As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates Clockify 2.5/5 and Toggl Track 2.5/5 in Time Tracking & Attendance. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Clockify and 0 pick Toggl Track. Clockify scores higher on 4 of 7 criteria (Capture in the real workplace, Working-time law & audit record, Absence & shift planning, plus 1 more). Toggl Track scores higher on 3 of 7 criteria (European sovereignty, Project, cost-centre & billing and Pricing transparency). Provenance — Clockify: Rest of world, United States; Toggl Track: EU-Made, Estonia. Ratings are the AI panel’s opinion, formed from public evidence: how scores are made.
The short answer
The benches split by criterion. Clockify leads time capture 6.0 to 5.0 (6 judges lean its way), working-time law 4.0 to 3.0 (6 lean its way) and absence and planning 4.8 to 4.0 (5 lean its way, 1 tie). Toggl Track takes sovereignty 3.2 to 1.3 with 6 judges leaning its way, its verdict crediting the Estonian entity, processing stated in Estonia, published transfer mechanisms and ISO 27001; Clockify's attributes read US legal-entity jurisdiction, unknown data residency and an EU hosting option its verdict calls Pro-only with no region named. Project and billing mostly ties: means 7.5 vs 7.8, 4 ties, 2 lean Toggl Track. Payroll export splits 3 lean Clockify, 3 tie. Pricing transparency reads 6.3 vs 6.5, 1 lean Toggl Track, 5 ties. Published weighted totals run Clockify ahead on five judges — 5.2/4.7, 4.7/4.3, 4.1/3.7, 5.5/5, 5/4.9 — with one judge's totals not shown.
Choose Clockify if
You need kiosk, timesheet and timer capture with mobile-only offline entry — time capture reads 6.0 vs 5.0 with 6 judges leaning Clockify and 0 against.
Your review weighs German working-time law — Clockify holds 4.0 vs 3.0 with 6 judges leaning its way; its verdict notes the audit log is Enterprise-only and no page names the German recording duty.
You need absence tracking and planning — absence and planning reads 4.8 vs 4.0 with 5 judges leaning Clockify and 1 tie; the verdict notes scheduling appears only as a named feature.
You hand payroll to a named system — payroll export reads 4.5 vs 4.0 with 3 judges leaning Clockify and 3 ties, and QuickBooks is the only named payroll system in its verdict.
You can license the Pro tier for a selectable EU hosting region — Clockify's hosting options read EU region selectable; its verdict states the option is Pro-only, excluded from the bundle, with no region named.
Choose Toggl Track if
Your procurement requires an EU legal entity — Toggl Track's legal-entity jurisdiction reads EE against Clockify's US; sovereignty reads 3.2 vs 1.3 with 6 judges leaning Toggl Track.
You bill rates at client, project, member and task level with effective dates — project and billing reads 7.8 vs 7.5 with 2 judges leaning Toggl Track and 4 ties.
Your security review credits ISO 27001 and published transfer mechanisms — the higher sovereignty scores in Toggl Track's verdict cite these plus processing stated in Estonia.
You work to budgets in hours or fees and want an alert at 80 percent — part of Toggl Track's project-and-billing scoring at 7.8 vs 7.5.
Read this comparison as one judge. Each weighs the same scores by what they care about.
The Skeptic
Has read a great many pages claiming to be "BAG-konform" and wants to know which feature makes that true. Reads compliance claims for what they do not say: which module, at which tier, and whether the terminal in the photograph costs extra.
Clockify
This judge's pick
Toggl Track
Criterion by criterion
Capture in the real workplace
Clockify
Timer, timesheet and manual entry run on web, desktop and mobile, a shared kiosk is offered for clock-in, and offline tracking syncs on reconnect — though the vendor's own mobile page calls offline support a mobile-only feature. GPS tracking sits behind the Pro plan with no stated limits, entries can always be edited and timesheets submitted for approval, but we found no public information on bulk corrections with an audit trail of who changed what, and no hardware terminal or badge reader beyond the kiosk app.
Toggl Track
Timers run on web, desktop, mobile and browser extensions, with manual entries, idle detection, several tracking modes and mobile offline capture that syncs on reconnect; weekly timesheets are submitted, corrected and resubmitted, and approvers flag entries with a note and act in bulk. We found no public information on shared kiosks, terminals, badge readers or GPS/geofenced check-in, so the capture story is built for desk workers rather than site or shift crews.
Working-time law & audit record
Clockify
The attendance report records start, end, break, work time and overtime per user with daily, weekly and monthly capacity models, Standard adds time locking and attendance plus overtime, and a beta TOIL flow converts overtime to time off — that is real record-keeping. But no captured page names the German recording duty or ArbZG, the audit log appears only at Enterprise, and we found no public information on automatic break or rest-period enforcement, maximum-hours warnings, or statutory retention.
Toggl Track
Time entries carry start and end times, reports can be cut per member, and weekly timesheets are approved and locked — the raw material of a working-time record. But we found no public information naming the German recording duty, the BAG ruling or the ArbZG, nor on break recording, statutory rest, maximum-hour warnings or retention of the time record itself, so no conformity claim can be tested from these pages.
Absence & shift planning
Clockify
Time-off policies cover sickness, vacation, half-days and more with configurable approvers, balance and accrual tracking, a shared PTO calendar and a leave timeline — full entitlement-era absence management. Scheduling exists as a Pro feature to plan work, assignments and shifts on a timeline, but we found no public information on shift templates, employee availability, substitution workflows or per-location public-holiday calendars, so the planning half stays thin.
Toggl Track
The Time Off Management add-on (Add-on Time Off Management $2 / per user per month) delivers approvals, balances and policies — fixed yearly, unlimited or monthly accrual, with starting balances seeded in a wizard — plus a balances report, and capacity planning counts PTO and public holidays. We found no public information on sickness recording, carry-over, substitution or any shift or duty roster, and the absence rate is explicitly not adjusted for public holidays or part-time hours.
Project, cost-centre & billing
Clockify
Time books to projects and tasks with billable flags, task rates and budget tracking, and the built-in invoicing module imports only uninvoiced billable time and expenses with three grouping modes, taxes and discounts, recurring invoices and payment recording. Approved entries auto-populate invoices and are marked invoiced, with maintained handoffs into named systems — QuickBooks and a Peppol e-invoicing add-on. We found no public information on cost centres or rate cards by person and role, and budget warnings are not described.
Toggl Track
This is the home ground: billable rates at client, project, member and task level, labour costs with effective dates so a raise does not rewrite last quarter, budgets in hours or fees with an alert at 80%, and invoices generated line-by-line or summarized from reports and sendable to QuickBooks. We found no public information on cost centres or role-based rate cards, and the invoice builder has documented limits — no built-in paid-marking and a fixed layout.
Payroll handoff
Clockify
The QuickBooks Payroll add-on is a real, named handoff — installed from the vendor's marketplace at $6.99 per month for the whole workspace, requiring Standard or higher — but it pushes only name, date, project, duration, description and billable status, and sent entries can never be resent. We found no public information on night, Sunday and holiday surcharges, time-account transfer or a lock step before transmission, no German payroll system is named, and attendance data otherwise leaves as CSV or Excel.
Toggl Track
The handoff is an API to pull time and rate data into whichever system pays your people, CSV exports of hours and the absence report, and an approved, locked timesheet record with configurable submitters, approvers, withdrawal and reminders. We found no public information on DATEV, Lohn und Gehalt, surcharge handling or a documented export format for any specific payroll provider — the system is deliberately unnamed.
European sovereignty
Clockify
The contracting entity is CAKE.com Inc. at 404 Bryant St, San Francisco, and every element the pages prove is American; a data-region choice appears only as a Pro-plan feature excluded from the bundle, with the selectable regions never named, so EU hosting is not confirmed. We found no public information on a data processing agreement or the subprocessor chain on the captured pages.
Toggl Track
Toggl OÜ of Tallinn is the vendor and processing is stated in Estonia, with transfers outside the EEA covered by named mechanisms — adequacy decisions including the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, or Standard Contractual Clauses with transfer impact assessments — and ISO 27001 certification published. We found no public information on a data processing agreement or the hosting data-centre provider, the sub-processor list is referenced but not shown on the pages we read, and the policy names Toggl, Inc. of Delaware as contracting entity for US customers.
Pricing transparency
Clockify
All five tiers carry public per-seat prices in euros and dollars with annual and monthly figures stated, Enterprise included, plus the bundle at €12.99 per seat monthly when billed annually and the QuickBooks add-on at $6.99 per month for the workspace. A buyer still cannot compute the full invoice: the kiosk-only limited users carry a 'separate fee' with no figure anywhere, the captured pages give different figures for the free plan's user limit (up to 5 users in the tier text, unlimited users in the offer description), and VAT treatment and minimum term are not stated.
Toggl Track
Almost every tier and add-on carries a public per-user price with billing period: Free $0, Starter $9 billed annually or $12 billed monthly, Premium $16 or $24, Enterprise contact sales, plus add-ons in Capacity Management $5 annually / $6 monthly and Time Off Management $2 per user per month. VAT treatment and minimum terms are not described, Enterprise has no number, and the captured pages give different figures for the free seat limit — up to 3 users on the pricing page, up to five team members elsewhere.
Sovereignty, side by side
Dimension
Clockify
Toggl Track
Legal entity
Incorporated in US
Incorporated in EE
Hosting location
Not determined
Not determined
Hosting options
EU region selectable
Not determined
Open source
Not determined
Not determined
Data processing agreement
Not determined
Not determined
Transfer impact assessment
Not determined
Not determined
Facts, side by side
Only facts both products carry under the same definition — anything else would not be a fair row.
As of 18 Nov 2026, the panel rates both 2.5/5. Weighted by what each judge cares about, 6 of the 6 judges pick Clockify and 0 pick Toggl Track. Which one fits depends on the criteria that matter to you; the table on this page shows both side by side, and each judge’s reading has its own page. Both were scored by the same AI bench under the same rubric, from public evidence only, as the methodology describes.
Is Clockify or Toggl Track European?
Clockify is not European by provenance (Rest of world, United States). Toggl Track is European (EU-Made, Estonia). Provenance is read from each company’s own legal pages: who builds it and who owns it.
Do Clockify and Toggl Track have a free plan?
As of 18 Nov 2026, both vendors’ own pages state a free plan. Each product page links the pricing page it was read from.