As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates immocloud 1.5/5 and vermietet.de 0.5/5 in Property & WEG Management. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick immocloud and 0 pick vermietet.de. immocloud scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (European sovereignty, Owner & tenant self-service, Documents, retention & handover, plus 3 more). Provenance — immocloud: EU-Made, Germany; vermietet.de: EU-Made. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Both verdicts describe rental-landlord software judged against WEG duties. The leans in the table go to immocloud: 6 judges lean immocloud on documents and handover (4.5 vs 3.0), owner self-service (3.8 vs 0.0) and sovereignty (7.3 vs 0.5), and 4 lean immocloud with 2 ties on WEG accounting (0.8 vs 0.0) and pricing transparency (6.5 vs 5.7). The bench also ties: 6 judges tie on assembly and resolutions (0.0 vs 0.0), and on maintenance and defects (0.3 vs 0.0) 5 tie while 1 leans immocloud. No criterion shows a lean toward vermietet.de, whose strongest criterion is pricing transparency at 5.7: '9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit' plus '0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit', a 30-day trial ending automatically, cancellation at any time. immocloud's sovereignty attributes list legal entity jurisdiction DE, EU-only data residency and a self-serve DPA; vermietet.de's list unknown, its sovereignty verdict spread 0 to 3.
Choose immocloud if
You need documents auto-sorted by object and unit with unlimited storage — documents and handover leans immocloud 6 judges to 0 (4.5 vs 3.0).
You need a documented tenant portal rather than captured pages showing no public information on a tenant or owner login — owner self-service leans immocloud 6 to 0 (3.8 vs 0.0).
You require a German legal entity, EU-only data residency and a self-serve Article 28 agreement — immocloud's sovereignty attributes list exactly that, and sovereignty leans immocloud 6 to 0 (7.3 vs 0.5).
You want a 45-day trial without payment data before committing to a twelve-month term with published tier prices — pricing transparency leans immocloud 4 to 0 with 2 ties (6.5 vs 5.7).
Choose vermietet.de if
You pay per residential unit — '9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit' plus '0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit'; pricing transparency is vermietet.de's strongest criterion (mean 5.7, 2 judges tie).
You want to cancel at any time instead of committing to a twelve-month term.
You want a 30-day trial that ends automatically with no credit card or bank data.
You list rentals on ImmoScout24 and want free listings every three months alongside central per-property document storage with upload (documents and handover mean 3.0).
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Accountant
Prepares the settlement and answers for its form. Cares that the Abrechnungsspitze is shown separately, that the Rücklage is genuinely segregated trust money rather than a labelled balance, and that heating costs apportion per HeizkostenV without a spreadsheet.
immocloud
This judge's pick
vermietet.de
Criterion by criterion
Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage
immocloud
The accounting here is the landlord's side: a step-by-step tenant utility settlement under § 2 BetrKV with stored, combinable distribution keys, day-accurate proration and a DATEV export. We found no public information on a Wirtschaftsplan, a Jahresabrechnung for an owners' community with the Abrechnungsspitze shown separately, or a reserve fund kept separately per community — the vacancy cost simply stays with the landlord, which tells me which statute this tool answers to.
vermietet.de
The captured pages present a private-landlord product: automatic rent receipt checks, an income and cost overview with profitability figures, and a tenant-facing Nebenkostenabrechnung with an auto-fill assistant. I found no public information on a Wirtschaftsplan, a Jahresabrechnung in the form the law requires for a community of owners, a separately shown Abrechnungsspitze, or a reserve fund kept as trust money — this is rental bookkeeping, not community accounting.
Eigentümerversammlung & Beschluss-Sammlung
immocloud
The documented function list — utility settlement, finances, rent management, correspondence, documents, meters — addresses landlords, tenants and administrators, and shows no feature for convening or minuting an owners' meeting. We found no public information on invitations generated from owner data, per-item voting, quorum and majority arithmetic, or a Beschluss-Sammlung maintained with amendment and invalidation notes.
vermietet.de
The captured pages describe a landlord's tool — listings on ImmoScout24 with unlimited tenant inquiries, portfolio and market value analysis, and templates for all landlord concerns. I found no public information on convening or running an owners' meeting, recording votes, or maintaining a Beschluss-Sammlung.
Owner & tenant self-service
immocloud
Tenants get a real portal: they are invited in, exchange messages, and the settlement goes out by email through the tenant portal, by letter or registered mail; the manager gets an app for portfolio, rent bookings and messages. We found no public information on access for WEG owners, a defect or request form reaching the administrator, or per-unit consumption and arrears visible to the tenant, so this sits between a shared document area and a full self-service portal.
vermietet.de
The pages show the landlord's own workspace ('Meine Immos', finances in view, market value estimates), with tenant contact running through ImmoScout24 listing inquiries. I found no public information on a personal login for owners or tenants showing their own documents and statements, or a defect or request form reaching the manager.
Maintenance, defects & contractors
immocloud
We found no public information on defect intake and tracking, recurring maintenance obligations, statutory inspections or contractor work orders. The function list carries an undifferentiated Vorgangsmanagement entry that the pages do not describe, and the templates offered are rental handover and notice letters rather than maintenance records.
vermietet.de
The captured pages cover rent receipts, tenant utility statements, document storage and property valuations. I found no public information on defect intake with status tracking, recurring maintenance obligations, statutory inspections, or contractor assignment and work orders.
Documents, retention & handover
immocloud
Documents are auto-sorted by object and unit, findable in seconds, with drag-and-drop upload and unlimited storage in every plan, holding leases, handover protocols and invoices. The exit is thin but real: a customer download right before personal data is deleted three months after the contract ends, plus a DATEV export — we found no public information on version history, full-text search, stated retention periods or a structured package a successor could load.
vermietet.de
The pages show a 'Dokumentenablage' where all documents are stored securely, a document assistant with analysis and recommendations, templates, and document upload with automatic text recognition — central storage for the landlord's own archive. I found no public information on documents linked to units, full-text search, retention periods, or a structured handover export in open formats.
European sovereignty
immocloud
A German GmbH on the commercial register, an exclusive German host named in the AVV (dogado), an ISO 27001 data centre, a self-serve data processing agreement with a TOM annex, a four-week audit right and EU standard contractual clauses — the community's and landlord's records sit in Germany on named infrastructure. The subprocessor list is published but locations appear only for some entries, and the captured pages give different statements on foreign data transfer: the security pages say none occurs while the privacy policy discloses analytics and monitoring providers.
vermietet.de
I found no public information on the contracting entity behind the service, where the records are hosted, a data processing agreement, or any subprocessor list. The captured homepage and pricing page state nothing on these points, so every dimension remains unproven to me.
Pricing transparency
immocloud
Four unit-banded tiers are priced publicly with both term options and a 10% twelve-month term discount, net prices plus 19% VAT stated, a precise definition of what counts as a unit, and the main inclusions plus paid extras flagged — letter dispatch and digital rental contracts cost extra, SMS outgoing only. An administrator above 50 units cannot compute the annual cost from these pages: the Tycoon tier is "Auf Anfrage" and the extra costs carry no figures.
vermietet.de
The pricing page states '9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit' and '0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit', with a 30-day trial containing all functions that ends automatically, cancellation at any time, no credit card required, and free ImmoScout24 listings every three months — a single tier with per-unit prices and the billing period stated. I found no public information on VAT treatment or setup and migration costs, so the full annual invoice is not derivable from the public pages alone.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
immocloud
vermietet.de
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Not determined
Hosting location
EU only
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not needed, no transfer outside the EU/EEA
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates immocloud higher: 1.5/5 against 0.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick immocloud and 0 pick vermietet.de. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is immocloud or vermietet.de European?
immocloud is European (EU-Made, Germany). vermietet.de is European (EU-Made). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do immocloud and vermietet.de store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — immocloud: In the EU; pages mention Germany. vermietet.de: its pages as captured do not say.