As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates immocloud 1.5/5 and vermietet.de 0.5/5 in Property & WEG Management. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick immocloud and 0 pick vermietet.de. immocloud scores higher on 6 of 7 criteria (European sovereignty, Owner & tenant self-service, Documents, retention & handover, plus 3 more). Provenance — immocloud: EU-Made, Germany; vermietet.de: EU-Made. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
Both verdicts describe rental-landlord software judged against WEG duties. The leans in the table go to immocloud: 6 judges lean immocloud on documents and handover (4.5 vs 3.0), owner self-service (3.8 vs 0.0) and sovereignty (7.3 vs 0.5), and 4 lean immocloud with 2 ties on WEG accounting (0.8 vs 0.0) and pricing transparency (6.5 vs 5.7). The bench also ties: 6 judges tie on assembly and resolutions (0.0 vs 0.0), and on maintenance and defects (0.3 vs 0.0) 5 tie while 1 leans immocloud. No criterion shows a lean toward vermietet.de, whose strongest criterion is pricing transparency at 5.7: '9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit' plus '0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit', a 30-day trial ending automatically, cancellation at any time. immocloud's sovereignty attributes list legal entity jurisdiction DE, EU-only data residency and a self-serve DPA; vermietet.de's list unknown, its sovereignty verdict spread 0 to 3.
Choose immocloud if
You need documents auto-sorted by object and unit with unlimited storage — documents and handover leans immocloud 6 judges to 0 (4.5 vs 3.0).
You need a documented tenant portal rather than captured pages showing no public information on a tenant or owner login — owner self-service leans immocloud 6 to 0 (3.8 vs 0.0).
You require a German legal entity, EU-only data residency and a self-serve Article 28 agreement — immocloud's sovereignty attributes list exactly that, and sovereignty leans immocloud 6 to 0 (7.3 vs 0.5).
You want a 45-day trial without payment data before committing to a twelve-month term with published tier prices — pricing transparency leans immocloud 4 to 0 with 2 ties (6.5 vs 5.7).
Choose vermietet.de if
You pay per residential unit — '9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit' plus '0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit'; pricing transparency is vermietet.de's strongest criterion (mean 5.7, 2 judges tie).
You want to cancel at any time instead of committing to a twelve-month term.
You want a 30-day trial that ends automatically with no credit card or bank data.
You list rentals on ImmoScout24 and want free listings every three months alongside central per-property document storage with upload (documents and handover mean 3.0).
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Portfolio Manager
Runs a firm managing several thousand units and lives on throughput. Wants statutory inspections scheduled with proof stored, defects that route to the right trade, multi-community reporting, and onboarding a new WEG that takes days rather than a quarter.
immocloud
This judge's pick
vermietet.de
Criterion by criterion
Wirtschaftsplan, Jahresabrechnung & Rücklage
immocloud
Everything documented on the financial side is the landlord cycle: costs captured per object and unit year-round, distributed via configurable keys (living, usable or total area, consumption, persons, units) into a tenant utility statement under § 2 BetrKV, with a DATEV export for the accountant and German VAT only. We found no public information on Wirtschaftsplan, Hausgeld, an owners' annual settlement in the post-2021 form, or a reserve fund held separately for a community. Real bookkeeping machinery, but nothing I could run a WEG's statutory financial year on.
vermietet.de
The captured pages present a rental-landlord product — automatic rent-receipt checking, an income and cost overview, and a tenant-facing utility statement — and we found no public information on a Wirtschaftsplan, a WEG Jahresabrechnung, distribution keys or reserve-fund trust accounting. Everything documented is rental-side, which for my communities removes it from the statutory financial cycle entirely.
Eigentümerversammlung & Beschluss-Sammlung
immocloud
We found no public information on convening or running an owners' meeting, recording votes per agenda item, majority arithmetic, or a resolution register. The captured feature lists cover rental modules and communication channels, and the free template library is rental paperwork such as index and staggered rent increases, tenancy confirmation and tenant self-disclosure.
vermietet.de
The documented scope is a landlord marketing and managing rentals: free listings on ImmoScout24 every three months, unlimited tenant inquiries, portfolio market-value analysis. We found no public information on convening an owners' meeting, recording votes and majorities, or maintaining a Beschluss-Sammlung.
Owner & tenant self-service
immocloud
A tenant portal is documented — tenants are invited into an exclusive portal with two-way messaging, settlements are delivered by email through the portal or by letter, and leases can be viewed digitally. The mobile app is the administrator's tool (portfolio overview, booking rent payments, messages). We found no public information on an owner login, defect reports with visible status, or meeting papers in the portal.
vermietet.de
The pages describe a tool the landlord uses alone; tenants surface only as inquiries against ImmoScout24 listings. We found no public information on an owner or tenant portal with personal logins, their own documents and statements, or a defect form with status visibility for the reporter.
Maintenance, defects & contractors
immocloud
We found no public information on defect intake, work orders with photos, contractor assignment, recurring maintenance obligations, or statutory inspections (lift, heating, fire safety, drinking water) with proof of completion stored. A general process-management module appears in the feature lists, but nothing published describes its building-side scope.
vermietet.de
The documented features run to finances, document storage, listings and market analysis, and we found no public information on defect intake, recurring statutory inspections such as lift, heating, fire safety or drinking water, contractor work orders, or stored proof of completion. The building side is the core of my operation, and the captured pages give me nothing documented to evaluate against it.
Documents, retention & handover
immocloud
Documents sit centrally with automatic organization by object and unit, drag-and-drop upload, unlimited storage on every plan, a document-inbox email address, and financial data leaving via DATEV export. The processing agreement states personal data is deleted three months after the contract ends, with customer download possible before that. We found no public information on version history, stated retention periods, or a structured handover package a successor administrator could load.
vermietet.de
Documents are stored centrally — "Alle Dokumente sicher ablegen" — with document-assistance analysis, templates, and properties held under "Meine Immos". That is basic central storage; we found no public information on search across the archive, version history, retention periods, or a structured handover export a successor administrator could load.
European sovereignty
immocloud
The chain is well evidenced: immocloud GmbH in Düsseldorf as contracting entity under German law, application systems running exclusively on dogado GmbH infrastructure in an ISO 27001-certified German datacenter, a self-serve Article 28 processing agreement with EU standard contractual clauses, and a published subprocessor list with locations. The captured pages give different statements on transfers abroad — the security pages state none occurs, while the processing agreement's subprocessor list names US providers such as Microsoft Corporation and Intuit Mailchimp — so the US touches are disclosed but present.
vermietet.de
The vendor behind these pages is Scout24 SE of Munich, Germany — one proven European element — and we found no public information on hosting location, the contracting entity for subscriptions, a data processing agreement or any subprocessor. A German brand without a documented hosting chain is not something I can put community trust-account data on.
Pricing transparency
immocloud
Four tiers up to 50 units are priced publicly with monthly net figures, 3- or 12-month terms with a 10% discount on the longer one, VAT treatment stated outright, the unit definition given, and the shared inclusions listed. From 50 units upward the Tycoon tier is "Auf Anfrage", letter dispatch and digital rental contracts carry additional costs without published amounts, and we found no public information on setup or migration fees — for a portfolio my size the annual cost is not computable from public pages alone.
vermietet.de
The pricing is public and per-unit: "9,90€ / Monat Grundpreis inkl. einer Wohneinheit" plus "0,99€ / Monat für jede zusätzliche Wohneinheit", with a 30-day all-features trial, no credit card or bank data required, subscription start only after consent, and cancellation at any time. VAT treatment and any setup or migration costs are not shown, which stops me short of deriving a final annual invoice.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
immocloud
vermietet.de
Legal entity
Incorporated in DE
Not determined
Hosting location
EU only
Not determined
Hosting options
Not determined
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Published, self-serve
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not needed, no transfer outside the EU/EEA
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates immocloud higher: 1.5/5 against 0.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick immocloud and 0 pick vermietet.de. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is immocloud or vermietet.de European?
immocloud is European (EU-Made, Germany). vermietet.de is European (EU-Made). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Where do immocloud and vermietet.de store customer data?
Per the vendors’ own pages as captured — immocloud: In the EU; pages mention Germany. vermietet.de: its pages as captured do not say.