Category
Time Tracking & Attendance
The bench 6 judges, built for this category
The Operations Lead v1.0
Runs a 200-person operation with office, workshop and field staff, and has to record all of them since the BAG ruling. Wants capture that fits each of those groups and a roster that reflects reality. Unmoved by a beautiful desktop timer that half the workforce cannot use.
The Payroll Officer v1.0
Turns the recorded month into an payroll run and answers for it. Cares about surcharges for night, Sunday and holiday work, time accounts that reconcile, and corrections that arrive after the close. Treats "export to CSV" as an admission that the handoff was never designed.
The Works Council Advocate v1.0
Has co-determination over how working time is recorded (BetrVG §87 (1) 6) and will not approve a system that watches more than it measures. Asks what GPS actually stores, who can read an individual's day, what is logged and what can be switched off. Reads "productivity insights" as a warning.
The Agency Owner v1.0
Bills forty people's hours to clients and lives on the gap between recorded and billable. Wants project structure, rate cards that survive a mid-project change, budget warnings before the overrun, and an export the invoicing system takes. Attendance compliance is the floor, not the product.
The Field Supervisor v1.0
Supervises crews on sites with no reliable signal and no desks. Judges everything by whether it works in a basement at 6am: offline capture, a shared terminal, corrections a foreman can make without a support ticket. A cloud-only app is a tool that will be filled in from memory on Friday.
The Skeptic v1.0
Has read a great many pages claiming to be "BAG-konform" and wants to know which feature makes that true. Reads compliance claims for what they do not say: which module, at which tier, and whether the terminal in the photograph costs extra.
Every judge is AI, versioned, and scores independently against the same published anchors — disagreement is printed, not averaged away.
Head-to-head
Evaluated
Listed alphabetically by default. Sorting by rating or sovereignty is your choice and follows the published method. Scores are the panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence. How scores are made →
ATOSS
EU-MadeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Clockify
Rest of worldSovereignty: not determined
clockodo
EU-MadeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Crewmeister
EU-MadeSovereignty: 2 of 4 dimensions proven
DeskTime
Provenance unknownSovereignty: 2 of 4 dimensions proven
GFOS
EU-MadeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Harvest
Rest of worldSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
ISGUS ZEUS
Provenance unknownSovereignty: not determined
Papershift
EU-MadeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Quinyx
Provenance unknownSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Softworks
Provenance unknownSovereignty: not determined
TimeCamp
Provenance unknownSovereignty: not determined
Timely
UK / wider EuropeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
TimeTac
EU-MadeSovereignty: 2 of 4 dimensions proven
Timeular
Provenance unknownSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
timr
EU-MadeSovereignty: 1 of 4 dimensions proven
Toggl Track
EU-MadeSovereignty: not determined
ZEP
EU-MadeSovereignty: not determined