As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Moz Pro 3/5 and Searchmetrics 1.5/5 in SEO. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Moz Pro and 0 pick Searchmetrics. Moz Pro scores higher on 5 of 5 criteria (Rank tracking & index quality, Data portability & exit, Keyword research & content guidance, plus 2 more). Provenance — Moz Pro: Rest of world; Searchmetrics: EU-Made. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Moz Pro leads each criterion — technical audit 6.0 vs 2.2, keyword and content 7.0 vs 2.8, rank and index data 6.8 vs 2.3, reporting and API 6.2 vs 4.2, data portability 5.3 vs 0.2, sovereignty 1.0 vs 0.0, pricing transparency 6.3 vs 0.5 — six judges lean Moz Pro, zero lean Searchmetrics, on each row. Splits sit inside scores: Searchmetrics' keyword and content runs 2 to 4, higher scores crediting documented AI content creation, lower ones citing no public information on volumes, difficulty or SERP features, while Moz Pro's keyword and content spans 6 to 8 and reporting and API 5 to 7. Moz Pro publishes Standard $99, Medium $179 and Large $299 USD per month with 20% yearly saving; Searchmetrics' pricing is linked but no figures are public, not weighted in its verdicts. Sovereignty attributes — legal entity jurisdiction, data residency, hosting options, open source, DPA, TIA — read unknown for both.
Choose Moz Pro if
You need published prices before committing: Moz Pro lists Standard $99, Medium $179 and Large $299 USD per month with 20% yearly saving, and pricing transparency scores 6.3 vs 0.5 with six judges leaning Moz Pro.
You need documented technical audit depth: technical audit scores 6.0 vs 2.2, and Searchmetrics' 2 to 3 rests on monitoring and visibility tracking rather than documented audit depth.
You need weekly rank tracking across up to four search engines, capped at the top 20 positions: rank and index data scores 6.8 vs 2.3.
You need keyword gap analysis against up to three competitors with traffic lift estimates: keyword and content scores 7.0 vs 2.8.
You need public information on data export and retention: data portability scores 5.3 vs 0.2, and the Searchmetrics verdict reports no public information on export and retention after cancellation.
Choose Searchmetrics if
You need visibility tracking across ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Claude alongside traditional search — the Searchmetrics verdict documents this capability.
Your team relies on Google Search Console and Google Analytics and needs those named integrations plus published API documentation with a developer playground — reporting and API is Searchmetrics' strongest criterion at 4 to 5.
You need documented AI content creation — the higher keyword and content scores for Searchmetrics credit it.
You need 24/7 monitoring of AI bot crawling — the Searchmetrics verdict documents it, and its technical audit and rank and index scores of 2 to 3 rest on monitoring and visibility tracking.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Data Analyst
Wants the numbers in the warehouse, not in a PDF. Cares about a documented API with published credit costs, bulk historical export, and whether three years of ranking history leaves with the customer or dies with the subscription.
Moz Pro
This judge's pick
Searchmetrics
Criterion by criterion
Crawling & technical audit
Moz Pro
Weekly crawls run at published per-plan page caps, with issues sorted into crawler, redirect, metadata and content categories, critical 5xx/4xx problems flagged first, expert fix guidance attached, and new issues emailed after each crawl. Total pages and issues are trended over time and a Lighthouse-based Core Web Vitals module publishes exact severity bands for mobile and desktop while stating plainly that its lab data may differ from Chrome field data. I found no public information on JavaScript rendering checks, log-file or Search Console comparison, indexation or canonical diagnosis, or structured-data validation.
Searchmetrics
The captured pages claim real-time site health with 24/7 monitoring of how AI bots crawl the site, real-time alerts and prioritised fixes. Beyond that marketing claim we found no public information on crawl depth, page limits, issue categories, Core Web Vitals, rendering or indexation diagnosis, so the depth of the audit cannot be assessed.
Keyword research & content guidance
Moz Pro
Keyword Explorer publishes volume, difficulty, organic CTR and priority with suggestions grouped by search intent, the keyword gap tool sizes opportunities with a Traffic Lift estimate against up to three competitors, and sixteen SERP feature types are tracked weekly with your-site-versus-competitor attribution. The AI Content Brief closes part of the loop by listing what already ranks, checking your existing content to avoid cannibalisation, and remaining fully editable. A market dropdown exists, but I found no public information on the depth of the German-language data specifically.
Searchmetrics
AI content generation and optimisation for search and LLMs is marketed, and the unified data engine is said to hold ten-plus years of intent and content signals. We found no public information on keyword suggestions with volume, difficulty, SERP feature data, clustering, or any German-language keyword data specifically.
Rank tracking & index quality
Moz Pro
Rankings update weekly across up to four search engines, nationally or locally, with mobile-versus-desktop comparison, but collection stops at the top 20 positions and anything beyond shows as 21+. The link index is large and its size plus a 3-day data refresh rate are published — the captured pages give different figures for the link count, 45.5 trillion on one and 44.8 trillion on another, across 1 billion domains — and the entire ranking history back to campaign setup is retained for the life of the account and exportable. Daily or city-level collection and new-versus-lost link reporting are not documented, which is what holds this below the top band.
Searchmetrics
Visibility tracking across traditional search plus ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Claude is documented, backed by a claim of ten-plus years of proprietary search signals. We found no public information on update frequency, country or city coverage, device splits, or any backlink index size and freshness, so the proprietary data cannot be held to account.
Reporting, integrations & API
Moz Pro
This is where I look first, and it mostly delivers: the API is documented with versioned V2 and V3 docs, JSON-RPC 2.0 with a single token, and self-serve tiers from a $250 USD / mo Entry Level with 120,000 rows per month to a $10,000 USD / mo Enterprise tier with 40,000,000 rows, overages priced at $20 down to $3.50 per additional 10,000 rows, plus per-plan query limits and custom reports with Google Analytics overlay. I found no public information on white-label client reporting, a BigQuery or data-warehouse export, or a Search Console connection, so beyond CSV and PDF the programmatic route to a warehouse is the row-metered API.
Searchmetrics
Google Search Console and Google Analytics are among eight named integrations, and an AEO developer playground with API documentation is offered. We found no public information on scheduled or white-label reporting, warehouse export, or published API rate limits and credit costs, which is the part I need before a team can build on it.
Data portability & exit
Moz Pro
The entire keyword ranking history back to campaign setup exports to CSV with any timeframe selectable from campaign history, and SERP feature data exports weekly for all tracked keywords — real accumulated history leaving the account, not just the current report. The documented edges matter: ranks outside the top 20 come out blank, featured snippet presence is not marked in the CSV, competition data exports one engine at a time, and the FAQ asking whether past crawl data can be exported shows no answer on the captured page. Retention is stated as the life of the account plus a reasonable and legally compliant period thereafter, but no retrievable grace period after cancellation is quantified.
Searchmetrics
We found no public information on export of ranking or crawl history, retention after cancellation, or any exit grace period. The captured homepage, imprint and privacy pages carry no export or retention terms I could assess.
European sovereignty
Moz Pro
The chain that is documented is American: the legal entity is SEOMoz, Inc. at a Seattle address, legal notices go to Ziff Davis in New York, the Federal Trade Commission is named as enforcement authority for the privacy framework, and subprocessors are described as located anywhere in the world with transfers out of the EEA resting on standard contractual clauses. A data protection officer is registered with the Irish Data Protection Commission, but no EU contracting entity and no hosting location are stated. I found no public information on where account and crawl data are hosted.
Searchmetrics
Every sovereignty dimension comes back unknown, and we found no public information on the contracting entity's jurisdiction, data residency, hosting, a data processing agreement, or subprocessor locations; the captured imprint page carries no legal entity details and the site copyright is Conductor's. Security certifications (ISO 27001, ISO 42001, SOC 2 Type 2) are published, but they establish no European element.
Pricing transparency
Moz Pro
The three main tiers are priced at $99, $179 and $299 USD per month with yearly rates of $79, $143 and $239 and the 20% yearly saving stated, and the limit table is unusually complete: user seats, campaigns, tracked keywords, pages crawled per week, and keyword, backlink and rank-checker query volumes per tier, plus add-ons at $20 per AI Visibility Dashboard and $50 per 100 tracked prompts. The API is separately priced from a $250 USD / mo Entry Level with 120,000 rows per month to $10,000 USD / mo with 40,000,000 rows, with every overage rate from $20 to $3.50 per additional 10,000 rows published. What a buyer still cannot compute from these pages: VAT treatment, minimum term, the price of a seat beyond the included ones, plan-level overage handling beyond an "Overages not included" footnote, and the Enterprise tier is contact-sales only.
Searchmetrics
The captured pages state no prices, plans, limits or billing details of any kind; the only pricing signal is a navigation link labelled Pricing whose destination we could not read. We found no public price figure for any tier, so a real annual cost cannot be computed from what is published.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Moz Pro
Searchmetrics
Legal entity
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Moz Pro higher: 3/5 against 1.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Moz Pro and 0 pick Searchmetrics. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Moz Pro or Searchmetrics European?
Moz Pro is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Searchmetrics is European (EU-Made). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.