Panel rating · 6 judges · How to read the stars

Category median

Sovereignty: 5 of 6 dimensions proven

0–5 in half steps. 5 means the rubric's top anchor is met on the evidence.

by CharlieHR Ltd · www.charliehr.com

Report an error on this page Is this your product? →

Link to this page

CharlieHR: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai CharlieHR: AI-assisted analysis on whats-best.ai (dark)

Add ?theme=dark to the image address for dark backgrounds. The badge shows the category and the month of the latest evaluation, and EU-Made where that is the product’s provenance. It never shows a score.

CharlieHR at a glance

Vendor
CharlieHR Ltd
Headquarters
Incorporated in the United Kingdom source, captured 16 Nov 2026
Data hosting
In the EU; pages mention Ireland source, captured 16 Nov 2026
Free plan
Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026
Panel verdict
The AI panel rates CharlieHR 2.5/5, the mean of 6 judges. CharlieHR is a UK small-business HR platform whose strongest scores came on core HR records, 4 to 6, and employee data governance, 4 to 5: judges credited an employee database where any document saves straight to a profile, an org chart, bulk import, salary visible only to Super Admins and Payroll Admins, and a self-serve data processing addendum with a named Data Protection Officer and data stated to sit on AWS servers in Ireland. how scores are made
As of
Vendor pages captured 29 Sep 2026 to 16 Nov 2026; evaluated by the panel 17 Nov 2026. all sources

CharlieHR alternatives, European ones first →

Read this page as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.

The Skeptic

Weighted verdict

Has watched three HR suites promise one system and deliver five modules with a shared logo. Reads every claim for what it does not say: which module the feature lives in, what it costs on top, and whether "integration" means a maintained connector or a documented endpoint someone could build against.

Same scores as the panel view — this lens weights them the way this judge cares.

Scored by The Skeptic

Panel median The Skeptic This judge’s scores over the panel median. Each label opens its reasoning below.
Scores per criterion, in stars out of 5
Criterion Panel median The Skeptic
Digital personnel file & data model 2.5 of 5 2.5 of 5
Payroll handoff 2 of 5 2 of 5
Absence & working-time 2 of 5 2 of 5
Recruiting & onboarding 2.5 of 5 2.5 of 5
Employee data protection & co-determination 2.5 of 5 2 of 5
European sovereignty 2.5 of 5 2.5 of 5
Pricing transparency 2 of 5 2 of 5

Digital personnel file & data model

How this is scored

The system of record: employee master data, the digital personnel file, org structure, custom fields, and whether history is kept rather than overwritten.

0 — Not a system of record for employees; the product holds no employee master data or personnel file.

3 — Employee records with master data and documents uploaded to a personnel file; org structure, custom fields and change history are basic or not described.

5 — A digital personnel file with employee master data and document storage, an org chart or department structure, custom fields, and access to the record controlled by role.

8 — Complete record: versioned contract and compensation history with effective dates, document templates with e-signature, org structure supporting multiple entities and cost centres, and granular field-level permissions.

10 — The file is the single source of truth an auditor could work from: full effective-dated history on every field, retention rules per document type, delegated administration per entity, and export that reproduces the record intact.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The file is real: documents saved straight to a profile, contracts, DBS certificates, even tax codes, plus an org chart, bulk import and role-based access described in working detail with salary fenced off from most roles. Custom fields, versioned or effective-dated history and retention rules per document type go undescribed in the captured material, and the permissions are explicitly fixed rather than configurable — "single source of truth" is a marketing line, not an audit trail. 5 13 12

Report an error

Payroll handoff

How this is scored

Whether the month closes cleanly into payroll — DATEV, Lohn und Gehalt, an in-house system or an external tax adviser — and how much of that is automated rather than re-typed.

0 — Payroll is outside the product: it holds none of the pay-relevant data and offers no path toward payroll.

3 — A payroll-relevant export (CSV, Excel or PDF) of master data, absences or hours for the payroll office; named formats and mid-month changes are basic or not described.

5 — A named payroll integration or a documented export for at least one major system (e.g. DATEV LODAS/Lohn und Gehalt), or the vendor's own payroll module, covering master data, absences and the recurring monthly changes.

8 — Certified or vendor-maintained integration with a named payroll provider, covering variable pay, absences and mid-month joiners and leavers, with a documented pre-payroll check.

10 — Payroll is a first-class part of the product: maintained bidirectional integrations with several named systems, an auditable approval and lock step before transmission, retro-accounting for backdated changes, and the tax adviser given their own access.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The change-tracking is genuinely built for month-end: one report lists starters, re-joiners, leavers, bank detail and National Insurance changes and uploaded P45s for the current and previous month, and a weekly digest emails the same to admins. But no named payroll system integration is documented — Xero appears only in a note about what the report excludes, alongside sick days — and the managed pay run is announced as coming soon, so today's handoff is a report and a CSV, not a connector. 8 7 1 9

Report an error

Absence & working-time

How this is scored

Vacation, sickness and working-time recording — including whether the product meets the German recording duty (BAG 2022, ArbZG) rather than merely offering a timer.

0 — Absence and working time are outside the product's scope.

3 — Vacation requests with an approval step and an absence overview; entitlement rules and working-time recording are basic or not described.

5 — Vacation and sickness recorded with automatic entitlement balances, a team absence calendar with public holidays, and working-time recording with a report per employee.

8 — Configurable per country and contract: pro-rata entitlement and carry-over, public-holiday calendars per location, break and rest-period rules, overtime accounts, and an export the employer can hand to a labour inspection.

10 — Working-time recording built as a legal obligation rather than a feature: tamper-evident records, documented compliance with the ArbZG recording duty, works-council-configurable monitoring limits, and shift or on-call models handled without add-ons.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Absence is the product's spine: self-serve requests with configurable auto-approval or sign-off, sick days recorded and extended by employees themselves, a team calendar showing who is off and why, and alerts on overlaps and holiday allowances. We found no public information on working-time recording — the German statutory duty — nor on entitlement pro-rating or public-holiday calendars. 9 10 9

Report an error

Recruiting & onboarding

How this is scored

The join path — vacancy to signed contract to a person who has an account, equipment and a plan on day one.

0 — Neither applicant tracking nor onboarding is part of the product.

3 — Job postings with an applicant list and statuses, or an onboarding checklist for new hires; the handover between the two is basic or not described.

5 — Applicant tracking with a careers page, pipeline stages and candidate communication, plus onboarding checklists or tasks for new hires, with the hired candidate carried into an employee record.

8 — Multi-posting to named job boards, interview scheduling and scorecards, GDPR-conscious applicant retention and deletion, e-signed contracts, and onboarding that triggers tasks in IT and payroll.

10 — The whole join is one governed flow: approval-gated requisitions with budget, structured and bias-conscious evaluation, automated applicant deletion at the stated deadline, and provisioning driven from the record so day one needs no HR intervention.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The join path exists: a built-in applicant tracking system (Charlie Recruit, run with a named provider), pre-boarding, self-serve document submission, checklists with reminders and a custom handbook — with the caveat that the tracking system is an add-on outside the base bundle. Multi-posting, interview scheduling, scorecards and applicant retention deadlines are not described, and the captured pages give different indications on e-signatures, one comparison marking them absent while product pages say signing is built in. 3 11 12 12

Report an error

Employee data protection & co-determination

How this is scored

How the product handles the most sensitive personal data a company holds — retention, deletion, role separation, subject rights — and whether it can pass a works council (BetrVG §87) rather than merely a procurement checklist.

0 — The vendor states that it offers no data processing agreement and no separation of access, leaving employee data protection entirely to the customer.

3 — A data processing agreement (AVV) available and roles that separate HR administrators from managers and employees; retention, deletion and co-determination settings are basic or not described.

5 — A data processing agreement available, roles and permissions configurable per module or team, deletion of employee and applicant data supported, and GDPR or works-council guidance describing how the product supports compliance.

8 — Field-level access control with an audit log of who read what, configurable retention per data category with automatic deletion, documented subject-rights support, and monitoring or analytics features that can be switched off for co-determination.

10 — Built for the works council to say yes: published processing documentation and subprocessor list, per-entity data separation, tamper-evident audit trail, evaluation and behavioural-analysis features off by default with their scope documented, and a data-protection impact assessment the customer can build on.

Report an error

The Skeptic

The basics are documented and better than a checklist: a designated data protection officer, a self-serve data processing addendum, encryption, deletion and full export on request, retention the customer defines, and no marketing to employees. But permissions are explicitly not customisable, no audit log of who read what is described, and retention control means a super admin removing data by hand rather than automatic per-category deletion — a works council would need answers the pages do not carry. 3 4 13 14

Report an error

European sovereignty

How this is scored

Where the data lives, who the contracting entity is, who the subprocessors are, and whether the answer is documented rather than assumed. Independently sourced by the sovereignty pipeline; scored here as the buyer would weigh it. Dimensions not proven either way are unknown, not non-European.

0 — Vendor, contracting entity and hosting shown to be outside the EU, and no data processing agreement offered.

3 — A privacy policy and a data processing agreement exist and one European element is proven (an EU contracting entity or representative, or EU hosting as an option); the rest of the chain is not stated.

5 — An EU contracting entity and EU hosting stated, with a data processing agreement; the subprocessor list is not published in full or includes non-EU providers without a stated safeguard.

8 — EU or DACH hosting with a named data-centre provider, an EU contracting entity, the full subprocessor list published with locations, and any non-EU processing named with its legal basis.

10 — Sovereign end to end and evidenced: vendor, contracting entity, hosting and every subprocessor in the EU, certification of the data centres published, and an on-premises or private-cloud option for buyers who need it.

Report an error

The Skeptic

Hosting is concrete — AWS servers in Ireland, named, EEA-stated — with a self-serve data processing addendum and several subprocessors actually named. The chain weakens at the ends: the contracting entity is English, under English law and UK data protection legislation, the subprocessor names carry no locations, and the privacy policy permits providers outside the EEA and transfers merely described as "outside the UK". 2 3 4 14

Report an error

Pricing transparency

How this is scored

Whether an HR lead can compute the real annual invoice for their headcount — including the modules they actually need — from public pages alone.

0 — No public prices at all; every tier is a sales conversation.

3 — A public "from" price per employee or one priced tier; how cost scales with modules, minimum headcount or setup is unclear.

5 — Per-employee prices public for the main tiers with the billing period stated and the main inclusions given; some modules (payroll, time, recruiting) or setup may be unpriced.

8 — Every tier and module priced publicly with per-employee maths, billing period, minimum term and VAT treatment stated; only genuinely custom enterprise work lacks a number.

10 — Complete price computability: a calculator or table that produces the annual invoice for a given headcount and module selection, including setup, minimums and renewal terms.

Report an error

The Skeptic

A public "From £21/month" with bracket pricing by team size, stated as VAT-inclusive and monthly, with inclusions named and a seven-day no-card trial — but the brackets themselves are unpublished, so an HR lead with sixty people cannot compute the invoice, and no public price is given for the applicant tracking add-on, the HR advisory service or setup ("by agreement"). The captured pages also give different figures for the headline monthly price. 2 6 11 6

Report an error

European sovereignty — proven facts

5 of 6 dimensions proven

Built only from facts shown on the vendor's own pages. A dimension we could not prove is left open, not scored as zero.

Hosting location EU only unverified
Why unverified?

The privacy policy also allows Personal Data to be 'processed by our service providers based in countries outside of the EEA' and moved to a destination merely described as 'outside the UK', so processing outside the EEA is not excluded.

4/4 pts 14 Report an error
Hosting options Cloud service only unverified
Why unverified?

The EULA permits use only through CharlieHR's server but nowhere states explicitly that no self-hosted or on-premises option exists.

0/1 pts 2 Report an error
Open source Proprietary unverified
Why unverified?

The word 'proprietary' appears in a definition of Charlie Technology rather than in a statement of the product's source-code licence.

0/1 pts 2 Report an error
Data processing agreement Published, self-serve unverified
Why unverified?

The excerpt shows only a link labelled 'here' to the addendum, not the addendum text itself.

1/1 pts 14 Report an error
Transfer impact assessment Not determined — uncited Report an error

Questions about CharlieHR

Is CharlieHR European?

Not determined: the vendor’s pages as captured do not say where CharlieHR is based. Its vendor, CharlieHR Ltd, is incorporated in the United Kingdom, per the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026.

Where does CharlieHR store data?

CharlieHR stores customer data in the EU, per the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026. The vendor’s pages mention Ireland as hosting location, per the vendor’s page captured 16 Nov 2026.

Does CharlieHR have a free plan?

Not stated on the vendor’s pages as of 16 Nov 2026.

What are the best alternatives to CharlieHR?

As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates rexx systems (3.5/5), HRworks (3.5/5) and Kenjo (3.5/5) highest among the other 37 HR Management products evaluated. Ratings that look equal are rounded to half stars; the order uses the unrounded rating, then the name. The highest-rated European alternative is rexx systems (EU-Made, Germany). Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made. The full list, with European products first: CharlieHR alternatives.

Where this could be wrong

What we left out

A claim that does not survive our checks costs us the claim, not the page. This is what was taken off this one.

Sources (14)

The pages every claim on this page was read from — each one checked, dated, and kept verifiable.

  1. 1 Vendor page www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +2 earlier captures: 2 Nov 2026, 29 Sep 2026 Details →
  2. 2 Terms of service — found from the homepage www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  3. 3 Privacy policy — found from the homepage www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  4. 4 Security / trust page — found from the homepage www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  5. 5 Digital personnel file & data model — found from sitemap www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  6. 6 Digital personnel file & data model — found from sitemap www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 1 Oct 2026 Details →
  7. 7 Payroll handoff — found from sitemap help.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 26 Oct 2026 Details →
  8. 8 Payroll handoff — found from sitemap help.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  9. 9 Absence & working-time — found from sitemap www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 2 Nov 2026 Details →
  10. 10 Absence & working-time — found from sitemap help.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  11. 11 Recruiting & onboarding — found from sitemap www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +1 earlier capture: 1 Oct 2026 Details →
  12. 12 Recruiting & onboarding — found from sitemap www.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 +2 earlier captures: 9 Nov 2026, 2 Nov 2026 Details →
  13. 13 Employee data protection & co-determination — found from sitemap help.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →
  14. 14 Employee data protection & co-determination — found from sitemap help.charliehr.com Checked 16 Nov 2026 Details →