As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates DOMUS 1.5/5 and Karthago 1.5/5 in Property & WEG Management. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 4 judges pick DOMUS and 1 picks Karthago. DOMUS scores higher on 3 of 5 criteria (Owner & tenant self-service, Maintenance, defects & contractors and Documents, retention & handover). Karthago scores higher on 2 of 5 criteria (European sovereignty and Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage). Provenance — DOMUS: EU-Made, Germany; Karthago: EU-Made. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Karthago is ahead on WEG accounting (3.7 vs 2.2; four lean Karthago), maintenance and defects (2.7 vs 2.2) and sovereignty (3.8 vs 3.0; five lean Karthago) — attributes list EU-only data residency and a self-hostable option; DOMUS lists Germany as jurisdiction, with data residency and hosting options unknown. DOMUS is ahead on assembly and resolutions (2.7 vs 0.0; four lean DOMUS) and owner self-service (2.2 vs 1.0; three lean DOMUS, three ties). Documents and handover splits three to three. Weighted totals favor DOMUS with the portfolio manager (4.4 vs 3.1), the WEG property manager (3.5 vs 3.2) and the accountant (3.4 vs 2.9); the advisory board member leans Karthago (3.1 vs 2.1); the data protection officer and skeptic show no total for DOMUS — captures stop at page titles in most areas. Both publish no prices (pricing transparency 0.5 vs 0.2). No overall winner — the lean differs by judge and criterion.
Choose DOMUS if
You convene online owners' meetings and need recorded votes: DOMUS pages advertise a voting module and new WEG meeting functions, and four judges lean DOMUS on assembly and resolutions (2.7 vs 0.0).
You want owners handling their own cases: the homecase owner portal sits behind owner self-service at 2.2 vs 1.0, with three judges leaning DOMUS and three ties.
You need a contracting entity in Germany: DOMUS is an Aktiengesellschaft registered at Amtsgericht München with a named internal data protection officer; jurisdiction is listed as DE.
Your evaluation team's weights match the portfolio manager's bench: that judge totals 4.4 for DOMUS vs 3.1 for Karthago, and the WEG property manager (3.5 vs 3.2) and accountant (3.4 vs 2.9) totals also favor DOMUS.
Choose Karthago if
WEG accounting is your core requirement: Karthago's published module list names double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and a WEG and utility settlement module, and four judges lean Karthago there (3.7 vs 2.2).
You require EU-only data residency: Karthago's data residency attribute reads EU-only, the cloud runs on German servers with certified data protection stated, and five judges lean Karthago on sovereignty (3.8 vs 3.0).
You must run the software on your own infrastructure: hosting options are self-hostable — the verdict calls it a genuine on-premise option.
Your data protection officer signs off on the purchase: that judge totals 3.6 for Karthago, while no total is recorded for DOMUS.
Your owners' advisory board holds the deciding vote: the advisory board member's total is 3.1 for Karthago vs 2.1 for DOMUS.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Portfolio Manager
Runs a firm managing several thousand units and lives on throughput. Wants statutory inspections scheduled with proof stored, defects that route to the right trade, multi-community reporting, and onboarding a new WEG that takes days rather than a quarter.
DOMUS
This judge's pick
Karthago
Criterion by criterion
Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage
DOMUS
DOMUS 1000 has dedicated product pages for booking the Wirtschaftsplan and for creating the Hausgeldabrechnung to the "WEG 2.0" standard, so the statutory settlement cycle is clearly product scope. The captured pages say nothing about the Abrechnungsspitze, the Vermögensbericht, separate reserve statements or distribution keys, so I can credit generated statements but not accountant-grade discharge.
Karthago
Karthago is aimed explicitly at WEG and rental administrations, and the published module list names Doppelte Buchhaltung, WEG- und Nebenkostenabrechnung and automated invoice import, so the statutory settlement cycle is clearly in the product's scope as more than templates. The pages stop at module names, though: we found no public information on Wirtschaftsplan generation, configurable distribution keys, reserve-fund handling in trust, or the post-2021 settlement form, so I cannot credit the settlement depth that decides my purchase.
Eigentümerversammlung & Beschluss-Sammlung
DOMUS
HomeCase is marketed with an explicit voting module for online owners' meetings plus "new WEG meeting functions", which is the online-meeting capability I need for throughput across thousands of units. We found no public information on quorum or majority computation, the Beschluss-Sammlung as a continuously maintained register, or amendment and invalidation notes under § 24 (7) WEG.
Karthago
We found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes per agenda item, majority arithmetic, or the resolution register the administrator must maintain — the captured pages I read cover deployment, modules and contact forms, and touch on the Versammlung in none of them. For a multi-thousand-unit portfolio that is a dimension I simply cannot assess.
Owner & tenant self-service
DOMUS
Documents can be placed online for owners in HomeCase, and the same platform hosts online owner meetings with voting, so owners clearly reach a portal with their papers. We found no public information on per-owner statements, tenant visibility or defect reports with status visible to the reporter.
Karthago
The captured pages describe communication with owners and tenants as one of the processes steered in the solution, which tells me correspondence is in scope but says nothing about who serves it. We found no public information on an owner or tenant portal, personal logins, statements or meeting papers delivered there, or a defect form with visible status, so I cannot credit the correspondence reduction I buy portals for.
Maintenance, defects & contractors
DOMUS
There is a ServiceCase maintenance portal and a communication platform explicitly aimed at craftsmen and service providers, which points at defect routing to the right trade rather than a bare ticket list. Statutory inspections scheduled with proof stored — my main requirement — and recurring maintenance obligations appear nowhere on the captured pages.
Karthago
A Digitales Facility Management module appears in the published module list, which puts the building side inside the product's scope. We found no public information on statutory inspections — lift, heating, fire safety, drinking water — scheduled with proof of completion stored, on defects routed to the responsible trade, or on recurring maintenance reminders, and that evidence trail is exactly what my operation runs on.
Documents, retention & handover
DOMUS
Reports and data exports have their own product page and documents can be placed online per community, so basic archiving and export exist. Full-text search, version history, retention periods and a structured handover package a successor administrator could actually load are not shown on the captured pages.
Karthago
An integriertes Dokumentenmanagement module is named in the published module list, which covers central storage in a property context. We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods, or a structured handover package a successor administrator could load — for me the exit is a statutory event, and the captured pages give me nothing on it.
European sovereignty
DOMUS
The vendor is a German AG registered in Munich and the privacy policy honestly names possible third-country transfers covered by adequacy decisions or standard contractual clauses, which is generic boilerplate rather than product substance. Hosting location for the product, subprocessors and a data processing agreement are unknown on the captured pages, so only the contracting entity's European character is proven.
Karthago
German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud variant across several captures, and the on-premise variant leaves all data and systems in the customer's hands — a combination I weigh heavily; the group's compliance page also names a whistleblowing provider with a data center in Deutschland. The contracting entity's jurisdiction is not confirmed on the vendor's own captured pages, and we found no public information on a data-processing agreement or the subprocessor chain, so the chain is proven only in part.
Pricing transparency
DOMUS
Pricing runs through an offer request inside a consultation call, with an optional product configurator, and products are also sold via the online shop of the partner TSA Solution GmbH — no figures appear on any captured page. For a portfolio my size there is no way to compute the annual cost without a sales conversation.
Karthago
Everything routes through a personal consultation form that collects verwaltete Einheiten and benötigte Arbeitsplätze — the price drivers are visible, but I found no public price figures, tiers, billing periods, setup or migration costs in the captured pages. For my unit count I cannot compute an annual cost from these pages alone; every quote is a sales conversation.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
DOMUS
Karthago
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
EU only
Hosting options
Not determined
Self-hostable
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 1.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 3 of the 4 judges pick DOMUS and 1 picks Karthago. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is DOMUS or Karthago European?
DOMUS is European (EU-Made, Germany). Karthago is European (EU-Made). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do DOMUS and Karthago store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — DOMUS: its pages as captured do not say. Karthago: In the EU.