Panel rating · 6 judges · How to read the stars

Category median

Sovereignty: 2 of 6 dimensions proven

0–5 in half steps. 5 means the rubric's top anchor is met on the evidence.

by Karthago Systeme GmbH · www.karthago.de

Compare with DOMUS → Report an error on this page Is this your product? →

Link to this page

Karthago: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai Karthago: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai (dark)

Add ?theme=dark to the image address for dark backgrounds. The badge shows the category and the month of the latest evaluation, and EU-Made where that is the product’s provenance. It never shows a score.

Karthago at a glance

Vendor
Karthago Systeme GmbH
Headquarters
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
Data hosting
In the EU source, captured 16 Nov 2026
Free plan
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
Panel verdict
The AI panel rates Karthago 1.5/5, the mean of 6 judges. Karthago is ERP software from Karthago Systeme GmbH for mid-sized and large administrations of WEG and rental properties, with 30 years of development. how scores are made
As of
Vendor pages captured 15 Sep 2026 to 16 Nov 2026; evaluated by the panel 18 Nov 2026. all sources

Karthago alternatives, European ones first →

Read this page as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The panel's verdict

Karthago is ERP software from Karthago Systeme GmbH for mid-sized and large administrations of WEG and rental properties, with 30 years of development. Weighted verdicts run from 2.9 to 3.6. It is strongest on WEG accounting, scoring 3-4: the published module list names double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and a WEG and utility settlement module, and the lower marks reflect pages that stop at module names, with no public information on the business plan, distribution keys or reserve-fund handling. Sovereignty scores 3-4, resting on German servers with certified data protection stated for the cloud and a genuine on-premise option; we found no public information on a data processing agreement, a subprocessor list or the contracting entity's jurisdiction. Weakest is assembly and resolutions, scored 0 — no public information appears on convening owners' meetings, recording votes or maintaining a resolution register. Owner self-service spans 0-2, the widest spread in the scores. No price figure appears on the pages we read; cost comes only through a consultation form asking for managed units and required workstations.

Report an error

Speaks for it

  • Named modules for double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and WEG and utility settlement; WEG accounting scores 3-4.
  • Aimed at mid-sized and large administrations of WEG and rental properties, with 30 years of development.
  • German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud variant; sovereignty scores 3-4.
  • An on-premise installation is offered that, in the vendor's words, keeps all data and systems in your hands.
  • Integrated document management and digital facility management are named modules, scoring 3 and 2-3.

Report an error

Held against it

  • Assembly and resolutions scored 0 — we found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes or maintaining a resolution register.
  • Owner self-service scored 0-2 — we found no public information on a portal, personal logins, statements on demand or owner-side defect reporting.
  • WEG accounting stops at 3-4 because the pages give module names only, with no public information on the business plan, distribution keys or reserve-fund handling.
  • Maintenance and defects scored 2-3 — we found no public information on defect tickets, contractor assignment or statutory inspections with stored proof.
  • We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods or a handover package, nor on a data processing agreement, subprocessor list or the contracting entity's jurisdiction.

Report an error

Best for

  • You run a mid-sized or large administration of WEG and rental properties and want bookkeeping and the settlement cycle inside one ERP.
  • You want the choice between a cloud stated to run on German servers and an on-premise installation on your own infrastructure.
  • You are prepared to verify settlement depth, assembly functions and owner portal capabilities in a consultation rather than from public pages.

Report an error

Avoid if

  • You need owners'-meeting functions — convening, voting, the resolution register — documented publicly before a shortlist.
  • You need an owner or tenant self-service portal with personal logins evidenced in public material.
  • You need settlement depth — business plan, distribution keys, reserve-fund handling — publicly documented before signing.
  • You must show a successor administrator a structured handover export, or evidence statutory inspections, before committing.

Report an error

The scores

Panel median The median of the judges’ scores per criterion. Each label opens its reasoning below.
Scores per criterion, in stars out of 5
Criterion Panel median
Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage 2 of 5
Owner & tenant self-service 1 of 5
Maintenance, defects & contractors 1.5 of 5
Documents, retention & handover 1.5 of 5
European sovereignty 2 of 5

Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage

Show reasoning
How this is scored

The statutory financial cycle: business plan, annual settlement in the form the law and the BGH require, distribution keys, and the separate handling of reserve funds held in trust for the community.

0 — Not WEG accounting: general bookkeeping or a rental tool with no Wirtschaftsplan or Jahresabrechnung, or no accounting at all.

3 — Bookkeeping per property with templates or a basic generator for Wirtschaftsplan and Jahresabrechnung, distribution keys entered per document.

5 — Wirtschaftsplan and Jahresabrechnung generated from the bookings with configurable distribution keys (MEA, units, consumption), Hausgeld and reserves booked per community.

8 — Settlement in the post-2021 BGH form with the Abrechnungsspitze shown separately, Vermögensbericht produced, the Rücklage kept as a separate reserve with its own statement, heating-cost apportionment per HeizkostenV integrated, owner changes apportioned mid-year, and Hausgeld arrears tracked with dunning.

10 — The whole financial year is discharged inside the system: multi-community bookkeeping with strict per-WEG separation, trust accounting for reserves with its own reporting, settlement documents an accountant would sign, and the arithmetic auditable back to individual postings.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

Double-entry bookkeeping and WEG- & utility-cost settlement are named modules of a thirty-year ERP aimed squarely at WEG and rental administration, so this is real WEG software, not a rental tool. The captured pages stop at module names, however: I found no public information on Wirtschaftsplan generation, distribution keys, the separate reserve statement or the post-2021 settlement form, which is what I am judged on every March. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

The pages name double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and a WEG and utility-cost settlement module, so the Jahresabrechnung is evidently produced inside the product rather than alongside it. But we found no public information on a Wirtschaftsplan, distribution keys, a separate reserve statement or the post-2021 settlement form, and I will not certify arithmetic I have not seen traced back to a posting. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Accountant

The product names a double-entry bookkeeping module and a WEG and utility settlement module for WEG and rental portfolios, so it is genuinely in WEG accounting. The public pages stop at module names: we found no public information on the business plan, distribution keys, the form of the settlement with the Abrechnungsspitze broken out, heating-cost apportionment, or how owner reserves are held. Before I credited more than a generator, I would want to see the settlement arithmetic traceable back to the postings. 1 3

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

Karthago is aimed explicitly at WEG and rental administrations, and the published module list names Doppelte Buchhaltung, WEG- und Nebenkostenabrechnung and automated invoice import, so the statutory settlement cycle is clearly in the product's scope as more than templates. The pages stop at module names, though: we found no public information on Wirtschaftsplan generation, configurable distribution keys, reserve-fund handling in trust, or the post-2021 settlement form, so I cannot credit the settlement depth that decides my purchase. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer

This is plainly WEG software: double-entry bookkeeping and a WEG and utility settlement module are named, alongside functions for special-ownership administration. We found no public information on the Wirtschaftsplan, configurable distribution keys, reserve funds held in trust for the community, or Hausgeld arrears with dunning, so the statutory financial cycle is evidenced only at module level. 3 2 2

Report an error

The Skeptic

The module list names double-entry bookkeeping, automated invoice import and a combined WEG and utility settlement module, so a statutory settlement generator is at least claimed, and the product is positioned for WEG administrations. Beyond the names the pages give no detail: we found no public information on the Wirtschaftsplan, configurable distribution keys, the separately shown settlement balance, the reserve fund held for the community, or heating-cost apportionment. 3 2 2

Report an error

Eigentümerversammlung & Beschluss-Sammlung

n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r Show reasoning
How this is scored

Convening, running and recording the owners' meeting — including the resolution register the law requires the administrator to maintain, and the majority arithmetic that decides whether a resolution stands.

0 — No owners' meeting features at all; the product is not built for WEG administration.

3 — Invitation templates generated from owner data and minutes stored with the property.

5 — Invitations with an agenda sent to all owners, votes or attendance recorded per agenda item, and a Beschluss-Sammlung kept as a register in the system.

8 — Quorum and majority computed per resolution type including MEA-weighted and qualified majorities, proxies and voting restrictions handled, minutes generated from the recorded votes, and the register maintained continuously with amendment and invalidation notes as § 24 (7) WEG requires.

10 — The meeting is conducted in the system: hybrid or online meetings and written circulation procedures supported with their own legal rules, contested resolutions flagged within the challenge period, the register complete and exportable as evidence, and every entry traceable to the meeting that produced it.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator not rated — no public information

I found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes or maintaining a Beschluss-Sammlung on any of the captured pages. The resolution register is a duty I carry personally, so this silence decides the mark. 1 2 3 2 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member not rated — no public information

We found no public information on convening or recording owners' meetings, on recording votes per agenda item, or on maintaining the resolution register the law requires. For a community's legal memory this gap matters, but nothing on the captured pages lets me judge it. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Accountant not rated — no public information

We found no public information on convening or recording owners' meetings, on voting or majority arithmetic, or on a resolution register. The captured homepage, product and process pages cover master data, settlement and communication with owners and tenants, but nothing on the assembly side. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager not rated — no public information

We found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes per agenda item, majority arithmetic, or the resolution register the administrator must maintain — the captured pages I read cover deployment, modules and contact forms, and touch on the Versammlung in none of them. For a multi-thousand-unit portfolio that is a dimension I simply cannot assess. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer not rated — no public information

We found no public information on convening owners' meetings, recording votes and majorities, or maintaining the resolution register. The pages we read describe master data, bookkeeping, settlement, document management and communication with owners and tenants, without naming any meeting or resolution feature. 3 2

Report an error

The Skeptic not rated — no public information

We found no public information on convening or recording an owners' meeting, a resolution register of the kind the law requires, or any majority arithmetic. The module and process lists on the vendor's captured pages mention none of it. 1 3

Report an error

Owner & tenant self-service

n/r n/r n/r Show reasoning
How this is scored

How an owner exercises their right to see the records, and how much routine correspondence the portal removes: statements, documents, meeting papers, defect reporting.

0 — No portal or app for owners or tenants; the product is used by the administrator alone.

3 — A document area or app where owners or tenants can view documents shared with them.

5 — A portal or app with a personal login per owner and tenant showing their own documents and statements, plus a request or defect form that reaches the administrator.

8 — Owners and tenants scoped separately with correct visibility, meeting papers and voting available in the portal, defect reports with status visible to the reporter, and consumption or arrears shown per unit.

10 — The portal discharges the disclosure duty: every record an owner is entitled to see available on demand with an access log, tenant and owner views strictly separated, notifications for statutory deadlines, and enough self-service that routine correspondence largely disappears.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

The captured pages name communication with owners and tenants as one of the processes the software steers, so the owner-facing correspondence runs through the product. The pages show no portal, app or personal login and no defect form or statement access, which reads to me as administrator-driven mail rather than self-service. 2 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

The pages describe steering communication with owners and tenants from within the product, which at least keeps correspondence in one place. We found no public information on a portal or app with personal logins where an owner could see their own statement, documents or meeting papers without asking the administrator. 2 3

Report an error

The Accountant not rated — no public information

We found no public information on an owner or tenant portal, personal logins, document access, statements on demand or a defect form. The pages describe communication with owners and tenants as part of the administrator's own processes, which does not evidence a self-service channel. 1 2 3

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

The captured pages describe communication with owners and tenants as one of the processes steered in the solution, which tells me correspondence is in scope but says nothing about who serves it. We found no public information on an owner or tenant portal, personal logins, statements or meeting papers delivered there, or a defect form with visible status, so I cannot credit the correspondence reduction I buy portals for. 2 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer not rated — no public information

We found no public information on an owner or tenant portal, personal logins, statements or meeting papers on demand, or defect reporting with status visible to the reporter. The pages describe the administrator steering communication with owners and tenants; nothing establishes separated owner and tenant visibility or an access log. 2 3

Report an error

The Skeptic not rated — no public information

The pages describe communication with owners and tenants as a process the administrator steers from within the software. We found no public information on a portal or app with personal logins, document or statement access, meeting papers, or defect reporting from the owner's or tenant's side. 2 3

Report an error

Maintenance, defects & contractors

Show reasoning
How this is scored

The building side: defect intake and tracking, recurring maintenance obligations, contractor assignment, and the evidence trail when something goes wrong.

0 — No building-side features at all; defects and maintenance are outside the product's scope.

3 — Defects or tasks recorded per property with a status, and a contractor contact list.

5 — Defect tickets per unit or property with status and photos, contractors assigned with a work order, and recurring maintenance tasks with reminders.

8 — Warranty and Gewährleistung periods tracked against the responsible trade, statutory inspections (lift, heating, fire safety, drinking water) scheduled with proof of completion stored, quotes and invoices linked to the defect, and cost allocated to the correct account.

10 — A defensible operating record: every obligation, inspection and defect with its evidence and dates, contractor performance visible, budget consumption against the Wirtschaftsplan tracked live, and a history that answers the question of what the administrator knew and when.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

Digitales Facility Management is a named module, so the building side sits inside the product rather than beside it. The captured pages give no detail on defect tickets with photos, recurring statutory inspections or warranty periods against the responsible trade, so I credit the basic level only. 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

Digital facility management is listed as an integrated module, so building-side work sits inside the product's scope. The captured pages show no detail on defect tickets, contractor assignment, statutory inspection dates or stored proof of completion, which is the level I would need before trusting an operating record. 3

Report an error

The Accountant

A digital facility management module is named in the module list, so the building side is within the product's scope. We found no public information on defect tickets with status, recurring maintenance with reminders, contractor assignment or statutory inspections with proof stored, so the documented level sits below a working defect tracker. 3

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

A Digitales Facility Management module appears in the published module list, which puts the building side inside the product's scope. We found no public information on statutory inspections — lift, heating, fire safety, drinking water — scheduled with proof of completion stored, on defects routed to the responsible trade, or on recurring maintenance reminders, and that evidence trail is exactly what my operation runs on. 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer

Digital facility management is named as an integrated module, which evidences building-side scope in the product. We found no public information on defect tickets with photos and status, contractor work orders, recurring maintenance reminders, or statutory inspection schedules with proof of completion. 3

Report an error

The Skeptic

A "Digitales Facility Management" module is named in the module list, so building-side scope exists in the vendor's own words. We found no public information on defect tickets, contractor assignment, recurring maintenance obligations, or stored proof of statutory inspections — a module name without detail leaves all of that unverified. 1 3

Report an error

Documents, retention & handover

Show reasoning
How this is scored

The archive and the exit. A Verwalter's appointment is finite by law, and the records belong to the community — so handover is a statutory event, not a support ticket.

0 — No document storage in the product; records are kept elsewhere.

3 — Central document storage per property with folders and upload.

5 — Document management per property and unit with search, documents linked to owners or units, and an export of a community's data or documents.

8 — Full-text search across the archive, version history, retention periods stated, documents linked to the resolutions and settlements that reference them, and a complete handover package (ledger, register, documents, master data) in open formats.

10 — Handover is a first-class feature rather than an obstacle: a complete, structured export a successor administrator can actually load, retention executed per statutory period, an access log over the archive, and no commercial friction placed in the way of a community leaving.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

Integriertes Dokumentenmanagement is a named module, so records live in the system. The captured pages give no information on full-text search, version history, retention periods or a handover package a successor administrator could load, and handover is a statutory event I plan for from the first day of an appointment. 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

An integrated document management module is named, which is central storage at entry level. We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods or a structured handover package a successor administrator could load — and handover is the moment that matters most to an owners' community. 2 3

Report an error

The Accountant

An integrated document management module is named alongside automated invoice import, which corresponds to central document storage. We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods, or a structured handover package a successor administrator could load. 3

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

An integriertes Dokumentenmanagement module is named in the published module list, which covers central storage in a property context. We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods, or a structured handover package a successor administrator could load — for me the exit is a statutory event, and the captured pages give me nothing on it. 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer

Integrated document management is named as a module, and the on-premise variant states that all data and systems stay in the administrator's hands. We found no public information on full-text search, version history, retention periods that execute, an access log over the archive, or a structured handover package for a community at the end of an appointment. 3 1

Report an error

The Skeptic

Integrated document management is named among the modules, which evidences central storage at most. We found no public information on search, version history, retention periods, or a structured handover export of a community's records — and the exit is where this criterion is decided. 1 3

Report an error

European sovereignty panel opinion

Show reasoning
How this is scored

Where the community's financial and personal records live, who the contracting entity is, and which subprocessors touch them. Independently sourced by the sovereignty pipeline; scored here as this buyer weighs it. Dimensions the sources do not establish are unknown, not non-EU.

0 — Proven non-EU: a non-EU vendor and contracting entity with hosting stated outside the EU.

3 — One European element proven — an EU contracting entity or EU hosting stated — with the rest of the chain undocumented.

5 — An EU contracting entity and EU hosting both stated, and a data processing agreement offered.

8 — German or EU hosting on named infrastructure, EU contracting entity, a subprocessor list published with locations, and any non-EU processing named with its legal basis.

10 — Sovereign end to end and evidenced: vendor, entity, hosting and every subprocessor European, certification published, and an export that keeps the community compliant for the full retention period after the appointment ends.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud, and an on-premise variant puts all data and systems in the customer's own hands. The group behind the product runs a German compliance apparatus including a whistleblowing system on a German data centre, but the contracting entity for Karthago is not established on the captured pages, and I found no public information on a data processing agreement or a subprocessor list. 1 2 4 3

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

Cloud hosting on German servers is stated, and a genuine on-premise installation is offered where the administration keeps all data and systems in its own hand — as a community I value that option. But we found no public information on the contracting entity's jurisdiction, a data processing agreement or a subprocessor list, so the chain is proven only up to the hosting. 1 2 4 3

Report an error

The Accountant

German hosting for the cloud variant is stated as "zertifiziertem Datenschutz auf deutschen Servern", an on-premise option keeps systems in the administrator's own hands, and the whistleblowing channel runs in a data centre in Germany under the Aareon Group. The contracting entity's jurisdiction, a data processing agreement and any subprocessor list are not established on the captured pages, so only the European element of hosting is proven. 1 2 4

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud variant across several captures, and the on-premise variant leaves all data and systems in the customer's hands — a combination I weigh heavily; the group's compliance page also names a whistleblowing provider with a data center in Deutschland. The contracting entity's jurisdiction is not confirmed on the vendor's own captured pages, and we found no public information on a data-processing agreement or the subprocessor chain, so the chain is proven only in part. 1 2 4 3

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer

German servers with certified data protection are stated for the cloud variant, a fully local installation is offered, and the group's whistleblowing system runs in a German data centre. We found no public information confirming the contracting entity's jurisdiction on the vendor's own pages, on a data processing agreement, on a published subprocessor list, or on where the automated invoice import sends the documents it reads. 1 2 4 3

Report an error

The Skeptic

The cloud is marketed with "zertifiziertem Datenschutz auf deutschen Servern" and an on-premise installation where "behalten Sie alle Daten und Systeme in Ihrer Hand", so German hosting is stated and self-hosting exists. The rest of the chain is dark: the contracting entity's jurisdiction is not confirmed on the captured pages even though the copyright and the compliance page name Aareon, and we found no public information on a data processing agreement or a subprocessor list for the product itself. 1 2 4 3

Report an error

Pricing transparency not rated — the vendor publishes no price

Show reasoning
How this is scored

Whether an administrator can compute the real annual cost for the units under management — including modules, per-community fees and setup — from public pages alone.

0 — No public prices at all; every quote is a sales conversation.

3 — A public "from" price or a single tier with a per-unit or per-community figure.

5 — Per-unit, per-community or per-tier prices public with the billing period stated and the main inclusions listed.

8 — Every tier and module priced publicly with per-unit maths, minimum term, setup and migration costs and VAT treatment stated; only genuinely custom enterprise work lacks a number.

10 — Complete price computability: annual invoice derivable for a given number of units and communities including every module, with no per-seat surprises and any exit or export fee stated outright.

Report an error

The WEG Administrator

The captured pages show no price figures; the only route to a number shown is a consultation form that asks for managed units and required workstations before anyone talks price. That is a sales conversation, and I cannot compute the annual cost for my forty communities from public pages alone. 3 2

Report an error

The Advisory Board Member

No figure of any kind appears on the captured pages. The only documented path to a price is a consultation form asking for managed units and required workstations, so an administrator cannot compute a real annual cost from public pages alone. 2 3 2

Report an error

The Accountant

The captured pages show no prices of any kind; the route to a number is a personal consultation form that asks for managed units and required workstations. An administrator cannot compute the annual cost for the units under management from what is public. 2 3 2

Report an error

The Portfolio Manager

Everything routes through a personal consultation form that collects verwaltete Einheiten and benötigte Arbeitsplätze — the price drivers are visible, but I found no public price figures, tiers, billing periods, setup or migration costs in the captured pages. For my unit count I cannot compute an annual cost from these pages alone; every quote is a sales conversation. 2 3 2

Report an error

The Data Protection Officer

No price figure appears on any page we read; the route to cost is a personal consultation whose form requires the number of managed units and required workstations before contact. An administrator cannot compute an annual cost for their portfolio from the published pages. 2 3 2

Report an error

The Skeptic

We found no public information on prices — no figure, tier, per-unit rate or billing period appears on any captured page. The only route to cost shown is a consultation form that asks for managed units and required workstations, so an administrator cannot compute an annual cost from these pages. 2 3 2

Report an error

European sovereignty — proven facts

2 of 6 dimensions proven

Built only from facts shown on the vendor's own pages. A dimension we could not prove is left open, not scored as zero.

Hosting location EU only unverified
Why unverified?

Marketing wording for the Cloud variant only, without words like "only" or "exclusively"; the actual privacy policy page content is not in the excerpts to confirm server location.

4/4 pts 1 Report an error
Hosting options Self-hostable 1/1 pts 1 Report an error
Open source Not determined — uncited Report an error
Data processing agreement Not determined — uncited Report an error
Transfer impact assessment Not determined — uncited Report an error

Questions about Karthago

Is Karthago European?

Yes. whats-best.ai classifies Karthago as EU-Made.

Where does Karthago store data?

Karthago stores customer data in the EU, per the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026.

Does Karthago have a free plan?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026.

What are the best alternatives to Karthago?

As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Condomana (3.5/5), Immoware24 (3/5) and etg24 (2.5/5) highest among the other 27 Property & WEG Management products evaluated. The highest-rated European alternative is Condomana (EU-Made, Germany). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made. The full list, with European products first: Karthago alternatives.

Where this could be wrong

What we left out

A claim that does not survive our checks costs us the claim, not the page. This is what was taken off this one.

Sources (4)

The pages every claim on this page was read from — each one checked, dated, and kept verifiable.

  1. 1 Vendor homepage www.karthago.de Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  2. 2 Imprint www.karthago.de Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 15 Sep 2026 Details →
  3. 3 Privacy policy www.karthago.de Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 15 Sep 2026 Details →
  4. 4 Security / trust page www.aareon.de Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →