about them.

Works council & employee data

Deputy

Pro plans carry custom access levels, a data processing addendum and a sub-processor list are published in the Privacy Centre, and customer data is deleted on termination — a base a works agreement could start from. We found no public information on audit logs of who viewed or changed an individual's data, configurable deletion periods, or whether location capture can be switched off; nothing in the captured pages offers documentation for works-council approval under BetrVG § 87.

Planday

Access levels are documented per feature (Administrator, Schedule manager, Any) and the Pro plan adds custom permissions and user roles. We found no public information on a data processing agreement, retention or deletion periods for availability and absence data, an audit log of who viewed an individual's data, or documentation offered for works-council approval.

Payroll handoff & integrations

Deputy

The payroll handoff is documented for one named system: approve timesheets in Deputy, click Send to Paycor, and approved timesheets, pay rates and leave transfer in one click — available on annual Core and Pro plans in the US, with a monthly base and per-employee fee that varies by business size. Beyond that there is a generic export of approved timesheets to "your payroll software", documented API with examples, and integration categories for payroll, POS and HR; we found no public information on DATEV or other European payroll connections, wage-type mapping per surcharge, or scoped tax-adviser access.

Planday

A documented DATEV Lohn und Gehalt export is evidenced in depth — salary codes distinguishing normal hours, extra hours and payroll supplements, per-employee salary identifier mapping, and payslip import back into the product — plus a documented Open API and payroll, POS, HR and Xero payroll integration collections. We found no public information on a lock step before transmission, whether integrations are vendor-maintained, or POS data feeding the forecast.

European sovereignty

Deputy

The contracting entity shown in the captured terms is Deputy Corporation in San Francisco, the vendor is Australian (Deputechnologies Pty Ltd), and we found no public information on where employee data is hosted — no EU hosting option is claimed anywhere in the captured pages. A self-serve data processing addendum and a sub-processor list are published, which is the minimum documented baseline; for a tool holding availability and location-verified clock-ins, that is thin for a European deployment.

Planday

The pages we read — the homepage, pricing pages and help-centre articles — state nothing about where employee data is hosted, the subprocessors, or a data processing agreement, so we found no public information on this and report it without a score.

Pricing transparency

Deputy

Three tiers are fully public — Lite at $5, Core at $6.50 and Pro at $9 per user per month (USD excl. all applicable taxes) — with priced add-ons (Analytics+ $1.50, Messaging+ $1.95, HR $2 per user per month), a 10% annual discount, a 31-day trial without credit card and net-30 terms. The payroll add-on's monthly base and per-employee fee varies by business size, so it carries no number, we found no public information on how inactive or seasonal staff are counted toward the per-user bill, and the captured pages give different figures for some plan names and prices.

Planday

Starter at €2.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat (Mind. 5 Benutzer) and Plus at €4.99 Pro Benutzer/Monat plus €25.00 monatliche Abogebühr (Mind. 10 Benutzer) are public, with monthly or quarterly billing and the five-user pack rounding explained, so two of three tiers are computable to an invoice. Pro is individual pricing, SMS is charged per SMS and onboarding is a paid service without stated figures, and we found no public information on VAT treatment.

Sovereignty, side by side

Dimension Deputy Planday
Legal entity Incorporated in AU Not determined
Hosting location Not determined Not determined
Hosting options Not determined Not determined
Open source Not determined Not determined
Data processing agreement Published, self-serve Not determined
Transfer impact assessment Not determined Not determined

Facts, side by side

Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.

Fact Deputy Planday
Pricing · Pro price excl. all applicable taxes · billed upfront or in monthly installments · 91

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Individuelle Preisgestaltung2

captured 19 Oct 2026 may be out of date · Report an error

Pricing · Trial 31 · yes · no3

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

30 · yes · no4

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Product · Features list Analytics · Auto scheduling · Break planning compliance · Demand forecasting · Fair workweek compliance · Integrations · Labor law compliance · Micro-scheduling · Mobile app · Payroll software · Scheduling · Shift planning · Shift swapping · Smart scheduling · Task management · Time clock app · Time tracking · Workplace communication5

captured 9 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Dienstplanung; Mitarbeiterverfügbarkeit; Vorlagen; Zeiterfassung; Stempeluhr; Stundenzettel; Lohnberichterstattung; Überstunden; Abwesenheit & Urlaub; Urlaubsmanagement; Abwesenheitsmanagement; Handy-App (Mitarbeiter/Manager); Messenger & SMS; Newsfeed; Personalkosten; Umsatzprognose; Dienstplan-Berichterstattung; Organisationsstruktur; HRIS; Dokumentenmanagement; Mitarbeiterentwicklung; Compliance; Sicherheit2

captured 19 Oct 2026 · Report an error

Product · Modules AI Agent · Scheduling · Timekeeping · Compliance · HR · Payroll · Communication6

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Dienstplanung; Arbeitszeiterfassung; Lohnvorbereitung; Mitarbeiter-App; Team-Kommunikation; Verwaltung von Mitarbeiterinformationen; Berichterstattung und Analysen; Integrationen2

captured 19 Oct 2026 · Report an error

Product · Pro features Custom Access Levels · Advanced Timesheets · Location Hierarchies · Pay Centers · Single Sign-On (SSO) · Dedicated Customer Success Manager · Sandbox Environment · 24/7 Live Chat · Analytics+ · Messaging+1

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Pro includes custom planning metrics, automatic scheduling, configurable org structure, custom permissions and roles, individual account setup4

captured 16 Nov 2026 · Report an error

Questions about Deputy and Planday

Which is better, Deputy or Planday?

As of 17 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 6 judges pick Deputy and 2 pick Planday, 1 calls it a tie. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.

Is Deputy or Planday European?

Deputy is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Australia). Planday is European (EU origin, foreign-owned). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.

Do Deputy and Planday have a free plan?

As of 17 Nov 2026, Deputy’s own pages state a free plan; Planday’s pages as captured do not. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.