As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Deputy 3/5 and When I Work 3/5 in Employee Scheduling. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 1 of the 6 judges picks Deputy and 4 pick When I Work, 1 calls it a tie. Deputy scores higher on 3 of 7 criteria (Pricing transparency, Roster building & demand planning and European sovereignty). When I Work scores higher on 4 of 7 criteria (Working-time law & collective agreements, Mobile self-service for deskless staff, Payroll handoff & integrations, plus 1 more). Provenance — Deputy: Rest of world, Australia; When I Work: Rest of world. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Deputy and When I Work split the bench with no overall winner. The table puts Deputy ahead on roster planning (7.3 vs 6.8), pricing transparency (6.8 vs 6.2; 4 judges lean Deputy, 2 tie) and sovereignty (2.8 vs 2.5); Deputy publishes Lite $5, Core $6.50, Pro $9 per user per month, USD excl. all applicable taxes. When I Work is ahead on working time rules (5.3 vs 4.3; 4 judges lean its way), staff self service (7.0 vs 6.5), payroll and integrations (6.5 vs 6.2) and codetermination and privacy (5.0 vs 4.8); it publishes $2.50 per user per month for single-location teams and $5 per user per month for multi-location businesses. Weighted totals split by judge: When I Work leads for the shift manager, works council and skeptic; Deputy for the frontline employee; the payroll officer ties at 5.5; the table shows no totals for the operations director.
Choose Deputy if
You build rosters from forecasted sales, delivery orders and foot traffic, with hour and wage budgets tracked in real time; roster planning scores 7.3 for Deputy vs 6.8 for When I Work, with 2 judges leaning Deputy and 4 tying.
You need published prices before purchase: Deputy lists Lite $5, Core $6.50, Pro $9 per user per month, USD excl. all applicable taxes, and pricing transparency leans Deputy 4 judges to 0 with 2 ties.
You weight the frontline employee's perspective: that judge's weighted total is 5.9 for Deputy vs 5.6 for When I Work.
You want a data processing agreement you can take self-serve: Deputy's sovereignty attributes list the data processing agreement as self-serve.
You compare sovereignty as the bench scored it: 3 judges lean Deputy vs 1 for When I Work (means 2.8 vs 2.5), though both verdicts place the category at 2-3.
Choose When I Work if
You need configurable working-time guardrails: 4 judges lean When I Work on working time rules (5.3 vs 4.3); Deputy's documented guardrails are framed for US state break law and fair workweek.
Your staff handle swaps, drops and open shifts from iOS and Android apps: staff self service scores 7.0 vs 6.5, with 3 judges leaning When I Work and 3 tying.
You close a locked pay period and send hours to named North American processors: payroll and integrations scores 6.5 vs 6.2, with 2 judges leaning When I Work and 4 tying.
You rely on granular role permissions and timesheet edit history: codetermination and privacy leans When I Work 2 judges to 1 (5.0 vs 4.8), with 3 judges tying.
Your panel gives weight to the skeptic: that judge's weighted total is 5.7 for When I Work vs 5.2 for Deputy.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Frontline Employee
Works part-time shifts next to a second job or a degree and never opens a laptop at work. Judges the product by its phone app: can she mark availability, swap a shift without three calls, see her hours, and read it in her own language. A roster she learns about from a photo in a group chat has failed.
Deputy
This judge's pick
When I Work
Criterion by criterion
Roster building & demand planning
Deputy
The planner side is strong: forecasting pulls named demand sources — sales, delivery orders, foot traffic — into auto-built schedule templates, one-click auto-scheduling weighs availability, training and cost, and hour-and-wage budgets show real-time variance while building. That is demand-based planning with automatic proposals and labour cost against budget; we found no public information on cross-location staff sharing or on the proposal explaining which rule drove each assignment.
When I Work
Templates with qualifications, open shifts and labour sharing across sites are documented, and one-click auto-assign builds a roster that honours the scheduling rules — a planner gets real help, not just a grid. What keeps it below the top bands is demand: labor forecasting and scheduled-versus-budgeted hours are named, but no captured page names a data source like POS sales driving the forecast, and the forecasting method itself is not documented. For me the plan matters mostly once it lands on my phone, and that handoff is covered elsewhere in the pages.
Working-time law & collective agreements
Deputy
Minimum rest between shifts, maximum weekly hours and break timing are named guardrails, with missed breaks flagged and attested and early return to work prevented — enforcement during planning, not just an export. The break-law material is written for US states and the feature lists speak of fair workweek and US pay rates; we found no public information on ArbZG, Tarifvertrag surcharges, Minijob earnings limits, youth protection or per-person contract-hours tracking.
When I Work
The planner faces named checks before publishing — maximum days in a row or per week, minimum hours between shifts (configurable up to 18 hours), and weekly, daily and double overtime at 1.5x and 2x rates — and shifts that would break a rule are hidden from swaps and open shifts, so nobody can hand me a shift that violates the rest rules. But no law is named: no German working-time act, no collective-agreement surcharges, no youth-protection or earnings limits, and the terms state the service is designed for US workplaces. Configurable guardrails, not a modelled rulebook.
Mobile self-service for deskless staff
Deputy
The phone is the product: schedules reach my device with automatic reminders, I can mark unavailable days, request time off, swap directly with suitable teammates and get mobile alerts when a shift opens — plus clock-in with a location check, pay stubs in the app, and a news feed that keeps shift talk out of my private group chats. We found no public information on interface languages, offline clock-in, or rest-period checks before a swap is approved, so it sits below the very top.
When I Work
This is the part I live in: iOS and Android apps with my shifts, swap, drop and release flows with eligibility lists, open-shift claiming, time-off requests with types and balances, and a shared time-clock terminal app as well as my own phone. Swaps are filtered by the rule set before anyone accepts — I cannot take a shift that breaks the rest rules — and built-in messaging keeps shift talk out of my private chats. We found no public information on interface languages or offline handling, which matters when the basement has no signal.
Works council & employee data
Deputy
Custom access levels and a privacy centre publishing a data processing addendum and a sub-processor list give the basics, with a 30-day export window and deletion after termination written into the agreement. We found no public information on a per-person audit log, hiding absence reasons from colleagues, tracking off by default, configurable deletion periods, or materials a works council would need to approve introduction.
When I Work
Role permissions are genuinely granular — supervisors only see timesheets of people they supervise, and wage visibility for new supervisors is unchecked by default — and GPS collection is permission-based. There is an edit history on timesheets showing who changed what, but we found no public information on a data processing agreement, configurable deletion periods, or documentation aimed at a works council, and the service is designed for US workplaces. Enough to start a works-agreement conversation, not enough to finish it.
Payroll handoff & integrations
Deputy
Approved timesheets, pay rates and leave go to Paycor in one click after individual or bulk approval, POS sales data feeds the schedule, and there is a documented API alongside payroll, point-of-sale and HR integration categories. Only one payroll destination is named and it is US-only with a fee that "varies by business size"; we found no public information on DATEV, wage-type mapping per surcharge, or an HR master-data sync.
When I Work
Named payroll integrations — Gusto, Paychex, QuickBooks Online, Square Payroll, OnPay, plus ADP and Rippling — sit beside a closed pay period that locks changes until an admin reopens it, and a documented API with webhooks. These are US payroll systems, and we found no public information on a German payroll handoff, wage-type mapping for surcharges, or an HR master-data sync. My hours leave the app cleanly; whether they reach a European payroll is an open question.
European sovereignty
Deputy
The marks belong to an Australian company and every footer shows a San Francisco address; a self-serve data processing addendum and a published sub-processor list exist. We found no public information on where employee data is hosted or on any EU hosting claim — thin for a tool that would hold my availability and where I clocked in.
When I Work
The captured pages put the vendor in Minneapolis with primary data centers in the United States, give different legal-entity names — When I Work, Inc. and When I Work, LLC — and name standard contractual clauses for transfers out of restricting jurisdictions. A line that data may be stored and processed in your region is the only nod to non-US customers, with no named EU provider behind it. My availability and clock-in location would sit under this arrangement, and we found no public information confirming EU hosting, an EU contracting entity, or a published subprocessor list beyond the earned-wage partner.
Pricing transparency
Deputy
Every main tier is public per user per month with annual and monthly figures, a stated 10% annual discount, and taxes stated as excluded — and the Analytics+, Messaging+ and HR add-ons each carry a public dollar figure. The payroll add-on "varies by business size", Flexi and charity pricing are by enquiry, and we found no public information on how seasonal or inactive staff are counted or on minimum terms.
When I Work
The maths is public and simple: $2.50 per user per month for single-location teams, $5 per user per month for multi-location, monthly or annual billing, no setup fees, no long-term contracts, and every plan stated to include scheduling, time tracking and messaging — so for a small team the annual invoice is computable. Enterprise pricing is a sales conversation, and we found no public information on VAT treatment or how seasonal and inactive staff are counted toward the bill.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Deputy
When I Work
Legal entity
Incorporated in AU
Not determined
Hosting location
Not determined
Outside the EU
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 3/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 1 of the 6 judges picks Deputy and 4 pick When I Work, 1 calls it a tie. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Deputy or When I Work European?
Deputy is not European by provenance (Rest of world, Australia). When I Work is not European by provenance (Rest of world). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do Deputy and When I Work store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — Deputy: its pages as captured do not say. When I Work: Outside the EU by default.
Do Deputy and When I Work have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, Deputy’s own pages state a free plan; When I Work’s pages as captured do not. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.