Performance reviews & calibration
How this is scored
The review cycle itself: configurable templates and rating scales, self, manager and 360° input, calibration across teams, and whether each rating can be traced back to criteria fixed before the cycle began.
0 — No structured reviews; at most a free-text form with no cycle, no scale and no record of who wrote what.
3 — Fixed review templates with self and manager input, but no configurable criteria, no calibration and no statement of what the employee sees.
5 — Configurable cycles, questions and rating scales, self, manager and peer input, employee sign-off or acknowledgement, and the review history kept per employee.
8 — 360° feedback with configurable reviewer selection, calibration views across teams with rating distributions, review criteria per role or level, reminders and deadlines per cycle, and a documented rule for what the employee, the manager and HR can each see.
10 — Reviews are an auditable process: criteria and competency models versioned and fixed before the cycle, every rating change during calibration attributed and reasoned, bias checks or distribution analysis described, and the full review history exportable per employee.
The Skeptic
The cycle machinery is real: self-reflection, peer and upward feedback and manager review in one cycle, nomination-based reviewer selection with manager approval, reminders at seven and one days before close, calibration views where HR adjusts ratings across a group before finalising, and unusually clear rules on who sees what — down to collaborator comments never reaching the employee. What falls short of the top is the audit story: we found no public information on review criteria versioned and fixed before a cycle (the help pages describe editing question text after a cycle has gone live), and no public information on attribution or reasoning for rating changes during calibration or on bias checks and distribution analysis. Competencies do link to roles, and calibration views, peer and upward feedback and self-reflections export to CSV, XLSX and PDF. 5 6 9 12 14